On Convincing Power of Counterexamples
Authors:
Open Access
- 1 February 2024
- journal article
- Published by University of Montana, Maureen and Mike Mansfield Library in The Mathematics Enthusiast
- Vol. 21 (1-2) , 443-458
Abstract
Despite plethora of research that attends to the convincing power of different types of proofs, research related to the convincing power of counterexamples is rather slim. In this paper we examine how prospective and practicing secondary school mathematics teachers respond to different types of counterexamples. The counterexamples were presented as products of students’ arguments, and the participants were asked to evaluate their correctness and comment on them. The counterexamples varied according to mathematical topic: algebra or geometry, and their explicitness. However, as we analyzed the data, we discovered that these distinctions were insufficient to explain why teachers accepted some counterexamples, but rejected others, with seemingly similar features. As we analyze the participants’ perceived transparency of different counterexamples, we employ various theoretical approaches that can advance our understanding of teachers’ conceptions of conviction with respect to counterexamples.Keywords
This publication has 15 references indexed in Scilit:
- The opaque nature of generic examples: The structure of student teachers’ arguments in multiplicative reasoningThe Journal of Mathematical Behavior, 2020
- Strengths and inconsistencies in students’ understanding of the roles of examples in provingThe Journal of Mathematical Behavior, 2019
- Are indirect proofs less convincing? A study of students' comparative assessmentsThe Journal of Mathematical Behavior, 2018
- When does an argument use a generic example?Educational Studies in Mathematics, 2015
- Expanding the Dimensions of Epistemic Cognition: Arguments From Philosophy and PsychologyEducational Psychologist, 2011
- Students’ Evolving Meaning About Tangent Line with the Mediation of a Dynamic Geometry Environment and an Instructional Example SpaceTechnology, Knowledge and Learning, 2011
- What makes a counterexample exemplary?Educational Studies in Mathematics, 2008
- High school geometry students' justification for their views of empirical evidence and mathematical proofEducational Studies in Mathematics, 1993
- The theory of figural conceptsEducational Studies in Mathematics, 1993
- Generic examples: Seeing the general in the particularEducational Studies in Mathematics, 1984