Strategic Ambiguity, Strategic Clarity, and Dual Clarity
- 27 April 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Oxford University Press (OUP) in Foreign Policy Analysis
- Vol. 20 (3)
Abstract
The United States has successfully prevented the military conflict between China and Taiwan since the 1980s through the Strategic Ambiguity (SA) strategy, which discourages both sides from deviating from the status quo by not committing to defend or not to defend Taiwan. The recent US–China tensions and the rising nationalism in China and Taiwan drew critics to SA and suggested it be replaced with the strategic clarity strategy. We argue that the choice of Dual Clarity (DC)—the United States promises to defend only if Taiwan does not unilaterally declare de jure independence—is widely ignored. We examine the psychological mechanisms behind the three strategies through a pre-registered, within-subject survey experiment in Taiwan (n = 910). The result shows that DC can keep the status quo similar to SA—respondents lowered their support of independence in both DC and SA conditions. The results hold through robustness checks and formalized by a game-theoretical model.Keywords
Funding Information
- University of Nevada, Las Vegas
This publication has 33 references indexed in Scilit:
- Explaining change in independence–unification views in Taiwan: a within-between modelAsian Journal of Communication, 2022
- The Case for Maintaining Strategic Ambiguity in the Taiwan StraitThe Washington Quarterly, 2021
- Studying Identities with Experiments: Weighing the Risk of Posttreatment Bias Against Priming EffectsJournal of Experimental Political Science, 2019
- Explaining incompleteness and conditionality in alliance agreementsInternational Interactions, 2019
- Constructing International Security2012
- Reappraising the debate and practice of US strategic ambiguity/clarity in cross-strait relationsThe Pacific Review, 2010
- Public Opinion, Foreign Policy, and the Security Balance in the Taiwan StraitSecurity Studies, 2005
- Strategy and Selection in International RelationsInternational Interactions, 2002
- Rationalist explanations for warInternational Organization, 1995
- Choices, values, and frames.American Psychologist, 1984