Putting the trolley in order: Experimental philosophy and the loop case
Authors:
- S. Matthew LiaoSLS. Matthew Liao
- Alex WiegmannAWAlex Wiegmann
- Joshua AlexanderJAJoshua Alexander
- Gerard VongGVGerard Vong
- 1 October 2012
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Philosophical Psychology
- Vol. 25 (5) , 661-671
Abstract
In recent years, a number of philosophers have conducted empirical studies that survey people's intuitions about various subject matters in philosophy. Some have found that intuitions vary accordingly to seemingly irrelevant facts: facts about who is considering the hypothetical case, the presence or absence of certain kinds of content, or the context in which the hypothetical case is being considered. Our research applies this experimental philosophical methodology to Judith Jarvis Thomson's famous Loop Case, which she used to call into question the validity of the intuitively plausible Doctrine of Double Effect. We found that intuitions about the Loop Case vary according to the context in which the case is considered. We contend that this undermines the supposed evidential status of intuitions about the Loop Case. We conclude by considering the implications of our findings for philosophers who rely on the Loop Case to make philosophical arguments and for philosophers who use intuitions in general.Keywords
This publication has 24 references indexed in Scilit:
- How (not) to react to experimental philosophyPhilosophical Psychology, 2010
- Survey-Driven RomanticismReview of Philosophy and Psychology, 2010
- The Loop Case and Kamm’s Doctrine of Triple EffectPhilosophical Studies, 2008
- The Epistemology of Thought Experiments: First Person versus Third Person ApproachesMidwest Studies in Philosophy, 2007
- A defense of intuitionsPhilosophical Studies, 2007
- THE RISE AND FALL OF EXPERIMENTAL PHILOSOPHYPhilosophical Explorations, 2007
- Intricate Ethics2007
- Analytic Epistemology and Experimental PhilosophyPhilosophy Compass, 2006
- Olympic medals as fruits of comparison? Assimilation and contrast in sequential performance judgments.Journal of Experimental Psychology: Applied, 2006
- Semantics, cross-cultural styleCognition, 2004