Aaron R. Brough
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Aaron R. Brough has a total of 22 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Mathew S. Isaac
Albers School of Business and Economics, Seattle University, Seattle, USA
3 shared publications - Alexander Chernev1 shared publication
- Ana Isabel Canhoto
University of Sussex
1 shared publication Antje R.H. Graul
1 shared publication- Antje Ricarda Helena Graul
Utah State University, Logan, UT, USA
1 shared publication Bernadette Kamleitner
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 14 September 2026
- Published by Wiley in Consumer Psychology Review
When the Vault is Never Opened: AI‐Enabled Inference and the Future of Consumer Privacy
Most research on consumer privacy assumes that privacy risks stem from unauthorized access to or misuse of sensitive consumer data. This review highlights the need to reassess consumer privacy in response to two ways in which artificial intelligence (AI) is transforming consumer privacy risk. First, AI widens the gap between what consumers intentionally reveal and what can be inferred about sensitive attributes from seemingly nonsensitive information. This increases the risk that privacy harm may arise even when sensitive data were never requested, disclosed, or accessed but instead inferred. Second, AI expands inferential capacity beyond firms to other consumers and non‐firm actors, increasing the risk of interpersonal privacy violations. Building on these arguments, I illustrate five types of AI‐enabled privacy harm and show how each can arise across organizational and interpersonal contexts. Given consumers' limited ability to anticipate, observe, or control AI‐enabled inferences or their consequences, these emerging risks create new challenges for privacy theory, management, and regulation while raising important questions for future research on consumer privacy.
- 14 September 2026
- Published by Wiley in Consumer Psychology Review
When the Vault is Never Opened: AI‐Enabled Inference and the Future of Consumer Privacy
Most research on consumer privacy assumes that privacy risks stem from unauthorized access to or misuse of sensitive consumer data. This review highlights the need to reassess consumer privacy in response to two ways in which artificial intelligence (AI) is transforming consumer privacy risk. First, AI widens the gap between what consumers intentionally reveal and what can be inferred about sensitive attributes from seemingly nonsensitive information. This increases the risk that privacy harm may arise even when sensitive data were never requested, disclosed, or accessed but instead inferred. Second, AI expands inferential capacity beyond firms to other consumers and non‐firm actors, increasing the risk of interpersonal privacy violations. Building on these arguments, I illustrate five types of AI‐enabled privacy harm and show how each can arise across organizational and interpersonal contexts. Given consumers' limited ability to anticipate, observe, or control AI‐enabled inferences or their consequences, these emerging risks create new challenges for privacy theory, management, and regulation while raising important questions for future research on consumer privacy.
- 12 September 2023
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of International Marketing
- Vol. 31 (4) , 76-79
Physical and Digital Privacy: How Developed and Developing Countries Differ in Both Vulnerability and Protection
- 12 September 2023
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of International Marketing
- Vol. 31 (4) , 76-79
Physical and Digital Privacy: How Developed and Developing Countries Differ in Both Vulnerability and Protection
- 18 February 2022
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Marketing Research
- Vol. 59 (4) , 739-754
The Bulletproof Glass Effect: Unintended Consequences of Privacy Notices
Drawing from a content analysis of publicly-traded companies’ privacy notices, a survey of managers, a field study, and five online experiments, this research investigates how consumers respond to privacy notices. A privacy notice, by placing legally-enforceable limits on a firm’s data practices, communicating safeguards, and signaling transparency, might be expected to promote confidence that personal data will not be misused. Indeed, most managers expected a privacy notice to make customers feel more secure (Study 1). Yet, consistent with the analogy that bulletproof glass can increase feelings of vulnerability despite the protection offered, formal privacy notices undermined consumer trust and decreased purchase interest even when they emphasized objective protection (Studies 2, 3, and 5) or omitted any mention of potentially concerning data practices (Study 6). These unintended consequences did not occur, however, when consumers had an a priori reason to be distrustful (Study 4) or when benevolence cues were added to privacy notices (Studies 5-6). Finally, Study 7 showed that both the presence and conspicuous absence of privacy information are sufficient to trigger decreased purchase intent. Together, these results provide actionable guidance to managers on how to effectively convey privacy information (without hurting purchase interest).
- 18 February 2022
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Marketing Research
- Vol. 59 (4) , 739-754
The Bulletproof Glass Effect: Unintended Consequences of Privacy Notices
Drawing from a content analysis of publicly-traded companies’ privacy notices, a survey of managers, a field study, and five online experiments, this research investigates how consumers respond to privacy notices. A privacy notice, by placing legally-enforceable limits on a firm’s data practices, communicating safeguards, and signaling transparency, might be expected to promote confidence that personal data will not be misused. Indeed, most managers expected a privacy notice to make customers feel more secure (Study 1). Yet, consistent with the analogy that bulletproof glass can increase feelings of vulnerability despite the protection offered, formal privacy notices undermined consumer trust and decreased purchase interest even when they emphasized objective protection (Studies 2, 3, and 5) or omitted any mention of potentially concerning data practices (Study 6). These unintended consequences did not occur, however, when consumers had an a priori reason to be distrustful (Study 4) or when benevolence cues were added to privacy notices (Studies 5-6). Finally, Study 7 showed that both the presence and conspicuous absence of privacy information are sufficient to trigger decreased purchase intent. Together, these results provide actionable guidance to managers on how to effectively convey privacy information (without hurting purchase interest).
- 1 February 2022
- Published by Elsevier in Journal of Business Research
- Vol. 139, 1211-1217
How emotional attachment influences lender participation in consumer-to-consumer rental platforms
- 1 February 2022
- Published by Elsevier in Journal of Business Research
- Vol. 139, 1211-1217
How emotional attachment influences lender participation in consumer-to-consumer rental platforms
- Open Access
- 27 January 2022
- Published by SAGE Publications in Social Marketing Quarterly
- Vol. 28 (1) , 78-86
The Pandemic-Induced Personal Data Explosion
Background: Government and private responses to the COVID-19 pandemic resulted in the generation and dissemination of personal data not previously available in the public sphere. Focus of the Article: This “Notes from the Field” paper reflects on the implications of this surge of new data for the study and practice of social marketing. The paper examines how this phenomenon impacts on the following aspects of social marketing: (1) Setting of explicit social goals; (2) citizen orientation and focus; (3) value proposition delivery via the social marketing intervention mix; (4) theory-, insight-, data-, and evidence-informed audience segmentation; (5) competition/barrier and asset analysis; and (6) critical thinking, reflexivity, and being ethical. Research Question: How are the government and private responses to the pandemic shaping the generation and use of personal data, and what are the implications of this eruption of data for the social marketing scholarly community? Approach: The paper highlights how the pandemic resulted in significant changes in behavior of government and citizens alike, and how these changes, in turn, spurred the generation and dissemination of new personal data. Subsequently, we draw on the Core Social Marketing Concepts framework to explore how the aforementioned data explosion impacts on the six dimensions of this central framework. Importance to the Social Marketing Field: The COVID-19 pandemic is more than a temporary public health event. Therefore, it is important to consider the lasting consequences that may stem from the pandemic-induced personal data explosion, for both consumers and social marketing scholars and practitioners. Methods: This paper comments on a topical matter, and discusses its implications for the social marketing community. Results: We find that the data explosion creates conflicting social marketing goals, and that inequalities in access to digital technology are increasingly impacting what voices are heard, and which concerns are prioritized. Moreover, new innovations may be enabled or needed, leading to the improvement of firms' ability to create value for individual citizens; the creation of new datasets—particularly among demographics that previously had a limited digital footprint—enhances the ability to segment markets and target social marketing activities. Furthermore, the pandemic-induced data explosion may lead to the identification of additional barriers to positive social behaviors that have emerged, diminished, or even disappeared during the pandemic; but researchers need to critically examine the consequences of the government and private behaviors at the macro, meso, and micro levels. Recommendations for Research or Practice: We propose a research agenda for the social marketing community, consisting of 21 research questions. Limitations: Our analysis focuses on the behavior of government and citizens in North America and Western Europe.
- 27 January 2022
- Published by SAGE Publications in Social Marketing Quarterly
- Vol. 28 (1) , 78-86
Open AccessThe Pandemic-Induced Personal Data Explosion
Background: Government and private responses to the COVID-19 pandemic resulted in the generation and dissemination of personal data not previously available in the public sphere. Focus of the Article: This “Notes from the Field” paper reflects on the implications of this surge of new data for the study and practice of social marketing. The paper examines how this phenomenon impacts on the following aspects of social marketing: (1) Setting of explicit social goals; (2) citizen orientation and focus; (3) value proposition delivery via the social marketing intervention mix; (4) theory-, insight-, data-, and evidence-informed audience segmentation; (5) competition/barrier and asset analysis; and (6) critical thinking, reflexivity, and being ethical. Research Question: How are the government and private responses to the pandemic shaping the generation and use of personal data, and what are the implications of this eruption of data for the social marketing scholarly community? Approach: The paper highlights how the pandemic resulted in significant changes in behavior of government and citizens alike, and how these changes, in turn, spurred the generation and dissemination of new personal data. Subsequently, we draw on the Core Social Marketing Concepts framework to explore how the aforementioned data explosion impacts on the six dimensions of this central framework. Importance to the Social Marketing Field: The COVID-19 pandemic is more than a temporary public health event. Therefore, it is important to consider the lasting consequences that may stem from the pandemic-induced personal data explosion, for both consumers and social marketing scholars and practitioners. Methods: This paper comments on a topical matter, and discusses its implications for the social marketing community. Results: We find that the data explosion creates conflicting social marketing goals, and that inequalities in access to digital technology are increasingly impacting what voices are heard, and which concerns are prioritized. Moreover, new innovations may be enabled or needed, leading to the improvement of firms' ability to create value for individual citizens; the creation of new datasets—particularly among demographics that previously had a limited digital footprint—enhances the ability to segment markets and target social marketing activities. Furthermore, the pandemic-induced data explosion may lead to the identification of additional barriers to positive social behaviors that have emerged, diminished, or even disappeared during the pandemic; but researchers need to critically examine the consequences of the government and private behaviors at the macro, meso, and micro levels. Recommendations for Research or Practice: We propose a research agenda for the social marketing community, consisting of 21 research questions. Limitations: Our analysis focuses on the behavior of government and citizens in North America and Western Europe.
- 10 November 2020
- Published by SAGE Publications in Social Marketing Quarterly
- Vol. 26 (4) , 309-324
Understanding How Sustainability Initiatives Fail: A Framework to Aid Design of Effective Interventions
Many sustainability initiatives are successful and produce results that benefit the environment. However, others miss the mark and fail to produce the desired outcome. Past research has typically focused on understanding why initiatives fail, without first considering differences in how they fail. This manuscript is related to Research and Evaluation—specifically, the social marketing concept it focuses on is evaluating the outcome of sustainability initiatives. What are the different ways in which sustainability initiatives can fail? A multi-day workshop of interdisciplinary behavioral sustainability scholars led to the identification of five systematic differences in how sustainability initiatives can fail, suggesting that failure can take on not only different levels of severity, but different forms altogether. Within this framework, we provide examples of each type of failure. We argue that diagnosing how instead of just why an initiative fails offers important insights that can reduce the likelihood of future failures—insights that may be missed by a narrow focus on the why behind any given failure. The identification of the different ways in which sustainability initiatives fail can lead to improvements in the design and implementation of behavioral interventions, facilitating successful sustainability outcomes and preventing unintended outcomes. Specific recommendations are discussed for each type of failure. The examples in our framework are not exhaustive, but are instead intended to be illustrative exemplars of each type of failure. Moreover, as our focus is on how sustainability initiatives fail, we do not attempt to diagnose why particular initiatives fail.
- 10 November 2020
- Published by SAGE Publications in Social Marketing Quarterly
- Vol. 26 (4) , 309-324
Understanding How Sustainability Initiatives Fail: A Framework to Aid Design of Effective Interventions
Many sustainability initiatives are successful and produce results that benefit the environment. However, others miss the mark and fail to produce the desired outcome. Past research has typically focused on understanding why initiatives fail, without first considering differences in how they fail. This manuscript is related to Research and Evaluation—specifically, the social marketing concept it focuses on is evaluating the outcome of sustainability initiatives. What are the different ways in which sustainability initiatives can fail? A multi-day workshop of interdisciplinary behavioral sustainability scholars led to the identification of five systematic differences in how sustainability initiatives can fail, suggesting that failure can take on not only different levels of severity, but different forms altogether. Within this framework, we provide examples of each type of failure. We argue that diagnosing how instead of just why an initiative fails offers important insights that can reduce the likelihood of future failures—insights that may be missed by a narrow focus on the why behind any given failure. The identification of the different ways in which sustainability initiatives fail can lead to improvements in the design and implementation of behavioral interventions, facilitating successful sustainability outcomes and preventing unintended outcomes. Specific recommendations are discussed for each type of failure. The examples in our framework are not exhaustive, but are instead intended to be illustrative exemplars of each type of failure. Moreover, as our focus is on how sustainability initiatives fail, we do not attempt to diagnose why particular initiatives fail.
- 13 September 2020
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Consumer Psychology
- Vol. 31 (2) , 329-341
Why We Don't Rent What Others Love: The Role of Product Attachment in Consumer‐to‐Consumer Transactions
When listing a possession for rent on a consumer‐to‐consumer platform, owners typically write a brief product description. Such descriptions often include attachment cues—indications that the owner is emotionally attached to the product. How does knowing that an owner is sharing a possession that has sentimental value impact rental likelihood? Evidence from secondary data and four experiments suggests that although some owners mistakenly expect attachment cues to enhance a product's appeal, attachment cues instead tend to deter prospective renters. We attribute this effect to renters' desire to avoid the responsibility of protecting (e.g., from damage, loss, or theft) an item to which the owner is emotionally attached. Whereas prior research has examined how product attachment influences owners' decisions, we show how an owners' expression of attachment affects others involved in a transaction. By refuting the lay theories of some owners about how to attract renters, our findings provide practical implications for owners and the platforms that connect them to users in the multi‐billion‐dollar consumer‐to‐consumer rental market.
- 13 September 2020
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Consumer Psychology
- Vol. 31 (2) , 329-341
Why We Don't Rent What Others Love: The Role of Product Attachment in Consumer‐to‐Consumer Transactions
When listing a possession for rent on a consumer‐to‐consumer platform, owners typically write a brief product description. Such descriptions often include attachment cues—indications that the owner is emotionally attached to the product. How does knowing that an owner is sharing a possession that has sentimental value impact rental likelihood? Evidence from secondary data and four experiments suggests that although some owners mistakenly expect attachment cues to enhance a product's appeal, attachment cues instead tend to deter prospective renters. We attribute this effect to renters' desire to avoid the responsibility of protecting (e.g., from damage, loss, or theft) an item to which the owner is emotionally attached. Whereas prior research has examined how product attachment influences owners' decisions, we show how an owners' expression of attachment affects others involved in a transaction. By refuting the lay theories of some owners about how to attract renters, our findings provide practical implications for owners and the platforms that connect them to users in the multi‐billion‐dollar consumer‐to‐consumer rental market.
- Open Access
- 28 May 2020
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Public Policy & Marketing
- Vol. 40 (1) , 108-110
Consumer Privacy During (and After) the COVID-19 Pandemic
- 28 May 2020
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Public Policy & Marketing
- Vol. 40 (1) , 108-110
Open AccessConsumer Privacy During (and After) the COVID-19 Pandemic
- 1 February 2020
- Published by Elsevier in Current Opinion in Psychology
- Vol. 31, 11-15
Critical roles of knowledge and motivation in privacy research
- 1 February 2020
- Published by Elsevier in Current Opinion in Psychology
- Vol. 31, 11-15
Critical roles of knowledge and motivation in privacy research
- 1 June 2016
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Marketing Research
- Vol. 53 (3) , 338-353
Is Top 10 Better than Top 9? The Role of Expectations in Consumer Response to Imprecise Rank Claims
Many marketing communications are carefully designed to cast a brand in its most favorable light. For example, marketers may prefer to highlight a brand's membership in the top 10 tier of a third-party list instead of disclosing the brand's exact rank. The authors propose that when marketers use these types of imprecise advertising claims, subtle differences in the selection of a tier boundary (e.g., top 9 vs. top 10) can influence consumers’ evaluations and willingness to pay. Specifically, the authors find a comfort tier effect in which a weaker claim that references a less exclusive but commonly used tier boundary can actually lead to higher brand evaluations than a stronger claim that references a more exclusive but less common tier boundary. This effect is attributed to a two-stage process by which consumers evaluate imprecise rank claims. The results demonstrate that consumers have specific expectations for how messages are constructed in marketing communications and may make negative inferences about a brand when these expectations are violated, thus attenuating the positive effect such claims might otherwise have on consumer responses.
- 1 June 2016
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Marketing Research
- Vol. 53 (3) , 338-353
Is Top 10 Better than Top 9? The Role of Expectations in Consumer Response to Imprecise Rank Claims
Many marketing communications are carefully designed to cast a brand in its most favorable light. For example, marketers may prefer to highlight a brand's membership in the top 10 tier of a third-party list instead of disclosing the brand's exact rank. The authors propose that when marketers use these types of imprecise advertising claims, subtle differences in the selection of a tier boundary (e.g., top 9 vs. top 10) can influence consumers’ evaluations and willingness to pay. Specifically, the authors find a comfort tier effect in which a weaker claim that references a less exclusive but commonly used tier boundary can actually lead to higher brand evaluations than a stronger claim that references a more exclusive but less common tier boundary. This effect is attributed to a two-stage process by which consumers evaluate imprecise rank claims. The results demonstrate that consumers have specific expectations for how messages are constructed in marketing communications and may make negative inferences about a brand when these expectations are violated, thus attenuating the positive effect such claims might otherwise have on consumer responses.