Pricing with Customer (Internal vs External) Purchase Records

Authors:

Abstract
Problem Definition: Firms increasingly use customer purchase-record information to implement price discrimination. Some firms adopt a moderate acquisition strategy, relying only on their internal purchase records to distinguish first-time from repurchasing customers, while others pursue a more aggressive strategy by further tracking customers' external purchase records with rivals and offering tailored discounts to competitors' customers. These observations raise a fundamental question: in competitive markets, what drives firms to adopt different purchase record acquisition strategies? Methodology/Results: We develop a stylized two-period model in which two firms compete, products are horizontally differentiated, and customers make purchases in both periods. Firms determine their strategies for acquiring customer purchase records: no acquisition, internal acquisition, or external acquisition; each acquisition strategy corresponds to a different pricing approach. We show that purchase-record acquisition has a non-monotonic effect on firms' competitive dynamics. In particular, while the transition from no acquisition to internal acquisition softens price competition, the transition from internal acquisition to external acquisition intensifies price competition. In equilibrium, we identify customer farsightedness as a key driver of firms' acquisition strategies. Both firms choose to acquire only internal records when customers are mildly farsighted, whereas they acquire external records from each other when customers are highly farsighted. When customer farsightedness falls within an intermediate range, the two firms adopt asymmetric acquisition strategies---one acquires internal records while the other acquires external records---despite being ex ante symmetric. This differentiation leads the two firms to reward different customer types and derive their profits primarily from different periods. Managerial Implications: Aggressively acquiring customers' purchase records from rivals does not necessarily generate higher profits, and acquiring only internal records can be rewarding. When facing a rival's internal or external acquisition strategy, a firm can respond with an alternative strategy, which mitigates competition and enables both firms to extract customer surplus at different stages of the customer lifecycle.