Claudio D'Onofrio
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Claudio D'Onofrio has a total of 125 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Alex Vermeulen
ICOS ERIC - Carbon Portal, Department of Physical Geography and Ecosystem Sciences, Lund University, Lund, 22362, Sweden
8 shared publications - Ute Karstens
ICOS ERIC Carbon Portal, Lund University, Lund, 22362, Sweden
7 shared publications - Benjamin Loubet
UMR ECOSYS, INRAE AgroParisTech, Université Paris-Saclay, 91120 Palaiseau, France
6 shared publications - Changxing Lan
Institute of Meteorology and Climate Research, Atmospheric Environmental Research, Karlsruhe Institute of Technology, Garmisch-Partenkirchen, Germany
6 shared publications - David Durden
National Ecological Observatory Network, Battelle, Boulder, CO 80301, USA
6 shared publications - Matthias Mauder
Institute of Hydrology and Meteorology, TUD Dresden University of Technology, Pienner Strasse 23, 01737 Tharandt, Germany
6 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
Toward a global ecosystem network‐of‐networks: Team science as a pathway for equitable macrosystem collaboration
Global environmental challenges—from shifting precipitation regimes to biodiversity loss—transcend geopolitical boundaries and demand collaborative, cross‐border scientific responses. Ecosystem Research Infrastructures (ERIs) provide standardized, long‐term observations across regions to continents, yet they cover only a fraction of Earth's surface, with gaps in the southern hemisphere and historically disadvantaged regions. Environmental networks (ENs) worldwide could supply complementary observations but remain largely unconnected to these larger infrastructures. We advocate for a new organizational framework—the Global Ecosystem Network‐of‐Networks Initiative (GENNI)—to formalize relationships between self‐organizing network‐of‐networks (NoNs) and federated ERIs such as the Global Ecosystem Research Infrastructure (GERI). Drawing on our collective experience and informed by a participatory workshop that brought together five Mexican ENs, we argue that evidence‐based team science approaches offer a practical pathway to overcome the organizational, cultural, and governance barriers that have historically impeded such collaborations. A landscape survey identified 223 potential “nearest neighbor” organizations across 41 countries, underscoring the substantial but underutilized capacity for global integration. We contend that the principal barriers are not primarily technical—advances in informatics and data standards have addressed many of those challenges—but rather organizational and cultural: rigid institutional hierarchies, inequitable data governance, insufficient research funding in many countries, and the absence of frameworks that ensure mutual benefit for all partners. Building on the insights from the Mexican workshop and our broader experience with GERI, we propose that team science methods—participatory governance, distributed leadership, trust‐building through codes of conduct—can be systematically applied to develop NoNs worldwide. We aim to catalyze a broader community dialogue on how networks, infrastructures, and researchers can work together more equitably and effectively to advance macrosystem science.
Open AccessToward a global ecosystem network‐of‐networks: Team science as a pathway for equitable macrosystem collaboration
Global environmental challenges—from shifting precipitation regimes to biodiversity loss—transcend geopolitical boundaries and demand collaborative, cross‐border scientific responses. Ecosystem Research Infrastructures (ERIs) provide standardized, long‐term observations across regions to continents, yet they cover only a fraction of Earth's surface, with gaps in the southern hemisphere and historically disadvantaged regions. Environmental networks (ENs) worldwide could supply complementary observations but remain largely unconnected to these larger infrastructures. We advocate for a new organizational framework—the Global Ecosystem Network‐of‐Networks Initiative (GENNI)—to formalize relationships between self‐organizing network‐of‐networks (NoNs) and federated ERIs such as the Global Ecosystem Research Infrastructure (GERI). Drawing on our collective experience and informed by a participatory workshop that brought together five Mexican ENs, we argue that evidence‐based team science approaches offer a practical pathway to overcome the organizational, cultural, and governance barriers that have historically impeded such collaborations. A landscape survey identified 223 potential “nearest neighbor” organizations across 41 countries, underscoring the substantial but underutilized capacity for global integration. We contend that the principal barriers are not primarily technical—advances in informatics and data standards have addressed many of those challenges—but rather organizational and cultural: rigid institutional hierarchies, inequitable data governance, insufficient research funding in many countries, and the absence of frameworks that ensure mutual benefit for all partners. Building on the insights from the Mexican workshop and our broader experience with GERI, we propose that team science methods—participatory governance, distributed leadership, trust‐building through codes of conduct—can be systematically applied to develop NoNs worldwide. We aim to catalyze a broader community dialogue on how networks, infrastructures, and researchers can work together more equitably and effectively to advance macrosystem science.
- Open Access
- 2 December 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Earth System Science Data
- Vol. 17 (12) , 6681-6701
Monitoring CO 2 in diverse European cities: highlighting needs and challenges through characterisation
For the development of a joint European capacity for monitoring CO2 emissions, we created the framework “CO2 Monitoring Challenges City Mapbooks v1.0” (CMC-CITYMAP). It includes a Jupyter notebook tool (Storm et al., 2025a, https://doi.org/10.18160/P8SV-B99F) which we use to characterise and cluster cities based on aspects relevant for different CO2 monitoring challenges. These include: a. determining background levels of CO2 inflow into a city (“background challenge”). b. separating the anthropogenic emissions from the influence of the biosphere (“biogenic challenge”). c. representing spatially and temporally non-uniform emissions in models (“modelling challenge”). d. implementing observation strategies not covered by the other challenges (“application-specific observational challenge”). We provide and discuss the challenges on a city-by-city basis. Our primary focus, however, is on the relationships between cities: best practices and lessons learned from monitoring CO2 emissions in one city can be transferred to other cities with similar characteristics. Additionally, we identify cities with characteristics that strongly contrast with those of cities with existing urban monitoring systems. While the notebook tool includes 308 cities, this paper focuses on the results for 96 cities with more than 200 000 inhabitants. We place a particular emphasis on Paris, Munich, and Zurich. These cities are pilot cities for the Horizon 2020-funded project Pilot Application in Urban Landscapes (“ICOS Cities”), where a range of urban CO2 monitoring methods are being implemented and assessed. According to our analyses, Zurich – and Munich especially – should be less challenging to monitor than Paris. Examining the challenges individually reveals that the most significant challenge relative to the other cities is the “modelling challenge” (c) for Zurich and Paris. Complex urban topography adds to the challenge for both cities, and in Zurich, the natural topography further amplifies the challenge. Munich has low scores across all challenges, but with the greatest challenge anticipated from the “application-specific observational challenge” (d). Overall, Bratislava (Slovakia) and Copenhagen (Denmark) are among the most distant from Paris, Munich, and Zurich in our dendrogram resulting from numerical cluster-analysis. This makes them strong candidates for inclusion in the ICOS Cities network, as they would potentially provide the most information on how to monitor emissions in cities that face different challenges.
- 2 December 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Earth System Science Data
- Vol. 17 (12) , 6681-6701
Open AccessMonitoring CO 2 in diverse European cities: highlighting needs and challenges through characterisation
For the development of a joint European capacity for monitoring CO2 emissions, we created the framework “CO2 Monitoring Challenges City Mapbooks v1.0” (CMC-CITYMAP). It includes a Jupyter notebook tool (Storm et al., 2025a, https://doi.org/10.18160/P8SV-B99F) which we use to characterise and cluster cities based on aspects relevant for different CO2 monitoring challenges. These include: a. determining background levels of CO2 inflow into a city (“background challenge”). b. separating the anthropogenic emissions from the influence of the biosphere (“biogenic challenge”). c. representing spatially and temporally non-uniform emissions in models (“modelling challenge”). d. implementing observation strategies not covered by the other challenges (“application-specific observational challenge”). We provide and discuss the challenges on a city-by-city basis. Our primary focus, however, is on the relationships between cities: best practices and lessons learned from monitoring CO2 emissions in one city can be transferred to other cities with similar characteristics. Additionally, we identify cities with characteristics that strongly contrast with those of cities with existing urban monitoring systems. While the notebook tool includes 308 cities, this paper focuses on the results for 96 cities with more than 200 000 inhabitants. We place a particular emphasis on Paris, Munich, and Zurich. These cities are pilot cities for the Horizon 2020-funded project Pilot Application in Urban Landscapes (“ICOS Cities”), where a range of urban CO2 monitoring methods are being implemented and assessed. According to our analyses, Zurich – and Munich especially – should be less challenging to monitor than Paris. Examining the challenges individually reveals that the most significant challenge relative to the other cities is the “modelling challenge” (c) for Zurich and Paris. Complex urban topography adds to the challenge for both cities, and in Zurich, the natural topography further amplifies the challenge. Munich has low scores across all challenges, but with the greatest challenge anticipated from the “application-specific observational challenge” (d). Overall, Bratislava (Slovakia) and Copenhagen (Denmark) are among the most distant from Paris, Munich, and Zurich in our dendrogram resulting from numerical cluster-analysis. This makes them strong candidates for inclusion in the ICOS Cities network, as they would potentially provide the most information on how to monitor emissions in cities that face different challenges.
- Open Access
- 2 June 2025
- Published by Pensoft Publishers in ARPHA Conference Abstracts
- Vol. 8, e158965
A Use Case Approach to Integrate Ecological Research Networks and Infrastructures to Advance Macrosystem Science
We explore how the Global Ecosystem Research Infrastructure (GERI) proposes a pathway for other Networks and Networks-of-Networks (NoNs) can work together and accelerate collaborations and data harmonization to address global environmental challenges. Recognizing that contemporary environmental issues transcend geopolitical boundaries, we advocate for collaborative frameworks that integrate top-down structured ecosystems research infrastructures (ERIs) with bottom-up environmental networks (ENs). We highlight the unique characteristics of ERIs, including their long-term data collection capabilities and structured governance, in contrast to the flexible and innovative nature of ENs. We address the technical and organizational barriers that hinder effective collaboration and data sharing among these entities and draw upon two use cases: ecological drought; and the integration of Mexican ENs into a NoNs framework. ecological drought; and the integration of Mexican ENs into a NoNs framework. Through workshops and strategic leadership tools, we established a shared understanding and collective identity among these diverse stakeholders, and fosteri sustainable organizational practices and enhance global environmental observations. Our findings underscore the importance of addressing cultural dynamics and building mutual trust to ensure the long-term sustainability of collaborative efforts in ecological research and data integration. Together top-down ERIs that support standardized and long-term observational continuity, and bottom-up ENs that introduce new perspectives and data types, provide the complementarity to support the data and human capital required to address the Grand Challenges of global environmental change.
- 2 June 2025
- Published by Pensoft Publishers in ARPHA Conference Abstracts
- Vol. 8, e158965
Open AccessA Use Case Approach to Integrate Ecological Research Networks and Infrastructures to Advance Macrosystem Science
We explore how the Global Ecosystem Research Infrastructure (GERI) proposes a pathway for other Networks and Networks-of-Networks (NoNs) can work together and accelerate collaborations and data harmonization to address global environmental challenges. Recognizing that contemporary environmental issues transcend geopolitical boundaries, we advocate for collaborative frameworks that integrate top-down structured ecosystems research infrastructures (ERIs) with bottom-up environmental networks (ENs). We highlight the unique characteristics of ERIs, including their long-term data collection capabilities and structured governance, in contrast to the flexible and innovative nature of ENs. We address the technical and organizational barriers that hinder effective collaboration and data sharing among these entities and draw upon two use cases: ecological drought; and the integration of Mexican ENs into a NoNs framework. ecological drought; and the integration of Mexican ENs into a NoNs framework. Through workshops and strategic leadership tools, we established a shared understanding and collective identity among these diverse stakeholders, and fosteri sustainable organizational practices and enhance global environmental observations. Our findings underscore the importance of addressing cultural dynamics and building mutual trust to ensure the long-term sustainability of collaborative efforts in ecological research and data integration. Together top-down ERIs that support standardized and long-term observational continuity, and bottom-up ENs that introduce new perspectives and data types, provide the complementarity to support the data and human capital required to address the Grand Challenges of global environmental change.
- Open Access
- 14 April 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2025, 1-37
Monitoring CO 2 in diverse European cities: Highlighting needs and challenges through characterisation
For the development of a joint European capacity for monitoring CO2 emissions, we created the framework "CO2 Monitoring Challenges City Mapbooks v1.0" (acronym CMC-CITYMAP). It includes a Jupyter notebook tool (Storm et al., 2025a, https://doi.org/10.18160/P8SV-B99F) which we use to characterise and cluster cities based on aspects relevant for different CO2 monitoring challenges, including (a) determining background levels of CO2 inflow into a city ("background challenge"), (b) separating the anthropogenic emissions from the influence of the biosphere ("biogenic challenge"), (c) representing spatially and temporally non-uniform emissions in models ("modelling challenge"), and (d) implementing observation strategies not covered by the other challenges ("application-specific observational challenge"). We provide and discuss the challenges city-by-city basis, but our primary focus is on the relationships between cities: best practices and lessons learned from monitoring CO2 emissions in one city can be transferred to other cities with similar characteristics. Additionally, we identify cities with characteristics that strongly contrast with those of cities with existing urban monitoring systems. While the notebook tool includes 308 cities, this paper focuses on the results for 96 cities with more than 200,000 inhabitants, with a particular emphasis on Paris, Munich, and Zurich. These cities are pilot cities for the Horizon 2020-funded project Pilot Application in Urban Landscapes ("ICOS Cities"), where a range of urban CO2 monitoring methods are being implemented and assessed. According to our analyses, Zurich — and Munich especially — should be less challenging to monitor than Paris. Examining the challenges individually reveals that the most significant relative challenge is the "modelling challenge" (c) for Zurich and Paris. Complex urban topography adds to the challenge for both cities, and in Zurich, the natural topography further amplifies the challenge. Munich has low scores across all challenges, but with the greatest challenge anticipated from the "application-specific observational challenge" (d). Overall, Bratislava (Slovakia) and Copenhagen (Denmark) are among the most distant from Paris, Munich, and Zurich in our dendrogram resulting from numerical cluster-analysis. This makes them strong candidates for inclusion in the ICOS Cities network, as they would potentially provide the most information on how to monitor emissions in cities that face different challenges.
- 14 April 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in EGUsphere
- Vol. 2025, 1-37
Open AccessMonitoring CO 2 in diverse European cities: Highlighting needs and challenges through characterisation
For the development of a joint European capacity for monitoring CO2 emissions, we created the framework "CO2 Monitoring Challenges City Mapbooks v1.0" (acronym CMC-CITYMAP). It includes a Jupyter notebook tool (Storm et al., 2025a, https://doi.org/10.18160/P8SV-B99F) which we use to characterise and cluster cities based on aspects relevant for different CO2 monitoring challenges, including (a) determining background levels of CO2 inflow into a city ("background challenge"), (b) separating the anthropogenic emissions from the influence of the biosphere ("biogenic challenge"), (c) representing spatially and temporally non-uniform emissions in models ("modelling challenge"), and (d) implementing observation strategies not covered by the other challenges ("application-specific observational challenge"). We provide and discuss the challenges city-by-city basis, but our primary focus is on the relationships between cities: best practices and lessons learned from monitoring CO2 emissions in one city can be transferred to other cities with similar characteristics. Additionally, we identify cities with characteristics that strongly contrast with those of cities with existing urban monitoring systems. While the notebook tool includes 308 cities, this paper focuses on the results for 96 cities with more than 200,000 inhabitants, with a particular emphasis on Paris, Munich, and Zurich. These cities are pilot cities for the Horizon 2020-funded project Pilot Application in Urban Landscapes ("ICOS Cities"), where a range of urban CO2 monitoring methods are being implemented and assessed. According to our analyses, Zurich — and Munich especially — should be less challenging to monitor than Paris. Examining the challenges individually reveals that the most significant relative challenge is the "modelling challenge" (c) for Zurich and Paris. Complex urban topography adds to the challenge for both cities, and in Zurich, the natural topography further amplifies the challenge. Munich has low scores across all challenges, but with the greatest challenge anticipated from the "application-specific observational challenge" (d). Overall, Bratislava (Slovakia) and Copenhagen (Denmark) are among the most distant from Paris, Munich, and Zurich in our dendrogram resulting from numerical cluster-analysis. This makes them strong candidates for inclusion in the ICOS Cities network, as they would potentially provide the most information on how to monitor emissions in cities that face different challenges.
- Open Access
- 20 January 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Challenges and opportunities from an in-house cross collaboration between three research infrastructure data repositories
The ICOS Carbon Portal is the main data repository for the Integrated Carbon Observation System Research Infrastructure (ICOS RI), covering the domains Atmosphere, Ocean, and Ecosystems. Data from ICOS is available and accessible for humans and machines with a rich set of metadata under a CC BY 4.0 licence. The core services for the data portal (https://data.icos-cp.eu/portal/) are open-source software and are available on GitHub (https://github.com/ICOS-Carbon-Portal). The main goal for the development was to make the European greenhouse gas measurements accessible as FAIR as possible. This led to a mature and stable data portal which was subsequently adapted to be applied by another Research Infrastructure namely SITES, a national Swedish Infrastructure for Ecosystem Science, and the European Horizon 2020 project PAUL, pilot applications in urban landscapes (ICOS Cities). Although all three data portals use the same software core and are hosted at the ICOS Carbon Portal, they are independent from each other and base on slightly different ontologies. Hence, we have a unique opportunity to explore the challenges and opportunities of accessing and combining data from three or more different data sources and compare FAIR aspects of the datasets. How do we deal with attribution of the used data using correct citations? Do we have access to the licence for each data sets, are they different and what are the implications? How do we combine the data for further analysis keeping track of provenance and origin?Further we will try to step back from the implementation of a service on specific data sets (which is kind of a hands-on bottom-up approach) and look at scalability to include other (environmental/ENVRI) data portals and think more about the top-down approach like the European Open Science Cloud EOSC. Can we offer a generalised service level for automated data processing from machine to machine? What do we need to process cross domain data sets?
- 20 January 2025
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
Open AccessChallenges and opportunities from an in-house cross collaboration between three research infrastructure data repositories
The ICOS Carbon Portal is the main data repository for the Integrated Carbon Observation System Research Infrastructure (ICOS RI), covering the domains Atmosphere, Ocean, and Ecosystems. Data from ICOS is available and accessible for humans and machines with a rich set of metadata under a CC BY 4.0 licence. The core services for the data portal (https://data.icos-cp.eu/portal/) are open-source software and are available on GitHub (https://github.com/ICOS-Carbon-Portal). The main goal for the development was to make the European greenhouse gas measurements accessible as FAIR as possible. This led to a mature and stable data portal which was subsequently adapted to be applied by another Research Infrastructure namely SITES, a national Swedish Infrastructure for Ecosystem Science, and the European Horizon 2020 project PAUL, pilot applications in urban landscapes (ICOS Cities). Although all three data portals use the same software core and are hosted at the ICOS Carbon Portal, they are independent from each other and base on slightly different ontologies. Hence, we have a unique opportunity to explore the challenges and opportunities of accessing and combining data from three or more different data sources and compare FAIR aspects of the datasets. How do we deal with attribution of the used data using correct citations? Do we have access to the licence for each data sets, are they different and what are the implications? How do we combine the data for further analysis keeping track of provenance and origin?Further we will try to step back from the implementation of a service on specific data sets (which is kind of a hands-on bottom-up approach) and look at scalability to include other (environmental/ENVRI) data portals and think more about the top-down approach like the European Open Science Cloud EOSC. Can we offer a generalised service level for automated data processing from machine to machine? What do we need to process cross domain data sets?
- Open Access
- 7 May 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Atmospheric Measurement Techniques
- Vol. 17 (9) , 2649-2669
Intercomparison of eddy-covariance software for urban tall-tower sites
Long-term tall-tower eddy-covariance (EC) measurements have been recently established in three European pilot cities as part of the ICOS-Cities project. We conducted a comparison of EC software to ensure a reliable generation of interoperable flux estimates, which is the prerequisite for avoiding methodological biases and improving the comparability of the results. We analyzed datasets covering 5 months collected from EC tall-tower installations located in urbanized areas of Munich, Zurich, and Paris. Fluxes of sensible heat, latent heat, and CO2 were calculated using three software packages (i.e., TK3, EddyPro, and eddy4R) to assess the uncertainty of flux estimations attributed to differences in implemented postprocessing schemes. A very good agreement on the mean values and standard deviations was found across all three sites, which can probably be attributed to a uniform instrumentation, data acquisition, and preprocessing. The overall comparison of final flux time series products showed a good but not yet perfect agreement among the three software packages. TK3 and EddyPro both calculated fluxes with low-frequency spectral correction, resulting in better agreement than between TK3 and the eddy4R workflow with disabled low-frequency spectral treatment. These observed flux discrepancies indicate the crucial role of treating low-frequency spectral loss in flux estimation for tall-tower EC systems.
- 7 May 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH in Atmospheric Measurement Techniques
- Vol. 17 (9) , 2649-2669
Open AccessIntercomparison of eddy-covariance software for urban tall-tower sites
Long-term tall-tower eddy-covariance (EC) measurements have been recently established in three European pilot cities as part of the ICOS-Cities project. We conducted a comparison of EC software to ensure a reliable generation of interoperable flux estimates, which is the prerequisite for avoiding methodological biases and improving the comparability of the results. We analyzed datasets covering 5 months collected from EC tall-tower installations located in urbanized areas of Munich, Zurich, and Paris. Fluxes of sensible heat, latent heat, and CO2 were calculated using three software packages (i.e., TK3, EddyPro, and eddy4R) to assess the uncertainty of flux estimations attributed to differences in implemented postprocessing schemes. A very good agreement on the mean values and standard deviations was found across all three sites, which can probably be attributed to a uniform instrumentation, data acquisition, and preprocessing. The overall comparison of final flux time series products showed a good but not yet perfect agreement among the three software packages. TK3 and EddyPro both calculated fluxes with low-frequency spectral correction, resulting in better agreement than between TK3 and the eddy4R workflow with disabled low-frequency spectral treatment. These observed flux discrepancies indicate the crucial role of treating low-frequency spectral loss in flux estimation for tall-tower EC systems.
- Open Access
- 22 April 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Agricultural and Forest Meteorology
- Vol. 351
Wildfire impacts on the carbon budget of a managed Nordic boreal forest
- 22 April 2024
- Published by Elsevier in Agricultural and Forest Meteorology
- Vol. 351
Open AccessWildfire impacts on the carbon budget of a managed Nordic boreal forest
- Open Access
- 26 February 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-25
Reply on RC2
Long-term tall-tower eddy-covariance (EC) measurements have been recently established in three European pilot cities as part of the ICOS-Cities project. We conducted a comparison of EC software to ensure a reliable generation of interoperable flux estimates, which is the prerequisite for avoiding methodological biases and improving the comparability of the results. We analyzed datasets covering five months collected from EC tall-tower installations located in urbanized areas of Munich, Zurich, and Paris. Fluxes of sensible heat, latent heat, and CO2 were calculated using three software packages (i.e., TK3, EddyPro, and eddy4) to assess the uncertainty of flux estimations attributed to differences in implemented post-processing schemes. A very good agreement on the mean values and standard deviations was found across all three sites, which can probably be attributed to a uniform instrumentation, data acquisition, and pre-processing. The overall comparison of final flux time-series products showed a good but not yet perfect agreement among three software packages. TK3 and EddyPro both calculated fluxes with low-frequency spectral correction, resulting in better agreement than between TK3 and the eddy4R workflow with disabled low-frequency spectral treatment. These observed flux discrepancies indicate the crucial role of treating low-frequency spectral loss in flux estimation for tall-tower EC systems.
- 26 February 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-25
Open AccessReply on RC2
Long-term tall-tower eddy-covariance (EC) measurements have been recently established in three European pilot cities as part of the ICOS-Cities project. We conducted a comparison of EC software to ensure a reliable generation of interoperable flux estimates, which is the prerequisite for avoiding methodological biases and improving the comparability of the results. We analyzed datasets covering five months collected from EC tall-tower installations located in urbanized areas of Munich, Zurich, and Paris. Fluxes of sensible heat, latent heat, and CO2 were calculated using three software packages (i.e., TK3, EddyPro, and eddy4) to assess the uncertainty of flux estimations attributed to differences in implemented post-processing schemes. A very good agreement on the mean values and standard deviations was found across all three sites, which can probably be attributed to a uniform instrumentation, data acquisition, and pre-processing. The overall comparison of final flux time-series products showed a good but not yet perfect agreement among three software packages. TK3 and EddyPro both calculated fluxes with low-frequency spectral correction, resulting in better agreement than between TK3 and the eddy4R workflow with disabled low-frequency spectral treatment. These observed flux discrepancies indicate the crucial role of treating low-frequency spectral loss in flux estimation for tall-tower EC systems.
- Open Access
- 26 February 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-25
Reply on RC1
Long-term tall-tower eddy-covariance (EC) measurements have been recently established in three European pilot cities as part of the ICOS-Cities project. We conducted a comparison of EC software to ensure a reliable generation of interoperable flux estimates, which is the prerequisite for avoiding methodological biases and improving the comparability of the results. We analyzed datasets covering five months collected from EC tall-tower installations located in urbanized areas of Munich, Zurich, and Paris. Fluxes of sensible heat, latent heat, and CO2 were calculated using three software packages (i.e., TK3, EddyPro, and eddy4) to assess the uncertainty of flux estimations attributed to differences in implemented post-processing schemes. A very good agreement on the mean values and standard deviations was found across all three sites, which can probably be attributed to a uniform instrumentation, data acquisition, and pre-processing. The overall comparison of final flux time-series products showed a good but not yet perfect agreement among three software packages. TK3 and EddyPro both calculated fluxes with low-frequency spectral correction, resulting in better agreement than between TK3 and the eddy4R workflow with disabled low-frequency spectral treatment. These observed flux discrepancies indicate the crucial role of treating low-frequency spectral loss in flux estimation for tall-tower EC systems.
- 26 February 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-25
Open AccessReply on RC1
Long-term tall-tower eddy-covariance (EC) measurements have been recently established in three European pilot cities as part of the ICOS-Cities project. We conducted a comparison of EC software to ensure a reliable generation of interoperable flux estimates, which is the prerequisite for avoiding methodological biases and improving the comparability of the results. We analyzed datasets covering five months collected from EC tall-tower installations located in urbanized areas of Munich, Zurich, and Paris. Fluxes of sensible heat, latent heat, and CO2 were calculated using three software packages (i.e., TK3, EddyPro, and eddy4) to assess the uncertainty of flux estimations attributed to differences in implemented post-processing schemes. A very good agreement on the mean values and standard deviations was found across all three sites, which can probably be attributed to a uniform instrumentation, data acquisition, and pre-processing. The overall comparison of final flux time-series products showed a good but not yet perfect agreement among three software packages. TK3 and EddyPro both calculated fluxes with low-frequency spectral correction, resulting in better agreement than between TK3 and the eddy4R workflow with disabled low-frequency spectral treatment. These observed flux discrepancies indicate the crucial role of treating low-frequency spectral loss in flux estimation for tall-tower EC systems.
- Open Access
- 21 February 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-25
Comment on egusphere-2024-35
Long-term tall-tower eddy-covariance (EC) measurements have been recently established in three European pilot cities as part of the ICOS-Cities project. We conducted a comparison of EC software to ensure a reliable generation of interoperable flux estimates, which is the prerequisite for avoiding methodological biases and improving the comparability of the results. We analyzed datasets covering five months collected from EC tall-tower installations located in urbanized areas of Munich, Zurich, and Paris. Fluxes of sensible heat, latent heat, and CO2 were calculated using three software packages (i.e., TK3, EddyPro, and eddy4) to assess the uncertainty of flux estimations attributed to differences in implemented post-processing schemes. A very good agreement on the mean values and standard deviations was found across all three sites, which can probably be attributed to a uniform instrumentation, data acquisition, and pre-processing. The overall comparison of final flux time-series products showed a good but not yet perfect agreement among three software packages. TK3 and EddyPro both calculated fluxes with low-frequency spectral correction, resulting in better agreement than between TK3 and the eddy4R workflow with disabled low-frequency spectral treatment. These observed flux discrepancies indicate the crucial role of treating low-frequency spectral loss in flux estimation for tall-tower EC systems.
- 21 February 2024
- Published by Copernicus GmbH
- Vol. 2024, 1-25
Open AccessComment on egusphere-2024-35
Long-term tall-tower eddy-covariance (EC) measurements have been recently established in three European pilot cities as part of the ICOS-Cities project. We conducted a comparison of EC software to ensure a reliable generation of interoperable flux estimates, which is the prerequisite for avoiding methodological biases and improving the comparability of the results. We analyzed datasets covering five months collected from EC tall-tower installations located in urbanized areas of Munich, Zurich, and Paris. Fluxes of sensible heat, latent heat, and CO2 were calculated using three software packages (i.e., TK3, EddyPro, and eddy4) to assess the uncertainty of flux estimations attributed to differences in implemented post-processing schemes. A very good agreement on the mean values and standard deviations was found across all three sites, which can probably be attributed to a uniform instrumentation, data acquisition, and pre-processing. The overall comparison of final flux time-series products showed a good but not yet perfect agreement among three software packages. TK3 and EddyPro both calculated fluxes with low-frequency spectral correction, resulting in better agreement than between TK3 and the eddy4R workflow with disabled low-frequency spectral treatment. These observed flux discrepancies indicate the crucial role of treating low-frequency spectral loss in flux estimation for tall-tower EC systems.