Abstract
Does the European Court of Justice respond to political division authoritatively or cautiously? The existing literature suggests the former but this article, surveying 920 free movement of persons judgments, suggests the latter: the Court issues fewer legally weighty decisions about the substance and the scope of the application of rights, principles, and the limits of European competence (audacious judgments) in times of uneven political support while also disproportionately increasing chamber size. The findings cast the Court as a selectively audacious lawmaker, primarily concerned with procedural legitimacy. They nuance the established narrative of the Court as able and willing to make law in times of political stalemate and legislative paralysis. More broadly, the article suggests that courts do not make policy in lieu of legislators when and because they can but avoid policymaking if and until they can.