Pilgrims sailing the Titanic: Plausibility effects on memory for misinformation
Authors:
- 5 September 2013
- journal article
- Published by Springer Nature in Memory & Cognition
- Vol. 42 (2) , 305-324
Abstract
People rely on information they read even when it is inaccurate (Marsh, Meade, & Roediger, Journal of Memory and Language 49:519–536, 2003), but how ubiquitous is this phenomenon? In two experiments, we investigated whether this tendency to encode and rely on inaccuracies from text might be influenced by the plausibility of misinformation. In Experiment 1, we presented stories containing inaccurate plausible statements (e.g., “The Pilgrims’ ship was the Godspeed”), inaccurate implausible statements (e.g., . . . the Titanic), or accurate statements (e.g., . . . the Mayflower). On a subsequent test of general knowledge, participants relied significantly less on implausible than on plausible inaccuracies from the texts but continued to rely on accurate information. In Experiment 2, we replicated these results with the addition of a think-aloud procedure to elicit information about readers’ noticing and evaluative processes for plausible and implausible misinformation. Participants indicated more skepticism and less acceptance of implausible than of plausible inaccuracies. In contrast, they often failed to notice, completely ignored, and at times even explicitly accepted the misinformation provided by plausible lures. These results offer insight into the conditions under which reliance on inaccurate information occurs and suggest potential mechanisms that may underlie reported misinformation effects.Keywords
This publication has 54 references indexed in Scilit:
- Learning Facts From Fiction: Effects of Healthy Aging and Early-Stage Dementia of the Alzheimer Type.Neuropsychology, 2005
- Using Recall to Reduce False Recognition: Diagnostic and Disqualifying Monitoring.Journal of Experimental Psychology: Learning, Memory, and Cognition, 2004
- Learning facts from fictionJournal of Memory and Language, 2003
- An introduction to latent semantic analysisDiscourse Processes, 1998
- Accessing the discourse representation during readingDiscourse Processes, 1998
- Planting False Childhood Memories: The Role of Event PlausibilityPsychological Science, 1997
- You can't not believe everything you read.Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 1993
- How mental systems believe.American Psychologist, 1991
- Plausibility judgments versus fact retrieval: Alternative strategies for sentence verification.Psychological Review, 1982
- Reactions to blatantly contradictory informationMemory & Cognition, 1979