The journalist, the housewife, the citizen and the press
Author:
- 1 August 2007
- journal article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journalism
- Vol. 8 (4) , 449-473
Abstract
The use of sources in news narratives is an extremely important part of not only the story's construction but also of its orientation and, ultimately, the point of view being supported in a given story. The sly deceit concealed within journalists' use of sources as apparently independent and authoritative commentators enables the journalist to masquerade as a mere conveyance of others' perspectives while actually peddling a particular viewpoint by the choice of speaker and the choice of quote. This study interrogates the content of three English regional newspapers over a 10-week period, up to, during and after the British general election in 2005, in order to identify gender differences in the sources used. It argues that, as with the national press, men are more than twice as likely as women to be quoted as sources and that women journalists are no more likely to source women than male colleagues. It concludes that a newsroom culture which privileges elite and other (white) male voices appears to exert a greater influence and conformity over who `counts' as an authoritative voice than any individual newsworker's proclivities to more accurately reflect their views of the diverse local community.Keywords
This publication has 31 references indexed in Scilit:
- Capital Constructions: Newspaper Reporting in Death Penalty CasesAnalyses of Social Issues and Public Policy, 2004
- Stirring up apathy? Political disengagement and the media in the 2003 Welsh Assembly electionsJournal of Public Affairs, 2004
- Talking past each other: Journalists, readers and local newspaper reporting of general election campaigns in the UKJournal of Public Affairs, 2004
- System failure: it's not just the media — the whole political system has failedJournal of Public Affairs, 2004
- A Poverty of VoicesJournalism, 2003
- Reporting on GlobalizationInternational Communication Gazette, 2003
- The Method is the Message: The Current State of Political Communication ResearchPolitical Communication, 2001
- Gender, organizational and professional identities in journalismJournalism, 2000
- Tracking gender differences: A comparative analysis of network correspondents and their sourcesJournal of Broadcasting & Electronic Media, 1997
- The civic role in public journalismNational Civic Review, 1996