Quantifying Soil Carbon and Nitrogen Stocks for Sustainability Assessment: Implications of Fixed-Depth and Equivalent Soil Mass Methods
Authors:
- K.R IslamKIK.R Islam
- Dexter B. WattsDWDexter B. Watts
- Javier M. GonzalezJGJavier M. Gonzalez
- Warren A. DickWDWarren A. Dick
- Norman R. FauseyNFNorman R. Fausey
- Randall C. ReederRRRandall C. Reeder
- Dennis C. FlanaganDFDennis C. Flanagan
- Tara T. VanToaiTVTara T. VanToai
- Marv T. BatteMBMarv T. Batte
Preprint
- 27 March 2026
- preprint
- Published by Elsevier in SSRN Electronic Journal
Abstract
Carbon and nitrogen are stoichiometrically coupled in soil organic matter (SOM) and underpin key ecosystem services; therefore, their accurate quantification is essential for evaluating the carbon marketing benefits of conservation agricultural practices. This study assessed agreement and bias between fixed-depth (FD) and equivalent soil mass (EM) approaches for estimating soil organic carbon (SOC) and total nitrogen (TN) stocks in a 5-year study under no-till systems amended with gypsum under soybean (Glycine max L. Merr.) –corn (Zea mays L.) rotations, with and without cereal rye (Secale cereale L.) cover crops. Soils were collected at 0–15 and 15–30 cm depths from replicated field experiments across four sites in the USA with contrasting soils and climates: Shorter, east-central Alabama; Farmland, east-central Indiana; Hoytville, northern Ohio; and Piketon, southern Ohio. SOC and TN stocks were calculated using FD and EM methods, with EM values adjusted using depth-correction factors derived from baseline and final bulk density (ρb) measurements. ρb varied significantly among sites and increased by an average of 6.8% over five years, exhibiting site-specific trajectories. Regression analyses showed significant positive relationships between FD- and EM-derived SOC (R² = 0.59 to 0.96) and TN stocks (R² = 0.31 to 0.93) among sites and across sites (R2 = 0.96). Similar relationships were observed for profile-wise SOC and TN stocks both among and across sites. However, FD estimates showed site-dependent bias, underestimating EM-based stocks at Shorter (east-central Alabama), Farmland (east-central Indiana), and Hoytville (northern Ohio), while overestimating SOC (820 kg ha-1) and TN (63 kg ha-1) stocks at Piketon (southern Ohio). The largest TN underestimation (1.11 Mg ha-1) occurred at Hoytville (northern Ohio). Despite these discrepancies, site- and depth-average FD estimates did not differ significantly from EM values. Overall, while FD approaches captured general trends, EM-based calculations provided a less biased assessment when ρb changed over time, thereby improving SOC and TN stock estimates for conservation of agricultural practices and potential carbon market applications. These findings support adopting EM methods in long-term trials, especially where comparability among diverse management systems, sites, and credible reporting for emerging environmental markets and policy frameworks.Keywords
This publication has 27 references indexed in Scilit:
- Understanding soil carbon sequestration: mechanistic insights, management approaches, and future challengesDiscover Soil, 2025
- Long-term changes (1986–2016) in soil organic carbon and nitrogen in agricultural soils of BavariaAgriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, 2025
- The interplay between external residue addition, and soil organic carbon dynamics and mineralization kinetics: Experiences from a 12-year old conservation agricultureJournal of Environmental Management, 2024
- Alfalfa–organic amendments impact soil carbon sequestration and its lability in reclaimed loessLand Degradation & Development, 2023
- Deforestation impacts soil organic carbon and nitrogen pools and carbon lability under Mediterranean climatesJournal of Soils and Sediments, 2022
- Spatial and temporal variation in soil bulk density and saturated hydraulic conductivity and its influencing factors along a 500 km transectCATENA, 2021
- Changes in soil structure and pore functions under long term/continuous grassland managementAgriculture, Ecosystems & Environment, 2021
- No tillage increases soil organic carbon storage and decreases carbon dioxide emission in the crop residue-returned farming systemJournal of Environmental Management, 2020
- Soil organic carbon storage as a key function of soils - A review of drivers and indicators at various scalesGeoderma, 2019
- Changes in soil carbon inventories following cultivation of previously untilled soilsBiogeochemistry, 1993