Integrated Analysis: Combining Risk and Economic Assessments While Preserving the Separation of Powers
- 27 December 2004
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Risk Analysis
- Vol. 24 (6) , 1613-1623
Abstract
This article presents a process for an integrated policy analysis that combines risk assessment and benefit-cost analysis. This concept, which explicitly combines the two types of related analyses, seems to contradict the long-accepted risk analysis paradigm of separating risk assessment and risk management since benefit-cost analysis is generally considered to be a part of risk management. Yet that separation has become a problem because benefit-cost analysis uses risk assessment results as a starting point and considerable debate over the last several years focused on the incompatibility of the use of upper bounds or "safe" point estimates in many risk assessments with benefit-cost analysis. The problem with these risk assessments is that they ignore probabilistic information. As advanced probabilistic techniques for risk assessment emerge and economic analysts receive distributions of risks instead of point estimates, the artificial separation between risk analysts and the economic/decision analysts complicates the overall analysis. In addition, recent developments in countervailing risk theory suggest that combining the risk and benefit-cost analyses is required to fully understand the complexity of choices and tradeoffs faced by the decisionmaker. This article also argues that the separation of analysis and management is important, but that benefit-cost analysis has been wrongly classified into the risk management category and that the analytical effort associated with understanding the economic impacts of risk reduction actions need to be part of a broader risk assessment process.Keywords
This publication has 8 references indexed in Scilit:
- Value of Information Analysis in Environmental Health Risk Management Decisions: Past, Present, and FutureRisk Analysis, 2004
- Validating Benefit and Cost Estimates: The Case of Airbag RegulationRisk Analysis, 2002
- Variability and Uncertainty Meet Risk Management and Risk CommunicationRisk Analysis, 2002
- Validating analytical judgments: the case of the airbag's lifesaving effectivenessReliability Engineering & System Safety, 1999
- The Value of Improved National Exposure Information for Perchloroethylene (Perc): A Case Study for Dry CleanersRisk Analysis, 1997
- Going beyond the single number: Using probabilistic risk assessment to improve risk managementHuman and Ecological Risk Assessment: An International Journal, 1996
- Risk vs. Risk1995
- Risk Assessment and Risk Management: Their Separation Should Not Mean Divorce1991