Cooperation and punishment in managing social performance: Labor standards in the Gap Inc. supply chain
Open Access
- 29 June 2025
- journal article
- Published by Wiley in Strategic Management Journal
- Vol. 46 (11) , 2663-2689
Abstract
Research Summary: Corporate social performance depends not only on a firm's behavior but also on the behavior of its suppliers. What management strategies improve the social performance of suppliers? Scholarship on inter‐firm relations and regulatory governance debates the efficacy of threatening to penalize suppliers, compared with more cooperative approaches. This study uses a regression discontinuity design to estimate the causal effects of typical actions to manage supplier social performance, both with and without threatened penalties. Suppliers improved social performance—increasing their probability of passing labor audits by 22 percentage points—only when regulatory actions included a threatened penalty: to discontinue business. Suppliers improved most in response to threatened penalties when they faced higher levels of supply chain competition or were engaged in longer‐term commercial relationships with the buyer.Managerial Summary: How can multinationals improve labor standards in their suppliers around the world? We compared two approaches at the clothing retailer Gap Inc. When Gap did not threaten to discontinue business with low‐performing suppliers, we found no improvement in labor compliance when Gap issued failing compliance grades. However, once Gap began threatening to discontinue business with its lowest‐compliance suppliers, failing suppliers showed marked improvement in labor compliance. Failing suppliers improved most when (a) they faced high competition within their product category, and (b) when they were in longer‐term commercial relationships with the buyer. Our findings suggest buyers should use a combination of both threats and cooperation with suppliers to improve labor standards in global supply chains.Keywords
This publication has 69 references indexed in Scilit:
- Untangling drivers for supplier environmental and social responsibility: An investigation in Philips Lighting's Chinese supply chainJournal of Operations Management, 2020
- Monitoring global supply chainsStrategic Management Journal, 2015
- The long‐term benefits of organizational resilience through sustainable business practicesStrategic Management Journal, 2015
- The impact of corporate social responsibility on investment recommendations: Analysts' perceptions and shifting institutional logicsStrategic Management Journal, 2014
- Corporate social performance, analyst stock recommendations, and firm future returnsStrategic Management Journal, 2013
- Trust over time in exchange relationships: Meta‐analysis and theoryStrategic Management Journal, 2013
- Spinning gold: The financial returns to stakeholder engagementStrategic Management Journal, 2013
- Firm litigation risk and the insurance value of corporate social performanceStrategic Management Journal, 2013
- Corporate social responsibility and access to financeStrategic Management Journal, 2013
- Knowledge spillover in corporate financing networks: embeddedness and the firm's debt performanceStrategic Management Journal, 2002