Abstract
XFOIL is widely used for preliminary aerodynamic screening and optimization of low-Reynolds-number airfoils because it combines low computational cost with viscous-inviscid interaction and transition modeling. Optimization studies usually look for performance improvements from the maximum lift-to-drag ratio stored in a polar, but the convergence history of angle-of-attack sequence is rarely addressed explicitly. In this study we perform a convergence aware reproducibility audit of five low Reynolds number wind turbine airfoils (E387, RG15, BW-3, SD6060 and S2055) and their previously proposed modified geometries. One hundred XFOIL cases were examined over Re = 1×10 5 to 1×10 6 , angles of attack from 0° to 10° by steps of 0.5°. Raw polar files, lift to drag data, geometry files, input scripts and complete solver logs were cross checked point by point. We introduced a peak-reliability framework to distinguish between complete sweeps (all 21 operating points were available), incomplete polars with local maximum resolved, peak uncertain runs with failed neighboring operating point and invalid runs in which no meaningful optimum was found. Only 59 of the 100 sweeps had all 21 intended operating points and 102 top-level operating-point VISCAL convergence failures were found but 95 cases still had a resolved local peak neighborhood. Of the 50 baseline-to-modified performance comparisons: 45 were reliable; three were peak uncertain; two were invalid. All 30 comparisons for RG15, S2055 and SD6060 were reliable whereas BW-3 and E387 contained critical failures. At Re =106 rerun gains were 17.20%, 17.90%, 23.95%, 67.80% and an observed 15.18% for RG15, S2055, SD6060, BW-3 and E387 respectively compared with previously reported values of 16.81%, 17.82%, 21.73%, 74.26% and 22.81%. The results show that the largest stored CL/CD value should not be interpreted automatically as a resolved aerodynamic optimum and pointwise convergence information should be retained and reported in low Reynolds number XFOIL optimization studies.