Hedging their bets? The case for a European pillar in NATO
- 23 September 2020
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Defence Studies
- Vol. 20 (4) , 295-317
Abstract
President Donald Trump has adopted a critical position on NATO, raising concerns of an American abandonment of its obligations to Europe’s defence. The severity of Trump’s position is unusual, but some of his concerns are of long-standing and likely to be voiced in some form by his successor in the White House. American criticism and equivocation has led the European allies to engage in various forms of hedging. Some of these strategies are designed to keep the US attached to NATO; others bypass the alliance – cultivating either bilateral links to the US or a strengthening of EU defence cooperation. Hedging, whatever its form, is potentially damaging to alliance effectiveness and cohesion. In that light, NATO’s interests are better served by a strategy which builds upon the NATO-EU relationship and which advertises the benefits of European effort within NATO itself. To that end, we argue in favour of a reformulation of an old but much misunderstood idea – that of NATO’s “European pillar.” Here, existing contributions to European defence provided by the allies through NATO are crucial. Such an arrangement need not, therefore, entail any elaborate institutional engineering, but it does require political and strategic clarity.Keywords
This publication has 17 references indexed in Scilit:
- Enduring Alliance2019
- Presidential Alliance PowersThe Washington Quarterly, 2019
- “I Am a Tariff Man”: The Power of Populist Foreign Policy Rhetoric under President TrumpThe Journal of Politics, 2019
- The Competing Logics of EU Security and DefenceSurvival, 2019
- Rediscovering geography in NATO defence planningDefence Studies, 2018
- Trusting relationships in international politics: No need to hedgeReview of International Studies, 2014
- The Essence of Hedging: Malaysia and Singapore´ s Response to a Rising ChinaContemporary Southeast Asia, 2008
- Beyond the Ivory Tower2001
- The United States and the European Pillar1992
- The European PillarForeign Affairs, 1984