Comment on egusphere-2024-35
Open Access
- 21 February 2024
- other
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-25
Abstract
Long-term tall-tower eddy-covariance (EC) measurements have been recently established in three European pilot cities as part of the ICOS-Cities project. We conducted a comparison of EC software to ensure a reliable generation of interoperable flux estimates, which is the prerequisite for avoiding methodological biases and improving the comparability of the results. We analyzed datasets covering five months collected from EC tall-tower installations located in urbanized areas of Munich, Zurich, and Paris. Fluxes of sensible heat, latent heat, and CO2 were calculated using three software packages (i.e., TK3, EddyPro, and eddy4) to assess the uncertainty of flux estimations attributed to differences in implemented post-processing schemes. A very good agreement on the mean values and standard deviations was found across all three sites, which can probably be attributed to a uniform instrumentation, data acquisition, and pre-processing. The overall comparison of final flux time-series products showed a good but not yet perfect agreement among three software packages. TK3 and EddyPro both calculated fluxes with low-frequency spectral correction, resulting in better agreement than between TK3 and the eddy4R workflow with disabled low-frequency spectral treatment. These observed flux discrepancies indicate the crucial role of treating low-frequency spectral loss in flux estimation for tall-tower EC systems.Keywords
This publication has 40 references indexed in Scilit:
- Can Data Mining Help Eddy Covariance See the Landscape? A Large-Eddy Simulation StudyBoundary-Layer Meteorology, 2020
- Surface-atmosphere exchange in a box: Making the control volume a suitable representation for in-situ observationsAgricultural and Forest Meteorology, 2018
- Surface-atmosphere exchange in a box: Space-time resolved storage and net vertical fluxes from tower-based eddy covarianceAgricultural and Forest Meteorology, 2018
- Characteristics of CO2 Concentration and Flux in the Beijing Urban AreaJournal of Geophysical Research: Atmospheres, 2018
- Upscaling tower-observed turbulent exchange at fine spatio-temporal resolution using environmental response functionsAgricultural and Forest Meteorology, 2017
- A strategy for quality and uncertainty assessment of long-term eddy-covariance measurementsAgricultural and Forest Meteorology, 2013
- A Wavelet-Based Correction Method for Eddy-Covariance High-Frequency Losses in Scalar Concentration MeasurementsBoundary-Layer Meteorology, 2012
- The energy balance experiment EBEX-2000. Part II: Intercomparison of eddy-covariance sensors and post-field data processing methodsBoundary-Layer Meteorology, 2006
- Temporal dynamics of CO2 fluxes and profiles over a Central European cityTheoretical and Applied Climatology, 2005
- Frequency response corrections for eddy correlation systemsBoundary-Layer Meteorology, 1986