Tacitly consenting to donate one's organs
- 30 March 2011
- journal article
- ethics
- Published by BMJ in Journal of Medical Ethics
- Vol. 37 (6) , 344-347
Abstract
The common objection to opt-out systems of postmortal organ procurement is that they allow removal of a deceased person's organs without their actual consent. However, under certain conditions it is possible for ‘silence’—failure to register any objection—conventionally and/or legally to count as genuine consent. Prominent conditions are that the consenter should be fully informed about the meaning of his or her silence and that the costs of registering dissent should be insignificant. This paper explicates this thesis and discusses some possible objections to it: (1) it cannot possibly be guaranteed that each citizen is aware of the meaning of silence; and (2) the system is slightly manipulative because it exploits a common defect in autonomous decision-making.Keywords
This publication has 18 references indexed in Scilit:
- Debate: To Nudge or Not to Nudge*Journal of Political Philosophy, 2010
- Human Tissue in Transplantation and Research2009
- Consent for Organ Retrieval Cannot be PresumedHEC Forum, 2009
- Individual and Family Decisions About Organ DonationJournal of Applied Philosophy, 2007
- ANOTHER LOOK AT THE PRESUMED‐VERSUS‐INFORMED CONSENT DICHOTOMY IN POSTMORTEM ORGAN PROCUREMENTBioethics, 2006
- Defaults and Donation DecisionsTransplantation, 2004
- Consent to Sexual Relations2003
- Improving Organ Retrieval Rates: Various Proposals and Their Ethical ValidityHealth Care Analysis, 2000
- Winning Hearts and Minds: Using Psychology to Promote Voluntary Organ DonationHealth Care Analysis, 2000
- Legal and judicial aspects of post mortem organ donation1997