Rethinking ‘Interest’ in Islamic Finance: A Critique of the Method of Fatwâ MUI and Its Legitimacy in Indonesia
Open Access
- 25 April 2025
- journal article
- Published by University of Management and Technology in Journal of Islamic Thought and Civilization
- Vol. 15 (1) , 81-98
Abstract
This article explores the concept of 'interest' as a fundamental issue in Islamic financial practice in Indonesia, with a particular focus on the fatwa issued by the Indonesian Ulema Council (MUI) No. 1/2004, which formalized the prohibition of interest in Islamic financial institutions as harâm activity. The fatwa has sparked criticism and debate among academics and scholars questioning its legitimacy. Also, the method of deriving laws is weak and less affirmative in addressing the socio-economic conditions of the Indonesian people who are used to conventional banks and have not recently intersected with Islamic banks, through a qualitative-normative approach and the collection of primary data from various academic sources that discuss the fatwâ. It was found that the MUI fatwâ relied heavily on normative postulates and used qiyâs, an analogical reasoning method based on legal 'illat (adequate cause), as its primary ijtihâd approach. However, the MUI's methods overlook the socio-economic context. Critical political indications specific to Indonesia can inform a more comprehensive and contextually relevant basis for expressing interest as harâm in financial institutions. The recommendation in this study is the need to review and reassess the arguments underlying the fatwa to align it more closely with the reality of the profit-taking system in financial institutions that is common to the national and global community.Keywords
This publication has 16 references indexed in Scilit:
- The role of religion and social capital on employees’ performance: An empirical study post Indonesia’s Islamic bank mergerCogent Business & Management, 2023
- Ribā and Paying Off Non-stipulated Interest: The Capability to Become a Prevalent Custom (ʿUrf) in Islamic SocietyArab Law Quarterly, 2022
- Islamic Organization and the Perception of riba (Usury) and Conventional Banks Among Muslims: Evidence From IndonesiaSage Open, 2022
- THE VARIANT OF THOUGHT OF THE MUHAMMADIYAH PRICE ELITES IN CONDUCTING USURY AND INTEREST OF BANKHumanities & Social Sciences Reviews, 2019
- Determinant factors of market share: evidence from the Indonesian Islamic banking industryProblems and Perspectives in Management, 2018
- İslâm’daki Faiz Yasağının Temeli Olarak Câhiliye Ribâsı KavramıCumhuriyet İlahiyat Dergisi, 2017
- Analisis Perbandingan Kinerja Keuangan Dan Ekonomi Sosial Bank Syariah Antara Sebelum Dan Sesudah Ditetapkannya Fatwa MUI Tentang Haramnya Bunga BankJurnal Ekonomi Syariah Teori dan Terapan, 2017
- Dinamika Fatwa Bunga Bank di Indonesia: Kajian Terhadap Fatwa MUI, Muhammaddiyah dan Nahdhatul UlamaMedia Syari'ah : Wahana Kajian Hukum Islam dan Pranata Sosial, 2012
- A History of Islamic Legal Theories1997
- Islamic Banking and Interest1996