Can Targets Benefit from Negotiations? Evidence from Auctions and Negotiations

Authors:

Abstract
Prior theory generally suggests target shareholders benefit more from auctions due to increased bidder competition. Recent evidence, however, finds no difference in target shareholders’ wealth effects whether the company is auctioned to multiple bidders or sold in a single bidder negotiation. Controlling for the self-selection bias stemming from management’s private information inherent in this decision, we find auctions are associated with higher target cumulative abnormal returns and offer premiums. Focusing on the impact of various proxies of adverse selection risk and the uncertainty of future cash flows on the sale, we find that targets with more aggressive (or opaque) financial reporting are more likely to auction the firm and this strategy proves beneficial only when the uncertainty of future cash flows is high. When financial reporting is more transparent or the uncertainty of future cash flows is low, targets benefit more from single bidder negotiations.