The Bulletproof Glass Effect: Unintended Consequences of Privacy Notices
Authors:
- Aaron R. BroughABAaron R. Brough
- David A. NortonDNDavid A. Norton
- Shannon L. SciarappaSSShannon L. Sciarappa
- Leslie K. JohnLJLeslie K. John
- 18 February 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Marketing Research
- Vol. 59 (4) , 739-754
Abstract
Drawing from a content analysis of publicly-traded companies’ privacy notices, a survey of managers, a field study, and five online experiments, this research investigates how consumers respond to privacy notices. A privacy notice, by placing legally-enforceable limits on a firm’s data practices, communicating safeguards, and signaling transparency, might be expected to promote confidence that personal data will not be misused. Indeed, most managers expected a privacy notice to make customers feel more secure (Study 1). Yet, consistent with the analogy that bulletproof glass can increase feelings of vulnerability despite the protection offered, formal privacy notices undermined consumer trust and decreased purchase interest even when they emphasized objective protection (Studies 2, 3, and 5) or omitted any mention of potentially concerning data practices (Study 6). These unintended consequences did not occur, however, when consumers had an a priori reason to be distrustful (Study 4) or when benevolence cues were added to privacy notices (Studies 5-6). Finally, Study 7 showed that both the presence and conspicuous absence of privacy information are sufficient to trigger decreased purchase intent. Together, these results provide actionable guidance to managers on how to effectively convey privacy information (without hurting purchase interest).Keywords
This publication has 79 references indexed in Scilit:
- What Is Privacy Worth?The Journal of Legal Studies, 2013
- Diminished or Just Different? A Factorial Vignette Study of Privacy as a Social ContractJournal of Business Ethics, 2012
- Trust considerations on attitudes towards online purchasing: The moderating effect of privacy and security concernsJournal of Business Research, 2010
- Perceived Ethicality of Insurance Claim Fraud: Do Higher Deductibles Lead to Lower Ethical Standards?Journal of Business Ethics, 2008
- Should we ask our children about sex, drugs and rock & roll? Potentially harmful effects of asking questions about risky behaviorsJournal of Consumer Psychology, 2008
- Building online trust through privacy practicesInternational Journal of Information Security, 2007
- An Integrative Model of Organizational Trust: Past, Present, and FutureAcademy of Management Review, 2007
- Internet Seals of Approval: Effects on Online Privacy Policies and Consumer PerceptionsJournal of Consumer Affairs, 2002
- Not So Different After All: A Cross-Discipline View Of TrustAcademy of Management Review, 1998
- Individual differences in intuitive–experiential and analytical–rational thinking styles.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1996