The democratic ideal under stress: Citizen commitment to democratic rights and procedures in challenging times
Open Access
- 21 July 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in European Journal of Political Research
- p. 1-22
Abstract
To what extent do citizens support democratic rights and procedures in the face of major societal challenges? Drawing on a Dahlian ideal of democracy, we exploit the context of the Covid-19 pandemic to address this question with two preregistered survey experiments covering 9,000 respondents in six countries (Germany, Hungary, Japan, Poland, South Korea, and Spain). A conjoint experiment on preferences for pandemic policies reveals that citizens strongly oppose restrictions that interfere with their private lives but are largely indifferent to constraints on core democratic rights (elections, rallies, freedom of the press). A framing experiment assessing citizens’ procedural preferences, elicited using best-worst scaling, shows that expert and business input are consistently ranked higher than parliamentary votes or partisan consensus – regardless of whether Covid-19, climate change, or generic ‘societal challenges’ are at stake. We discuss alternative readings of our results and conclude that commitment to democracy does not appear particularly robust when citizens confront concrete crisis-related trade-offs, with largely similar patterns across countries. While our findings diverge from those of some other experimental studies, they are broadly consistent with accounts that point to rising technocratic preferences, concerns about stealth democracy, and risks of gradual democratic erosion rather than abrupt autocratic shifts.Keywords
This publication has 69 references indexed in Scilit:
- Covid and the constitution: unlawful states of emergency during the pandemicEuropean Journal of Law and Economics, 2025
- Household crowding during the COVID-19 lockdown fosters anti-democracy even after 17 months: A 5-wave latent growth curve studyJournal of Environmental Psychology, 2022
- Variation in the COVID-19 infection–fatality ratio by age, time, and geography during the pre-vaccine era: a systematic analysisThe Lancet, 2022
- COVID-19 and erosion of democracyEconomic Modelling, 2021
- Pandemic backsliding: Violations of democratic standards during Covid-19Social Science & Medicine, 2021
- Democratic Accountability in Times of Crisis: Executive Power, Fiscal Policy and COVID-19Government and Opposition, 2021
- Governing in a time of global crises: the good, the bad, and the merely normalGlobal Public Policy and Governance, 2021
- Best-Worst Scaling2015
- Democracy Barometer: a new instrument to measure the quality of democracyZeitschrift für Vergleichende Politikwissenschaft, 2012
- Stealth Democracy2002