Rethinking Language Proficiency: Commentary on Hulstijn (2024)
Open Access
Abstract
We enjoyed reading Jan Hustijn’s update of his Basic Language Cognition (BLC) theory in the pages of Languages (Hulstijn, 2024), and we are honored to provide a commentary here. Researchers, language learners, and educators hold varying definitions and understandings of language proficiency. Innovative work that helps researchers in the field rethink proficiency is therefore of utmost importance. Hulstijn’s BLC theory offers a clear, well-motivated, and comprehensive framework for investigating what language proficiency may be, what ceilings there may be in what can be attained, and what causes there may be for attainment differences. Hulstijn tells us that BLC rests on a metatheory (i.e., a foundation of assumptions) of language and language learning grounded in two areas familiar to most scholars in second language acquisition (SLA): usage-based linguistics and complex systems. He offers BLC as a theory, that is, a tool to empirically investigate the causation and development of a phenomenon, in this case, proficiency, through a well-articulated research program. In this commentary, we highlight some aspects of the updated BLC theory that we find most useful. Following the Popperian spirit embraced by Hulstijn, we also introduce some critical probes subjects for refinements that may benefit BLC theory in the future.Keywords
This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit:
- Predictions of Individual Differences in the Acquisition of Native and Non-Native Languages: An Update of BLC TheoryLanguages, 2024
- Examining the comparability of parallel English and Chinese elicited imitation tasksResearch Methods in Applied Linguistics, 2023
- Handbook of Literacy in Diglossia and in Dialectal Contexts2022
- A Life in Cognition2022
- ELICITED IMITATION AS A MEASURE OF L2 PROFICIENCYStudies in Second Language Acquisition, 2021
- Education and Input as Predictors of Second Language Attainment in Naturalistic ContextsLanguages, 2019
- Measuring global oral proficiency in SLA research: A new elicited imitation test of L2 ChineseForeign Language Annals, 2013
- The Encyclopedia of Applied Linguistics2012
- BIDIRECTIONAL CROSSLINGUISTIC INFLUENCE IN L1-L2 ENCODING OF MANNER IN SPEECH AND GESTURE: A Study of Japanese Speakers of EnglishStudies in Second Language Acquisition, 2008
- Individual differences in language attainment: Comprehension of passive sentences by native and non-native English speakersLanguage Sciences, 2006