Elizabeth Harrison
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Research Interests
Elizabeth Harrison has a total of 5 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Anna Mdee
School of Politics and International Studies, University of Leeds, Leeds, UK
2 shared publications - Andrea Cornwall
University of Sussex, Falmer, Brighton, UK
1 shared publication - Ann Whitehead
University of Sussex, Falmer, Brighton, UK
1 shared publication - Canford Chiroro1 shared publication
- Elizabeth E. Watson
Department of Geography, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, UK
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 12 March 2020
- Published by SAGE Publications in Critique of Anthropology
- Vol. 40 (2) , 194-217
‘People are willing to fight to the end’. Romanticising the ‘moral’ in moral economies of irrigation
This article is about the continued salience of a particular understanding of moral economy in sub-Saharan Africa. Despite the fact that a significant body of anthropological theory argues against simplified binaries of market and moral economies, such binaries persist. These either romanticise or vilify moral economies and exist in both policy and academic contexts. Thus, moral economies are said to drive corruption or shape anti-market cultural stances. Meanwhile, a romantic fantasy of a non-capitalist rural economy oriented by morality rather than economic rationality continues to animate areas of development policy and to direct funding. My argument is not with the concept of moral economy itself, but with how it is marshalled in support of both romantic and sometimes negatively essentialised conceptions of people and places. The article sets out the case for the persistence of these ideas, focusing on their application to irrigation development and the problems with this. I then use an example from southern Malawi to illustrate how moral ideas of fairness and reciprocity interplay with processes of differentiation in access to (and exclusion from) land and labour and influence how people manage scarce resources. Whilst there are moral discourses and a mutual embeddedness of the moral and economic, these reflect a range of ethically informed positions which are influenced by social position and power. However, this emic perspective is largely absent from the more romanticised models. I conclude by reflecting on the politics of their persistence.
- 12 March 2020
- Published by SAGE Publications in Critique of Anthropology
- Vol. 40 (2) , 194-217
Open Access‘People are willing to fight to the end’. Romanticising the ‘moral’ in moral economies of irrigation
This article is about the continued salience of a particular understanding of moral economy in sub-Saharan Africa. Despite the fact that a significant body of anthropological theory argues against simplified binaries of market and moral economies, such binaries persist. These either romanticise or vilify moral economies and exist in both policy and academic contexts. Thus, moral economies are said to drive corruption or shape anti-market cultural stances. Meanwhile, a romantic fantasy of a non-capitalist rural economy oriented by morality rather than economic rationality continues to animate areas of development policy and to direct funding. My argument is not with the concept of moral economy itself, but with how it is marshalled in support of both romantic and sometimes negatively essentialised conceptions of people and places. The article sets out the case for the persistence of these ideas, focusing on their application to irrigation development and the problems with this. I then use an example from southern Malawi to illustrate how moral ideas of fairness and reciprocity interplay with processes of differentiation in access to (and exclusion from) land and labour and influence how people manage scarce resources. Whilst there are moral discourses and a mutual embeddedness of the moral and economic, these reflect a range of ethically informed positions which are influenced by social position and power. However, this emic perspective is largely absent from the more romanticised models. I conclude by reflecting on the politics of their persistence.
- 1 May 2019
- Published by Elsevier in Journal of Rural Studies
- Vol. 68, 54-62
‘They are treating us with contempt’: The complexities of opposition in an English village
- 1 May 2019
- Published by Elsevier in Journal of Rural Studies
- Vol. 68, 54-62
‘They are treating us with contempt’: The complexities of opposition in an English village
- 1 November 2018
- Published by Elsevier in World Development
- Vol. 111, 246-255
Engineering change? The idea of ‘the scheme’ in African irrigation
- 1 November 2018
- Published by Elsevier in World Development
- Vol. 111, 246-255
Engineering change? The idea of ‘the scheme’ in African irrigation
- Open Access
- 3 May 2018
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Third World Quarterly
- Vol. 39 (11) , 2126-2141
Entrepreneurs, investors and the state: the public and the private in sub-Saharan African irrigation development
This article draws on ethnographic research in Tanzania to interrogate the discourse of ‘public’ and ‘private’ in sub-Saharan irrigation development. It contrasts the complexity of social and political relations with narratives suggesting that ‘private’ is necessarily opposed and superior to ‘public’. We argue that support for models of private-sector development obscures access to and control over resources and can result in the dispossession of those least able to resist this. Different interests of ‘entrepreneurial’ individuals and corporate investors and the ways in which these relate to the state are also glossed over. Conversely, the failure of the ‘public’ cannot simply be read from the chequered histories of irrigation schemes within which public and private interests intersect in complex ways.
- 3 May 2018
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Third World Quarterly
- Vol. 39 (11) , 2126-2141
Open AccessEntrepreneurs, investors and the state: the public and the private in sub-Saharan African irrigation development
This article draws on ethnographic research in Tanzania to interrogate the discourse of ‘public’ and ‘private’ in sub-Saharan irrigation development. It contrasts the complexity of social and political relations with narratives suggesting that ‘private’ is necessarily opposed and superior to ‘public’. We argue that support for models of private-sector development obscures access to and control over resources and can result in the dispossession of those least able to resist this. Different interests of ‘entrepreneurial’ individuals and corporate investors and the ways in which these relate to the state are also glossed over. Conversely, the failure of the ‘public’ cannot simply be read from the chequered histories of irrigation schemes within which public and private interests intersect in complex ways.
- 8 May 2017
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in The Journal of Modern African Studies
- Vol. 55 (2) , 251-273
Size isn't everything: narratives of scale and viability in a Tanzanian irrigation scheme
This paper explores tensions over scale and viability in irrigated agricultural development in Tanzania. A revival of ambition to transform African agriculture has reawakened debate over what type of agriculture can best deliver increased production and poverty reduction for rural populations. This paper examines these debates through the lens of an ethnographic study of an irrigated rice farm in Tanzania. With a chequered history of state and donor intervention management, Dakawa, Rice Farm in Mvomero District is now collectively farmed by a cooperative society of ‘small farmers’. It is widely hailed as a success, both of irrigation production, and of ‘small farmers’ in delivering this. However, such narratives of smallness and success obscure a more complex reality in which smallness of scale may be more of a discursive tool than a reflection of empirical reality. Although notions of ‘viability’ and ‘success’ in such development interventions are themselves also contested and depend on perspective, there is evidence that there are fundamental problems of both short- and long-term viability.
- 8 May 2017
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in The Journal of Modern African Studies
- Vol. 55 (2) , 251-273
Size isn't everything: narratives of scale and viability in a Tanzanian irrigation scheme
This paper explores tensions over scale and viability in irrigated agricultural development in Tanzania. A revival of ambition to transform African agriculture has reawakened debate over what type of agriculture can best deliver increased production and poverty reduction for rural populations. This paper examines these debates through the lens of an ethnographic study of an irrigated rice farm in Tanzania. With a chequered history of state and donor intervention management, Dakawa, Rice Farm in Mvomero District is now collectively farmed by a cooperative society of ‘small farmers’. It is widely hailed as a success, both of irrigation production, and of ‘small farmers’ in delivering this. However, such narratives of smallness and success obscure a more complex reality in which smallness of scale may be more of a discursive tool than a reflection of empirical reality. Although notions of ‘viability’ and ‘success’ in such development interventions are themselves also contested and depend on perspective, there is evidence that there are fundamental problems of both short- and long-term viability.
- 27 June 2016
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The Journal of Peasant Studies
- Vol. 44 (5) , 1022-1042
Differentiated legitimacy, differentiated resilience: beyond the natural in ‘natural disasters’
This paper starts with a flood in southern Malawi. Although apparently a ‘natural’ event, those most affected argued that it was made much worse by the rehabilitation of a nearby irrigation scheme. We use this example to interrogate the current interest in resilience from a perspective informed by political ecology and political economy, arguing that a focus on resilience should not be at the expense of understanding the conditions that shape vulnerability, including the ways in which ‘communities’ are differentiated. Complex factors are at play – and the ways in which these combine can result in a ‘perfect storm’ for some individuals and households. These factors include the effects of history combining with ethnicity, of legitimacy influencing voice, and of the interplay of political dynamics at different levels. In particular, processes of commodification have played an important role in shaping how some may benefit at the cost of catastrophic harm to others.
- 27 June 2016
- Published by Taylor & Francis in The Journal of Peasant Studies
- Vol. 44 (5) , 1022-1042
Differentiated legitimacy, differentiated resilience: beyond the natural in ‘natural disasters’
This paper starts with a flood in southern Malawi. Although apparently a ‘natural’ event, those most affected argued that it was made much worse by the rehabilitation of a nearby irrigation scheme. We use this example to interrogate the current interest in resilience from a perspective informed by political ecology and political economy, arguing that a focus on resilience should not be at the expense of understanding the conditions that shape vulnerability, including the ways in which ‘communities’ are differentiated. Complex factors are at play – and the ways in which these combine can result in a ‘perfect storm’ for some individuals and households. These factors include the effects of history combining with ethnicity, of legitimacy influencing voice, and of the interplay of political dynamics at different levels. In particular, processes of commodification have played an important role in shaping how some may benefit at the cost of catastrophic harm to others.
- 26 February 2015
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Development Effectiveness
- p. 1-14
Anthropology and impact evaluation: a critical commentary
Quantitative and quasi-experimental methods have become popular in the evaluation of development impact. In response, several commentators have argued for more effective use of ‘mixed methods’. This paper engages with, and builds upon, this current criticism of more quantitatively based impact evaluation from the disciplinary perspective of anthropology. Focusing on one specific evaluation, of an irrigation project in Malawi, it asks what was missed and what was misunderstood in the quantitative focus that was adopted. The paper then reflects on the wider question that is raised of how particular methods and perspectives can take centre stage and produce apparent ‘truths’ even in the face of evidence pointing in opposite directions. The overall argument is that this is a matter of the politics of knowledge production and of how particular disciplinary perspectives may come to dominate.
- 26 February 2015
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Journal of Development Effectiveness
- p. 1-14
Anthropology and impact evaluation: a critical commentary
Quantitative and quasi-experimental methods have become popular in the evaluation of development impact. In response, several commentators have argued for more effective use of ‘mixed methods’. This paper engages with, and builds upon, this current criticism of more quantitatively based impact evaluation from the disciplinary perspective of anthropology. Focusing on one specific evaluation, of an irrigation project in Malawi, it asks what was missed and what was misunderstood in the quantitative focus that was adopted. The paper then reflects on the wider question that is raised of how particular methods and perspectives can take centre stage and produce apparent ‘truths’ even in the face of evidence pointing in opposite directions. The overall argument is that this is a matter of the politics of knowledge production and of how particular disciplinary perspectives may come to dominate.
- 21 March 2012
- Published by SAGE Publications in Critical Social Policy
- Vol. 33 (1) , 97-113
Bouncing back? Recession, resilience and everyday lives
This paper critically engages with a recent shift towards an emphasis on ‘resilience’ in policy and academic fields. The paper suggests that this shift is problematic for several reasons: that it supports normative value judgements; that it may overemphasize the ability of people to ‘bounce back’ and undervalue the hidden costs of resilience, especially those with gendered dimensions; and that it may be associated with policy prescriptions that shift responsibility for dealing with crisis away from the public sphere. The empirical illustration for this analysis is a qualitative study of the impact of economic decline in the Sussex town of Newhaven.
- 21 March 2012
- Published by SAGE Publications in Critical Social Policy
- Vol. 33 (1) , 97-113
Bouncing back? Recession, resilience and everyday lives
This paper critically engages with a recent shift towards an emphasis on ‘resilience’ in policy and academic fields. The paper suggests that this shift is problematic for several reasons: that it supports normative value judgements; that it may overemphasize the ability of people to ‘bounce back’ and undervalue the hidden costs of resilience, especially those with gendered dimensions; and that it may be associated with policy prescriptions that shift responsibility for dealing with crisis away from the public sphere. The empirical illustration for this analysis is a qualitative study of the impact of economic decline in the Sussex town of Newhaven.
- 5 January 2012
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Society & Natural Resources
- Vol. 25 (9) , 933-944
Mind the Gap: Disciplinary Dissonance, Gender, and the Environment
This article investigates the treatment of gender issues in “research for development” natural resources management (NRM) projects. Through discussion of an NRM research project in the United Kingdom and India, the article explores how the use of inaccurate gender stereotypes results in projects being compromised. The article seeks to explain why this happens despite widespread appreciation of the centrality of gender issues to NRM and poverty. In explanation the article identifies the significance of difficulties in the partnerships between the natural and social science dimensions of these projects. The study demonstrates that instead of easy and equal partnership, the relationship between natural and social science practitioners and practices remains characterized by inequality and poor communication, with serious consequences for the understanding of, and response to, gender issues.
- 5 January 2012
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Society & Natural Resources
- Vol. 25 (9) , 933-944
Mind the Gap: Disciplinary Dissonance, Gender, and the Environment
This article investigates the treatment of gender issues in “research for development” natural resources management (NRM) projects. Through discussion of an NRM research project in the United Kingdom and India, the article explores how the use of inaccurate gender stereotypes results in projects being compromised. The article seeks to explain why this happens despite widespread appreciation of the centrality of gender issues to NRM and poverty. In explanation the article identifies the significance of difficulties in the partnerships between the natural and social science dimensions of these projects. The study demonstrates that instead of easy and equal partnership, the relationship between natural and social science practitioners and practices remains characterized by inequality and poor communication, with serious consequences for the understanding of, and response to, gender issues.
- 12 March 2008
- Published by Wiley
- p. 1-19
Gender Myths and Feminist Fables: The Struggle for Interpretive Power in Gender and Development
- 12 March 2008
- Published by Wiley
- p. 1-19
Gender Myths and Feminist Fables: The Struggle for Interpretive Power in Gender and Development