Citizens' perceptions of the legitimacy of independent agencies: The effects of expertise‐based and reputation‐sourced authority
Top Cited Papers
Open Access
- 2 January 2025
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Wiley in Public Administration Review
- Vol. 85 (5) , 1495-1511
Abstract
Legitimacy is a central concern for independent agencies tasked with shaping policies. While expertise‐based and reputation‐sourced authority bases are assumed to be relevant for agency legitimacy, their individual and joint effects on citizens' perceptions lack comprehensive examination. To address this gap, the study integrates insights from bureaucratic politics, bureaucratic reputation, and cognitive psychology. Our survey experiment with Dutch citizens, focusing on the European Food Safety Authority, suggests that expertise‐based authority positively affects perceived agency legitimacy, while a negative reputation has detrimental effects. Furthermore, expertise‐based authority moderates the impact of reputation, amplifying positive effects and mitigating negative ones. This implies that agencies are more susceptible to reputational threats when they lack expertise‐based authority. The study advances the theoretical tenets of bureaucratic reputation theory and offers effective strategies for agencies to strengthen their legitimacy among the most critical audience in democratic political systems—citizens.Keywords
This publication has 78 references indexed in Scilit:
- Securing the Trustworthiness of the FDA to Build Public Trust in VaccinesHastings Center Report, 2023
- Negativity Biases and Political Ideology: A Comparative Test across 17 CountriesAmerican Political Science Review, 2020
- Glyphosate Effect: Has the Glyphosate Controversy Affected the EU’s Regulatory Epistemology?European Journal of Risk Regulation, 2020
- Carving Up Concepts? Differentiating Between Trust and Legitimacy in Public Attitudes Towards Legal Authority2016
- Making Policy Public2014
- Cambridge Handbook of Experimental Political Science2011
- Science and Risk Regulation in International Law2010
- Explaining Bureaucratic Optimism: Theory and Evidence from U.S. Executive Agency Macroeconomic ForecastsAmerican Political Science Review, 2007
- Managing the reputation of restructuring corporations: send the right signal to the right stakeholderJournal of Public Affairs, 2004
- Consent, Dissent, and Patriotism1997