KING ARTHUR’S ROUND TABLE, EAMONT BRIDGE, CUMBRIA: THE EXCAVATION OF AN EXCAVATION
Open Access
- 10 September 2025
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in The Antiquaries Journal
- Vol. 105, 296-324
Abstract
In 1937 the philosopher Robin Collingwood excavated a henge monument in Cumbria and identified the postholes of a series of timber buildings, which he compared with those at other sites. These structures at Eamont Bridge were replaced by a stone circle. He planned to continue the work for a second season, but was prevented by illness. His project was completed by the famous German scholar Gerhard Bersu, who concluded that many of the features identified two years earlier were of geological origin; others were rootholes and animal burrows. Their projects have played a part in the history of fieldwork, but in recent years influential researchers have tried to rehabilitate Collingwood’s reputation as an excavator. Their views were encouraged by his pivotal role in studies of the northern frontier of Roman Britain. In 2023 parts of the monument at King Arthur’s Round Table were re-excavated with the aim of settling the dispute. The new work supported Bersu’s interpretation, but recognised that Collingwood’s approach was not as misguided as his critics had supposed – it was directly based on his agenda for historical research. The real problem is that he had been working without sufficient experience on a difficult subsoil. This article considers the methods used by both researchers at King Arthur’s Round Table and compares their distinctive approaches to field archaeology.Keywords
This publication has 8 references indexed in Scilit:
- KING ARTHUR’S ROUND TABLE REVISITED: A REVIEW OF TWO RIVAL INTERPRETATIONS OF A HENGE MONUMENT NEAR PENRITH, IN CUMBRIAThe Antiquaries Journal, 2019
- Making Archaeology Happen2016
- A life in booksJournal of the Royal Anthropological Institute, 2014
- The philosopher and the field archaeologist: Collingwood, Bersu and the excavation of King Arthur's Round TableProceedings of the Prehistoric Society, 1994
- The Penrith Henges: A Survey by the Royal Commission on the Historical Monuments of EnglandProceedings of the Prehistoric Society, 1992
- The excavation of a late Neolithic henge-type enclosure at Balfarg, Markinch, Fife, Scotland, 1977-78Proceedings of the Society of Antiquaries of Scotland, 1982
- British Museum Excavation at Hod Hill, DorsetThe British Museum Quarterly, 1952
- Maiden Castle, Dorset1943