Anthropology and impact evaluation: a critical commentary
- 26 February 2015
- journal article
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Development Effectiveness
- p. 1-14
Abstract
Quantitative and quasi-experimental methods have become popular in the evaluation of development impact. In response, several commentators have argued for more effective use of ‘mixed methods’. This paper engages with, and builds upon, this current criticism of more quantitatively based impact evaluation from the disciplinary perspective of anthropology. Focusing on one specific evaluation, of an irrigation project in Malawi, it asks what was missed and what was misunderstood in the quantitative focus that was adopted. The paper then reflects on the wider question that is raised of how particular methods and perspectives can take centre stage and produce apparent ‘truths’ even in the face of evidence pointing in opposite directions. The overall argument is that this is a matter of the politics of knowledge production and of how particular disciplinary perspectives may come to dominate.Keywords
This publication has 13 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Use of Mixed Methods in Randomized Control TrialsNew Directions for Evaluation, 2013
- What is the irrigation potential for Africa? A combined biophysical and socioeconomic approachFood Policy, 2011
- An effective approach to sustainable small-scale irrigation developments in Sub-Saharan AfricaPaddy and Water Environment, 2011
- Achieving high-quality impact evaluation design through mixed methods: the case of infrastructureJournal of Development Effectiveness, 2011
- The Power and Pitfalls of Experiments in Development Economics: Some Non‐random ReflectionsApplied Economic Perspectives and Policy, 2010
- “Our daughters inherit our land, but our sons use their wives' fields”: matrilineal-matrilocal land tenure and the New Land Policy in MalawiJournal of Eastern African Studies, 2010
- Sand in the Engine: The Travails of an Irrigated Rice Scheme in Bwanje Valley, MalawiThe Journal of Development Studies, 2009
- If government failed, how are we to succeed? The importance of history and context in present-day irrigation reform in Malawi.2007
- ''Bargaining'' and Gender Relations: Within and Beyond the HouseholdFeminist Economics, 1997
- Irrigation as a Privileged Solution in African DevelopmentDevelopment Policy Review, 1987