What If? Tinkering with the Counterfactual: A Comment on US–Washing Machines (Article 22.6-US)
Open Access
- 31 May 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in World Trade Review
- Vol. 20 (4) , 421-435
Abstract
Typically, the WTO Arbitrator, when charged with evaluating the permissible level of countermeasures (suspension of concessions), has chosen a counterfactual state of the world where the challenged (illegal) measure has not been adopted at all. The Arbitrator then would calculate the trade lost because of the adopted (illegal) measure, and thus, decide on the level of permissible countermeasures. In US–Washing Machines (Article 22.6-US), deviating from this custom, the Arbitrator adopted a different counterfactual, assuming that the complainant had adopted a different, ‘reasonable’ measure. The Arbitrator then evaluated the trade lost based on the distance between the adopted (illegal) and the ‘reasonable’ measure and calculated the level of countermeasures. In this paper, we explain the multitude of perils facing dispute settlement if this approach is adopted in future disputes. We also advance a few thoughts on rethinking the workings of the Arbitrator when measuring the level of permissible countermeasures, since similar slippery slopes risk being reproduced in future cases.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 7 references indexed in Scilit:
- Die Another Day: Zeroing in on Targeted Dumping – Did the AB Hit the Mark in US–Washing Machines?World Trade Review, 2018
- Land Rich and Cash Poor? The Reluctance of the WTO Dispute Settlement System to Entertain Economics Expertise: An Institutional Analysis2017
- US–COOL Retaliation: The WTO's Article 22.6 ArbitrationWorld Trade Review, 2017
- The economics of permissible WTO retaliation2010
- Measuring the Costs of Protection in Europe: European Commercial Policy in the 2000sForeign Affairs, 2002
- Remedies in the WTO legal system: between a rock and a hard placeEuropean Journal of International Law, 2000
- A Theory of Demand for Products Distinguished by Place of Production (Une theorie de la demande de produits differencies d'apres leur origine) (Una teoria de la demanda de productos distinguiendolos segun el lugar de produccion)Staff Papers, 1969