Things We Lost in the Fire: How Different Types of Contestation Affect the Robustness of International Norms
Authors:
Top Cited Papers
Open Access
- 31 December 2018
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in International Studies Review
- Vol. 22 (1) , 51-76
Abstract
Contestation of international norms has become the new focus of IR norm research. The optimism of the 1990s that fundamental liberal norms would diffuse globally has remained unfulfilled in recent years—even human rights norms have witnessed strong contestation. Time and again, controversy has erupted regarding international norms such as the ban on torture or the Responsibility to Protect. Meanwhile, we know little about how such controversy affects the robustness of norms—whether it contributes to their weakening or to their strengthening. Existing research offers two competing hypotheses: One branch of norm research often conceptualizes contestation as a sign of norm weakening. By contrast, another branch assigns contestation a normative power of its own, which strengthens norms. It does not specify the limits of such normative power, however. In this article, we argue that contestation per se is a poor predictor of norm robustness. The type of contestation a norm faces matters. Contestation can either (1) address the dimension of application of a norm or (2) examine its validity by questioning the righteousness of the claims a norm makes. The article draws on two illustrative case studies of extensively contested norms, the Responsibility to Protect and the ban on commercial whaling. We argue that widespread contestation of the very validity of a norm is likely to lead to a loss of norm robustness. Applicatory contestation, by contrast, can—under specific circumstances—even strengthen it.Keywords
This publication has 88 references indexed in Scilit:
- Almost Saving Whales: The Ambiguity of Success at the International Whaling CommissionEthics & International Affairs, 2012
- Moratoria in International Politics: A Comparative Analysis of the Moratoria on Genetically Modified Products and Commercial WhalingThe British Journal of Politics and International Relations, 2011
- Why international norms disappear sometimesEuropean Journal of International Relations, 2011
- Realizing the Responsibility to ProtectInternational Studies Perspectives, 2009
- The Discursive Process of Legalization: Charting Islands of Persuasion in the ICC CaseInternational Organization, 2009
- The Responsibility to Protect: An Idea Whose Time Has Come … and Gone?International Relations, 2008
- The Responsibility to Protect Doctrine and Humanitarian Intervention: Too Many Ambiguities for a Working DoctrineJournal of Conflict and Security Law, 2008
- Normalization of the International Whaling CommissionMarine Policy, 2008
- The agent-structure problem in international relations theoryInternational Organization, 1987
- International organization: a state of the art on an art of the stateInternational Organization, 1986