Protecting stable biological nomenclatural systems enables universal communication: A collective international appeal
Authors:
- Pedro Jiménez-MejíasPJPedro Jiménez-Mejías
- Saúl ManzanoSMSaúl Manzano
- Vinita GowdaVGVinita Gowda
- Frank-Thorsten KrellFrank-Thorsten Krell
- Mei-Ying LinMLMei-Ying Lin
- Santiago Martín-BravoSMSantiago Martín-Bravo
- Laura Martín-TorrijosLMLaura Martín-Torrijos
- Gonzalo Nieto FelinerGFGonzalo Nieto Feliner
- Sergei L MosyakinSMSergei L Mosyakin
- Robert F C NacziRNRobert F C Naczi
- Carmen AcedoCarmen Acedo
- Inés ÁlvarezInés Álvarez
Top Cited Papers
Open Access
- 19 June 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in BioScience
- Vol. 74 (7) , 467-472
Abstract
The fundamental value of universal nomenclatural systems in biology is that they enable unambiguous scientific communication. However, the stability of these systems is threatened by recent discussions asking for a fairer nomenclature, raising the possibility of bulk revision processes for “inappropriate” names. It is evident that such proposals come from very deep feelings, but we show how they can irreparably damage the foundation of biological communication and, in turn, the sciences that depend on it. There are four essential consequences of objective codes of nomenclature: universality, stability, neutrality, and transculturality. These codes provide fair and impartial guides to the principles governing biological nomenclature and allow unambiguous universal communication in biology. Accordingly, no subjective proposals should be allowed to undermine them.Keywords
This publication has 30 references indexed in Scilit:
- Name and shame: can taxonomists agree on systematic reforms?Trends in Ecology & Evolution, 2023
- (221) Proposal to add a new Recommendation after Article 38, with the advice to report local/indigenous vernacular names (if available) of new taxa and to use such names, if appropriate, in scientific nomenclatureTaxon, 2023
- (195) Proposal to amend the Preamble by adding a “potentially sensitive content disclaimer and limitation of liability”Taxon, 2023
- Attempts to introduce a system of national, racial and/or ethnocultural discrimination in codes of biological nomenclature should not be tolerated: Comments on some recent proposals (Wright & Gillman, 2022, etc.)Taxon, 2022
- Taxonomists have an opportunity to rid botanical nomenclature of inappropriate honorifics in a structured and defensible wayTaxon, 2022
- Dealing with inappropriate honorifics in a structured and defensible way is possibleTaxon, 2022
- What’s in a Fish Species Name and When to Change It?Fisheries, 2022
- If “Rhodes‐” must fall, who shall fall next?Taxon, 2022
- (119–122) Proposals to amend Articles 51 and 56 and Division III, to allow the rejection of culturally offensive and inappropriate namesTaxon, 2021
- Replacing current nomenclature with pre‐existing indigenous names in algae, fungi and plantsTaxon, 2021