Is the Blade Element Momentum Theory overestimating Wind Turbine Loads? – A Comparison with a Lifting Line Free Vortex Wake Method
Preprint
- 8 October 2019
- preprint
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2019, 1-38
Abstract
Load calculations play a key role in determining the design loads of different wind turbine components. State of the art in the industry is to use the Blade Element Momentum (BEM) theory to calculate the aerodynamic loads. Due to their simplifying assumptions of the rotor aerodynamics, BEM methods have to rely on several engineering correction models to capture the aerodynamic phenomena present in Design Load Cases (DLCs) with turbulent wind. Because of this, BEM methods can overestimate aerodynamic loads under challenging conditions when compared to higher-order aerodynamic methods - such as the Lifting Line Free Vortex Wake (LLFVW) method – leading to unnecessarily high design loads and component costs. In this paper, we give a quantitative answer to the question of BEM load overestimation by comparing the results of aeroelastic load calculations done with the BEM-based OpenFAST code and the QBlade code which uses a LLFVW method. We compare extreme and fatigue load predictions from both codes using 66 ten-minute load simulations of the DTU 10 MW Reference Wind Turbine according to the IEC 61400-1 power production DLC group. Results from both codes show differences in fatigue and extreme load estimations for practically all considered sensors of the turbine. LLFVW simulations predict 4 % and 14 % lower lifetime Damage Equivalent Loads (DELs) for the out-of-plane blade root and the tower base fore-aft bending moments, when compared to BEM simulations. The results also show that lifetime DELs for the yaw bearing tilt- and yaw moments are 2 % and 4 % higher when calculated with the LLFVW code. An ultimate state analysis shows that extreme loads of the blade root out-of-plane and the tower base fore-aft bending moments predicted by the LLFVW simulations are 3 % and 8 % lower than the moments predicted by BEM simulations, respectively. Further analysis reveals that there are two main contributors to these load differences. The first is the different treatment in both codes of the effect that sheared inflow has on the local blade aerodynamics and second is the wake memory effect model which was not included in the BEM simulations.Keywords
All Related Versions
- Published version: Wind Energy Science, 5 (2), 721.
This publication has 25 references indexed in Scilit:
- Influence of wake asymmetry on wind turbine blade aerodynamic and aeroelastic performance in shear/yawed windJournal of Renewable and Sustainable Energy, 2018
- Rotor wake engineering models for aeroelastic applicationsJournal of Physics: Conference Series, 2018
- Investigations on the Fatigue Load Reduction Potential of Advanced Control Strategies for Multi-MW Wind Turbines Using a Free Vortex Wake Model2018
- Development of an aeroelastic code based on three‐dimensional viscous–inviscid method for wind turbine computationsWind Energy, 2017
- Application of the lifting line vortex wake method to dynamic load case simulationsJournal of Physics: Conference Series, 2016
- Aeroelastic simulation of multi-MW wind turbines using a free vortex model coupled to a geometrically exact beam modelJournal of Physics: Conference Series, 2016
- Wake impacts on aerodynamic and aeroelastic behaviors of a horizontal axis wind turbine blade for sheared and turbulent flow conditionsJournal of Fluids and Structures, 2014
- Blade element momentum modeling of inflow with shear in comparison with advanced model resultsWind Energy, 2011
- Vortex methods in aeronautics: how to make things workInternational Journal of Computational Fluid Dynamics, 2006
- Modeling of the UAE Wind Turbine for Refinement of FAST{_}AD2003