The resurgence of interest in the role chattel slavery has played in US capital growth has been marked by an abiding emphasis on the Cotton Kingdom. Highlighting the 19th-century sector that arguably generated more wealth than any other—with enduring implications for governance and the management of difference—scholars have trained their emphasis on the Mississippi River Valley. One implication of this approach is that scholars have focused on the role between coercion and productivity, generally arguing for a direct correlation. That is, from Edward Baptist to Walter Johnson 1 and many others, the argument is that capitalist societies rely on violence and that increasing violence enhances productivity. The consequence is an emphasis on capitalism as a violent system and capital growth as a brutal process. The fact that social historians interested in capital and slavery in the emergence of capitalist societies have generally eschewed defining any of these key terms has only exacerbated the problem.