Context is key: A comment on Herczeg et al. 2019
- 17 August 2019
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Journal of Evolutionary Biology
- Vol. 32 (12) , 1444-1449
Abstract
In the last several years, there has been a surge in the number of studies addressing the causes and consequences of among‐individual variation in cognitive ability and behavioural plasticity. Here, we use a recent publication by Herczeg et al. (2019: 32(3), 218–226) to highlight three shortcomings common to this newly emerging field. In their study, Herczeg et al. attempted to link variation in cognitive ability and behavioural plasticity by testing whether selection lines of guppies (Poecilia reticulata) that differ in relative brain size also differ in behavioural plasticity, as might be expected if the costs to plasticity are predominantly derived from the cost of developing large brains. First, residual brain size may not be a suitable proxy for ‘cognitive ability’. Recent work has shown that intraspecific variation in cognitive ability can be better understood by considering variation in the specific brain areas responsible for the relevant behaviours as opposed to whole‐brain mass. Second, the measure of behavioural plasticity, habituation, is unlikely to fulfil the assumptions that plasticity is both adaptive and costly. Finally, we point out several misconceptions regarding animal personality that continue to contribute to the choice of traits that are not well aligned with study objectives. Elucidating the mechanisms underlying among‐individual variation in cognition and behavioural plasticity within populations requires integration between behavioural ecology and comparative cognition, and the study system developed by Herczeg et al. has the potential to provide important mechanistic insights. We hope that by articulating and critically appraising the underlying assumptions that are common in these traditionally separate disciplines, a strong foundation can emerge to allow for more fruitful integration of these fields.Keywords
This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit:
- On the usage of single measurements in behavioural ecology research on individual differencesAnimal Behaviour, 2018
- Numbers of neurons as biological correlates of cognitive capabilityCurrent Opinion in Behavioral Sciences, 2017
- Hippocampus and Spatial Memory in Brood Parasitic Cowbirds2017
- Habituation and sensitization: new thoughts about old ideasAnimal Behaviour, 2016
- An overview of the evolutionary causes and consequences of behavioural plasticityAnimal Behaviour, 2013
- How does variation in the environment and individual cognition explain the existence of consistent behavioral differences?Ecology and Evolution, 2012
- Elevation-related differences in memory and the hippocampus in mountain chickadees, Poecile gambeliAnimal Behaviour, 2012
- Are Bigger Brains Better?Current Biology, 2009
- Habituation revisited: An updated and revised description of the behavioral characteristics of habituationNeurobiology of Learning and Memory, 2009
- The social brain hypothesisEvolutionary Anthropology: Issues, News, and Reviews, 1998