Basic inferences of scientific reasoning, argumentation, and discovery
Open Access
- 28 May 2009
- journal article
- issues and-trends
- Published by Wiley in Science Education
- Vol. 94 (2) , 336-364
Abstract
Helping students better understand how scientists reason and argue to draw scientific conclusions has long been viewed as a critical component of scientific literacy, thus remains a central goal of science instruction. However, differences of opinion persist regarding the nature of scientific reasoning, argumentation, and discovery. Accordingly, the primary goal of this paper is to employ the inferences of abduction, retroduction, deduction, and induction to introduce a pattern of scientific reasoning, argumentation, and discovery that is postulated to be universal, thus can serve as an instructional framework to improve student reasoning and argumentative skills. The paper first analyzes three varied and presumably representative case histories in terms of the four inferences (i.e., Galileo's discovery of Jupiter's moons, Rosemary and Peter Grants' research on Darwin's finches, and Marshall Nirenberg's Nobel Prize–winning research on genetic coding). Each case history reveals a pattern of reasoning and argumentation used during explanation testing that can be summarized in anIf/then/Thereforeform. The paper then summarizes additional cases also exemplary of the form. Implications of the resulting theory are discussed in terms of improving the quality of research and classroom instruction. © 2009 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.Sci Ed94:336–364, 2010Keywords
This publication has 29 references indexed in Scilit:
- Contextual epistemic development in science: A comparison of chemistry students and research chemistsScience Education, 2006
- Allchin's errors and misrepresentations and the H-D nature of scienceScience Education, 2006
- What is the role of induction and deduction in reasoning and scientific inquiry?Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 2005
- TAPping into argumentation: Developments in the application of Toulmin's Argument Pattern for studying science discourseScience Education, 2004
- Gregor Mendel and ?myth-conceptions?Science Education, 2004
- Sound and faulty arguments generated by preservice biology teachers when testing hypotheses involving unobservable entities*Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 2002
- Development of Scientific Reasoning in College Biology: Do Two Levels of General Hypothesis-Testing Skills Exist?Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 2000
- The place of argumentation in the pedagogy of school scienceInternational Journal of Science Education, 1999
- Whose nature of science?Journal of Research in Science Teaching, 1997
- Neural principles of memory and a neural theory of analogical insightJournal of Research in Science Teaching, 1993