The empirical turn and its consequences for theoretical syntax
Author:
- 1 June 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Walter de Gruyter GmbH in Theoretical Linguistics
- Vol. 50 (1-2) , 5-21
Abstract
In a pioneer paper, Featherston (Featherston, Sam. 2007. Data in generative grammar: The stick and the carrot. Theoretical Linguistics 33. 269–318) advocated the use of better controlled data in theoretical linguistics. Despite diverging on many aspects, most syntactic theories are now testing their hypotheses with more data than a few linguists’ intuitions. I will examine the consequences of this empirical turn on two syntactic phenomena: long-distance dependencies (LDD) and ellipsis. In a series of recent experiments (Liu, Yingtong, Elodie Winckel, Anne Abeillé, Barbara Hemforth & Edward Gibson. 2022. Structural, functional and processing perspectives on linguistic islands effects. Annual Review of Linguistics 8. 495–525), most of the syntactic constraints (‘island constraints’) on LDD have shown less crosslinguistic variation and more cross-construction variation than previously thought. Corpus and experimental data have also shown elliptical clauses to be more flexible than expected under deletion-under-identity theories (Poppels, Till. 2022. Explaining ellipsis without identity. The Linguistic Review 39. 341–400). These are challenges for most syntactic theories, which call for taking discourse factors more seriously into account.Keywords
This publication has 58 references indexed in Scilit:
- Extraction from subjects: Differences in acceptability depend on the discourse function of the constructionCognition, 2020
- Investigating variation in island effectsNatural Language & Linguistic Theory, 2017
- Lexical‐Functional Syntax2015
- Experimental syntax and the variation of island effects in English and ItalianNatural Language & Linguistic Theory, 2015
- On the grammar of extraction and coordinationNatural Language & Linguistic Theory, 2012
- Processing elided verb phrases with flawed antecedents: The recycling hypothesisJournal of Memory and Language, 2006
- Treebanks2003
- ‘Long’ WH-Movements and Referentiality1996
- Coordination and how to distinguish categoriesNatural Language & Linguistic Theory, 1985
- The syntax and semantics of english relative clausesLingua, 1981