Assessing the Physiological Relevance of Cough Simulators for Respiratory Droplet Dispersion
Open Access
- 17 September 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by MDPI AG in Journal of Clinical Medicine
- Vol. 9 (9) , 3002
Abstract
Various breathing and cough simulators have been used to model respiratory droplet dispersion and viral droplets, in particular for SARS-CoV-2 modeling. However, limited data are available comparing these cough simulations to physiological breathing and coughing. In this study, three different cough simulators (Teleflex Mucosal Atomization Device Nasal (MAD Nasal), a spray gun, and GloGermTM MIST) that have been used in the literature were studied to assess their physiologic relevance. Droplet size, velocity, dispersion, and force generated by the simulators were measured. Droplet size was measured with scanning electron microscopy (SEM). Slow-motion videography was used to 3D reconstruct and measure the velocity of each simulated cough. A force-sensitive resistor was used to measure the force of each simulated cough. The average size of droplets from each cough simulator was 176 to 220 µm. MAD Nasal, the spray gun, and GloGermTM MIST traveled 0.38 m, 0.89 m, and 1.62 m respectively. The average velocities for the MAD Nasal, spray gun, and GloGermTM MIST were 1.57 m/s, 2.60 m/s, and 9.27 m/s respectively, and all yielded a force of TM MIST and the spray gun most closely resemble physiological coughs and breathing respectively. In conclusion, none of the simulators tested accurately modeled all physiologic characteristics (droplet size, 3-D dispersion velocity, and force) of a cough, while there were various strengths and weaknesses of each method. One should take this into account when performing simulations with these devices.Keywords
Funding Information
- National Institutes of Health (DP2 HL137187, R21 AG065776, K08EY030510)
- National Science Foundation (#1845683)
- University of California Tobacco Related-Disease Research Program (TRDRP) under Emergency COVID-19 Research Seed Funding (R00RG2515)
This publication has 29 references indexed in Scilit:
- Efficacy of Slit Lamp Breath ShieldsAmerican Journal of Ophthalmology, 2020
- Transmission of COVID-19 virus by droplets and aerosols: A critical review on the unresolved dichotomyEnvironmental Research, 2020
- On the Effect of the Respiratory Droplet Generation Condition on COVID-19 TransmissionFluids, 2020
- Reducing transmission of SARS-CoV-2Science, 2020
- Efficacy of slit lamp breath shieldsEye, 2020
- Aerodynamic analysis of SARS-CoV-2 in two Wuhan hospitalsNature, 2020
- Comprehensive update on current outbreak of novel coronavirus infection (2019-nCoV)Annals of Translational Medicine, 2020
- Monsoon Season Quantitative Assessment of Biomass Burning Clear-Sky Aerosol Radiative Effect at Surface by Ground-Based Lidar Observations in Pulau Pinang, Malaysia in 2014Remote Sensing, 2019
- Aerosol meteorology of Maritime Continent for the 2012 7SEAS southwest monsoon intensive study – Part 2: Philippine receptor observations of fine-scale aerosol behaviorAtmospheric Chemistry and Physics, 2016
- A Cough Aerosol Simulator for the Study of Disease Transmission by Human Cough-Generated AerosolsAerosol Science and Technology, 2013