An afforded elaboration mechanism of judgment of learning reactivity
Open Access
- 22 June 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in Metacognition and Learning
- Vol. 21 (1) , 31
Abstract
The mere act of providing a judgment of learning (JOL) influences subsequent memory performance. Such JOL reactivity depends on features of the learned material, as shown by numerous studies demonstrating that providing JOLs tends to enhance memory for related word pairs but not unrelated word pairs. Consequently, the mechanisms underlying existing accounts of positive reactivity predict the effect should generalize across semantically related word pairs broadly. In contrast, we propose that providing JOLs prompts elaboration, but JOL reactivity is conditional on the amount of test-relevant elaboration that cues afford. That is, positive reactivity for related word pairs is not due to their semantic relatedness per se, but rather, occurs because semantically related pairs tend to afford deeper elaboration. Across three preregistered experiments (N = 375), we test these competing mechanistic assumptions by examining whether positive reactivity arises for synonyms–a word pair type that is characterized by high semantic relatedness but only affords shallow elaboration on that relation due to high similarity. Despite being highly related, we find no JOL reactivity for synonym pairs, significantly differing from the positive reactivity observed for distinct-related word pairs. That is, JOL reactivity does not uniformly generalize across all semantically related word pairs. Further, supporting an afforded elaboration mechanism, we find that a novel, continuous metric of the amount of elaboration word pairs afford moderates JOL reactivity. These results emphasize the need for refinement of major accounts of JOL reactivity and offer a pathway for transferring positive JOL reactivity to real-world learning.Keywords
Funding Information
- Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (NI 2166/2-1)
- Deutsche Forschungsgemeinschaft (GRK 2277 – 310365261)
This publication has 73 references indexed in Scilit:
- Judgment of learning reactivity reflects enhanced relational encoding on cued-recall but not recognition testsMetacognition and Learning, 2023
- Changed-goal or cue-strengthening? Examining the reactivity of judgments of learning with the dual-retrieval modelMetacognition and Learning, 2022
- Reactivity from judgments of learning is not only due to memory forecasting: evidence from associative memory and frequency judgmentsMetacognition and Learning, 2022
- Do Judgments of Learning Directly Enhance Learning of Educational Materials?Educational Psychology Review, 2020
- The deceptive nature of associative word pairs: the effects of associative direction on judgments of learningPsychological Research, 2020
- Metamemory viewed through the judgment lensActa Psychologica, 2019
- The influence of judgments of learning on long-term learning and short-term performance.Journal of Applied Research in Memory and Cognition, 2017
- Bayesian hypothesis testing for psychologists: A tutorial on the Savage–Dickey methodCognitive Psychology, 2010
- The Enigma of Organization and DistinctivenessJournal of Memory and Language, 1993
- Vorsatz, Wille und BedürfnisPsychological Research, 1926