Comparative analysis of grease types on bearing performance: time-frequency and statistical investigations
Authors:
- Nazik JeburNJNazik Jebur
- Wafa Abd SoudWSWafa Abd Soud
Open Access
- 4 June 2025
- journal article
- Published by Tribologia - Finnish Journal of Tribology in Tribologia - Finnish Journal of Tribology
- Vol. 42 (1–2) , 24-34
Abstract
This study focuses on evaluating the behavior of three commercially available lithium-based lubricating greases—77 EP (from 77 Lubricants), LGMP3 (AXCL Lubes), and LHTG3 (XADO)—when applied to journal bearings operating at low (600 RPM) and high (2400 RPM) speeds. The purpose is to understand how different grease types influence the vibration performance of bearings under dynamic conditions. The analysis includes both time-domain statistical indicators and vibration characteristics in the frequency domain. Measurements such as RMS, standard deviation, skewness, kurtosis, and variance were gathered using a real-time LabVIEW setup. These metrics helped in identifying differences in system response under each lubrication condition. The outcomes revealed that higher rotational speeds significantly amplified both vibration levels and system irregularities. This behavior demonstrates the critical impact of selecting the proper lubricant, particularly in fast-moving machinery. Among the samples tested, LHTG3 achieved the most consistent results, showing lower fluctuations in vibration readings, which implies effective damping properties. LGMP3, on the other hand, showed greater variability in its data, suggesting reduced vibration stability. Although 77 EP did not score highest in time-domain statistics, it performed strongly in frequency-based analysis, reducing the effect of sudden shocks and high-frequency responses Long-term performance could benefit from LHTG3; 77 EP would be preferable for machines with varying or fast dynamic loads. These results underline the need of choosing lubricant for stability and condition of journal bearings.Keywords
This publication has 17 references indexed in Scilit:
- Vibration-based fault detection and classification in ball bearings using statistical analysis and random forest2024
- Experimental investigation of tribological performance of PTFE-derived solid lubricants in sliding building bearingsConstruction and Building Materials, 2024
- Diagnosis of Bearing Faults Using Temporal Vibration Signals: A Comparative Study of Machine Learning Models with Feature Selection TechniquesJournal of Failure Analysis and Prevention, 2024
- Investigation of various damping pads effect on vibrationAIP Conference Proceedings, 2023
- Effect of grease grades on the tribological and vibrational behaviours of a radial ball bearing: Conventional vs. micro-grooved outer racesProceedings of the Institution of Mechanical Engineers, Part J: Journal of Engineering Tribology, 2022
- Analysis of misaligned journal bearing lubrication performance considering the effect of lubricant couple stress and shear thinningJournal of Mechanics, 2021
- An experimental study on the tribological performance of water-lubricated journal bearings with three different materialsIndustrial Lubrication and Tribology, 2020
- Study on lubrication performance of heavy duty bearing of shearer based on fluid-solid couplingJournal of Physics: Conference Series, 2019
- The Effect of Lubrication on the Vibration of Roller BearingsMATEC Web of Conferences, 2018
- Effect of grease type on abnormal vibration of ball bearingJournal of Sound and Vibration, 2003