Appraisement and selection of third party logistics service providers in fuzzy environment
Authors:
- Saurav DattaSDSaurav Datta
- Chitrasen SamantraCSChitrasen Samantra
- Siba Sankar MahapatraSMSiba Sankar Mahapatra
- Goutam MandalGMGoutam Mandal
- Gautam MajumdarGMGautam Majumdar
- 5 July 2013
- journal article
- Published by Emerald Publishing in Benchmarking: An International Journal
- Vol. 20 (4) , 537-548
Abstract
Purpose: The purpose of this paper is to develop a decision‐making procedural hierarchy for evaluation as well as selection of third‐party reverse logistics provider (3PL) under fuzzy environment.Design/methodology/approach: Due to uncertainty, vagueness arising from decision makers (DM) subjective judgment towards intangible (qualitative) selection criteria, fuzzy logic has been utilized to facilitate such a decision‐making process for 3PL evaluation and selection.Findings: Evaluating and selecting 3PL providers can be regarded as a multi‐criteria decision making (MCDM) process in which a decision maker chooses, under several selection criteria, the best suited alternative. The present study highlights a case study on evaluation and selection of 3PL service providers for a reputed Indian automobile part manufacturing company. The fuzzy based decision‐making tool applied here has been proved fruitful for its effectiveness.Research limitations/implications: There are many research issues remaining in the development of this approach. First, the definition of appropriate fuzzy linguistic variables, corresponding membership functions (MFs) and their numbers, and their universe of discourse for a general use in the algorithm. Second, a methodology for accumulating raw data and analyzing the appropriate MFs for the base linguistic variables. Third, the relative importance of every decision maker, the decision‐making environment and structure may affect the decision‐making process. These have been assumed negligible in this study.Originality/value: The main contributions of this research are: first, an integrated criteria list (followed by sets of sub‐criteria) has been modeled for service quality evaluation and appraisement of 3PL providers. Each sub criteria set has been structured to be preceded by a main criteria. Second, priority weights of various main criteria as well as sub‐criteria; extent of successful performance (rating) of different sub‐criteria have been expressed in fuzzy numbers. It facilitates in accumulating DMs subjective judgments into a unique numerical evaluation score. Third, decision makers risk‐bearing attitude has been estimated and utilized in computing overall evaluation index for alternative candidates. The decision‐making framework presented here can be extended to solve any decision‐making problem designed under a complex and interconnected set of primary criteria followed by sub‐criteria or more extended elaborate criteria hierarchy.Keywords
This publication has 15 references indexed in Scilit:
- An information granulation entropy-based model for third-party logistics providers evaluationInternational Journal of Production Research, 2011
- Selection of third‐party reverse logistics provider using fuzzy extent analysisBenchmarking: An International Journal, 2011
- Analytical modeling of third party service provider selection in lead logistics provider environmentsJournal of Modelling in Management, 2010
- A loss function based decision support model for 3PL selection by 4PLsInternational Journal of Integrated Supply Management, 2010
- An integrated fuzzy approach for provider evaluation and selection in third-party logisticsExpert Systems with Applications, 2009
- A holistic approach for selecting a third-party reverse logistics provider in the presence of vaguenessComputers & Industrial Engineering, 2008
- Third party logistics: a literature review and research agendaThe International Journal of Logistics Management, 2007
- Evaluating the Service Quality of Thirdparty Logistics Service Providers Using the Analytic Hierarchy ProcessJournal of Information Systems and Technology Management, 2007
- Strategic development of third party logistics providersIndustrial Marketing Management, 2003
- A fuzzy multi-criteria decision making method for technology transfer strategy selection in biotechnologyFuzzy Sets and Systems, 1994