Maximizing Output Power in p–n Junction Betavoltaic Batteries via Monte Carlo and Physics-Based Compact Model Cosimulation
- 25 July 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Nuclear Science
- Vol. 71 (12) , 2515-2529
Abstract
Betavoltaic nuclear batteries show promise as compact and enduring power sources for microelectromechanical systems (MEMS). Current theoretical calculations often overlook practical diode characteristics like surface recombination ( S ), bulk recombination within the space-charge region (R-SCR), series resistance ( Rs ) and shunt resistance ( Rsh ), resulting in significant discrepancies between theoretical predictions and experimental outcomes, with differences in JSC , VOC , or converter efficiency up to tenfold. To address this, a Practical Diode Model, integrating these practical characteristics, is developed via Monte Carlo and Physics-Based Compact Model Co-Simulation. We quantitatively analyze the differential impacts and synergistic effects of these practical characteristics on JSC , VOC , FF , and Pout , highlighting the detrimental effects of S , R-SCR, and Rs , while emphasizing the beneficial role of Rsh . Further analysis of the degree of influence of S , Rs , and Rsh on output power reveals a priority ranking order of Rs , S , and Rsh for Si-based batteries, and S , Rsh , and Rs for SiC-based batteries. This approach effectively bridges the theoretical-experimental gap, evidenced by J − V curves closely matching tested batteries and minute relative errors of -0.8% to 0.6% between Pout values and their tested counterparts, emphasizing its accuracy in predictions. We predict output performance across material qualities, obtaining achievable powers of 16.82 and 73.90 nW/cm 2 for planar Si- and SiC-based batteries, and evaluate the quality levels of current batteries. Furthermore, our model can forecast the performance of 3D batteries by incorporating an extended electron-hole pair generation rate model into 3D structures, achieving 28 μW/cm 3 for the 63 Ni-Si-based multi-layer battery, surpassing planar silicon and suitable for MEMS applications.Keywords
Funding Information
- National Natural Science Foundation of China (12305382)
- Hubei Provincial Natural Science Foundation of China (2022CFB575)
- Science Island Graduate Innovation and Entrepreneurship Fund Project (KY-2022-SC-04)
- HFIPS Director’s Fund (YZJJ202311-TS)
This publication has 46 references indexed in Scilit:
- Recent progress and perspective on batteries made from nuclear wasteNuclear Science and Techniques, 2023
- Quantitative modeling, optimization, and verification of 63Ni-powered betavoltaic cells based on three-dimensional ZnO nanorod arraysNuclear Science and Techniques, 2022
- Demonstration of a Three-Dimensionally Structured BetavoltaicJournal of Electronic Materials, 2021
- A 4H–SiC betavoltaic battery based on a $^{\textbf{63}}{\textbf{Ni}}$ 63 Ni sourceNuclear Science and Techniques, 2018
- Vacuum degree effects on betavoltaics irradiated by 63Ni with differently apparent activity densitiesScience China Technological Sciences, 2016
- The Physics of Semiconductors2016
- Influences of planar source thickness on betavoltaics with different semiconductorsJournal of Radioanalytical and Nuclear Chemistry, 2015
- Optimization design and analysis of Si-63Ni betavoltaic batteryScience China Technological Sciences, 2012
- 63Ni schottky barrier nuclear battery of 4H-SiCJournal of Radioanalytical and Nuclear Chemistry, 2010
- A Three‐Dimensional Porous Silicon p–n Diode for Betavoltaics and PhotovoltaicsAdvanced Materials, 2005