Orly Buchbinder
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Orly Buchbinder has a total of 22 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Sharon McCrone
3 shared publicationsRebecca Butler
2 shared publicationsAlice Cook
University of Maryland
1 shared publication- Daniel Chazan
Department of Teaching and Learning, Policy and Leadership, University of Maryland, College Park, USA
1 shared publication - Gil Schwarts
The Science Teaching Department, The Weizmann Institute of Science, Rehovot, Israel
1 shared publication - Irit Hadar
Department of Information Systems, University of Haifa, Haifa, Israel
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 25 November 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Educational Studies in Mathematics
- Vol. 121 (2) , 309-332
Exploring the opportunities for reasoning and proving in mathematical tasks designed by secondary prospective teachers
This article examines the opportunities for reasoning and proving (ORP) embedded in mathematical tasks designed by secondary prospective mathematics teachers (PSTs) in a capstone course, Mathematical Reasoning and Proving for Secondary Teachers . Drawing upon the commognitive framework, we establish a unified conceptualization for examining the mathematical reasoning processes and the logic-related constructs embedded in mathematical tasks. We analyze 551 questions designed by 15 PSTs who participated in the course and explore how mathematical reasoning and logic-related constructs are reflected and intertwined in the tasks. Findings revealed four types of ORP, explicating the differences between opportunities related to reasoning processes and logic-related constructs: limited ORP, mathematical-reasoning ORP, logic-related ORP, and fully-integrated ORP. We discuss the contribution of the four types of ORP for characterizing tasks, specifically those that include logic-related constructs, and potential implications for supporting teachers in integrating reasoning and proving in their classrooms.
- 25 November 2025
- Published by Springer Nature in Educational Studies in Mathematics
- Vol. 121 (2) , 309-332
Open AccessExploring the opportunities for reasoning and proving in mathematical tasks designed by secondary prospective teachers
This article examines the opportunities for reasoning and proving (ORP) embedded in mathematical tasks designed by secondary prospective mathematics teachers (PSTs) in a capstone course, Mathematical Reasoning and Proving for Secondary Teachers . Drawing upon the commognitive framework, we establish a unified conceptualization for examining the mathematical reasoning processes and the logic-related constructs embedded in mathematical tasks. We analyze 551 questions designed by 15 PSTs who participated in the course and explore how mathematical reasoning and logic-related constructs are reflected and intertwined in the tasks. Findings revealed four types of ORP, explicating the differences between opportunities related to reasoning processes and logic-related constructs: limited ORP, mathematical-reasoning ORP, logic-related ORP, and fully-integrated ORP. We discuss the contribution of the four types of ORP for characterizing tasks, specifically those that include logic-related constructs, and potential implications for supporting teachers in integrating reasoning and proving in their classrooms.
- Open Access
- 13 September 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Mathematics Teacher Education
- Vol. 28 (2) , 341-368
Mathematics teacher educators’ navigational expertise when designing multimodal representations of practice: a semiotic analysis
Critical elements of the expertise of mathematics teacher educators (MTE) can be identified in the artifacts they design for working with prospective teachers (PT), specifically for engaging PT in the double role of practitioners and students of practice. While MTE are increasingly utilizing designed multimodal representations of practice (such as storyboards), theoretical frameworks and methods for analyzing these pedagogical artifacts and the meanings they support are still in early development. We utilize a semiotic framework, expanding systemic functional linguistics to encompass non-linguistic elements, to identify aspects of what we call navigational expertise—which supports PTs in engaging both as practitioners and students of the practice. We view this expertise as tacit knowledge-in-use, enacted through artifact production. The paper demonstrates MTE’s navigational expertise by showing how MTE design storyboards of practice to engage PT as fellow teachers experiencing the lesson taught by a peer and as university students who consider the artifact (including the represented lesson) as an object of study. The framework allows us to identify how MTE’s navigational expertise lies in seamlessly interweaving these two purposes and navigating between them, knowing when, how, and for what purposes to invoke each. Through analysis of storyboards from four MTE in diverse US settings, we uncover some of the nuanced tacit components of navigational expertise, highlighting linguistic and non-linguistic design choices and their potential meanings for transactions with PT.
- 13 September 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal of Mathematics Teacher Education
- Vol. 28 (2) , 341-368
Open AccessMathematics teacher educators’ navigational expertise when designing multimodal representations of practice: a semiotic analysis
Critical elements of the expertise of mathematics teacher educators (MTE) can be identified in the artifacts they design for working with prospective teachers (PT), specifically for engaging PT in the double role of practitioners and students of practice. While MTE are increasingly utilizing designed multimodal representations of practice (such as storyboards), theoretical frameworks and methods for analyzing these pedagogical artifacts and the meanings they support are still in early development. We utilize a semiotic framework, expanding systemic functional linguistics to encompass non-linguistic elements, to identify aspects of what we call navigational expertise—which supports PTs in engaging both as practitioners and students of the practice. We view this expertise as tacit knowledge-in-use, enacted through artifact production. The paper demonstrates MTE’s navigational expertise by showing how MTE design storyboards of practice to engage PT as fellow teachers experiencing the lesson taught by a peer and as university students who consider the artifact (including the represented lesson) as an object of study. The framework allows us to identify how MTE’s navigational expertise lies in seamlessly interweaving these two purposes and navigating between them, knowing when, how, and for what purposes to invoke each. Through analysis of storyboards from four MTE in diverse US settings, we uncover some of the nuanced tacit components of navigational expertise, highlighting linguistic and non-linguistic design choices and their potential meanings for transactions with PT.
- Open Access
- 15 August 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Digital Experiences in Mathematics Education
- Vol. 10 (3) , 431-461
Instructional Technology Tetrahedron and Network Visualization: Conceptualizing Online Teaching Through a Lens of Reflective Noticing
Online learning and teaching, accelerated by the global pandemic and rapid advancement of digital technology, require novel conceptual and analytical tools to understand better the evolving nature of online teaching. Drawing on the classical model of the instructional triangle and previous attempts to extend it, we propose the Instructional Technology Tetrahedron (ITT)—a conceptual framework that integrates technology into the instructional triangle to represent the role of technology, as a learning tool and a mediator between teachers, students, and content. Combining the ITT framework with network visualization strategies allowed for representing the intensity of interactions within the tetrahedron. We illustrate the affordances of the ITT framework by analyzing reflective noticing patterns of three prospective secondary teachers (PSTs) who reflected on the video recordings of their own online teaching, with each PST teaching four online lessons to groups of high-school students. We demonstrate the utility of the ITT framework to characterize individual noticing patterns, in a particular lesson and across time, and to support a variety of cross-case comparisons. The discussion sheds light on the broader implications of the ITT framework.
- 15 August 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Digital Experiences in Mathematics Education
- Vol. 10 (3) , 431-461
Open AccessInstructional Technology Tetrahedron and Network Visualization: Conceptualizing Online Teaching Through a Lens of Reflective Noticing
Online learning and teaching, accelerated by the global pandemic and rapid advancement of digital technology, require novel conceptual and analytical tools to understand better the evolving nature of online teaching. Drawing on the classical model of the instructional triangle and previous attempts to extend it, we propose the Instructional Technology Tetrahedron (ITT)—a conceptual framework that integrates technology into the instructional triangle to represent the role of technology, as a learning tool and a mediator between teachers, students, and content. Combining the ITT framework with network visualization strategies allowed for representing the intensity of interactions within the tetrahedron. We illustrate the affordances of the ITT framework by analyzing reflective noticing patterns of three prospective secondary teachers (PSTs) who reflected on the video recordings of their own online teaching, with each PST teaching four online lessons to groups of high-school students. We demonstrate the utility of the ITT framework to characterize individual noticing patterns, in a particular lesson and across time, and to support a variety of cross-case comparisons. The discussion sheds light on the broader implications of the ITT framework.
- Open Access
- 14 June 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Digital Experiences in Mathematics Education
- Vol. 10 (2) , 302-319
An Ode to a Mathematician: Commemorating Uri Leron
This is one of two contributions written to commemorate Professor Uri Leron, who became Associate Editor of what was then the International Journal for Computers and Mathematical Learning, a journal founded by Seymour Papert, and upon which Digital Experiences in Mathematics Education builds. One contribution includes memories from several current and former Editorial Board members. In this contribution, five former supervisees of Uri Leron share their stories.In addition to the personal and professional development of the storytellers, the stories reflect upon the distinguished career of Prof. Leron—a mathematician, an educator, a mentor and a colleague. These stories reflect a scholarly exchange devoted to the debate upon the nature of mathematical and computer science thinking and teaching. These topics are addressed from a variety of perspectives—cognitive, social and psychological—to highlight Uri’s interest in computing as a way to express and explore mathematical and logical ideas.
- 14 June 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Digital Experiences in Mathematics Education
- Vol. 10 (2) , 302-319
Open AccessAn Ode to a Mathematician: Commemorating Uri Leron
This is one of two contributions written to commemorate Professor Uri Leron, who became Associate Editor of what was then the International Journal for Computers and Mathematical Learning, a journal founded by Seymour Papert, and upon which Digital Experiences in Mathematics Education builds. One contribution includes memories from several current and former Editorial Board members. In this contribution, five former supervisees of Uri Leron share their stories.In addition to the personal and professional development of the storytellers, the stories reflect upon the distinguished career of Prof. Leron—a mathematician, an educator, a mentor and a colleague. These stories reflect a scholarly exchange devoted to the debate upon the nature of mathematical and computer science thinking and teaching. These topics are addressed from a variety of perspectives—cognitive, social and psychological—to highlight Uri’s interest in computing as a way to express and explore mathematical and logical ideas.
- Open Access
- 1 February 2024
- Published by University of Montana, Maureen and Mike Mansfield Library in The Mathematics Enthusiast
- Vol. 21 (1-2) , 443-458
On Convincing Power of Counterexamples
Despite plethora of research that attends to the convincing power of different types of proofs, research related to the convincing power of counterexamples is rather slim. In this paper we examine how prospective and practicing secondary school mathematics teachers respond to different types of counterexamples. The counterexamples were presented as products of students’ arguments, and the participants were asked to evaluate their correctness and comment on them. The counterexamples varied according to mathematical topic: algebra or geometry, and their explicitness. However, as we analyzed the data, we discovered that these distinctions were insufficient to explain why teachers accepted some counterexamples, but rejected others, with seemingly similar features. As we analyze the participants’ perceived transparency of different counterexamples, we employ various theoretical approaches that can advance our understanding of teachers’ conceptions of conviction with respect to counterexamples.
- 1 February 2024
- Published by University of Montana, Maureen and Mike Mansfield Library in The Mathematics Enthusiast
- Vol. 21 (1-2) , 443-458
Open AccessOn Convincing Power of Counterexamples
Despite plethora of research that attends to the convincing power of different types of proofs, research related to the convincing power of counterexamples is rather slim. In this paper we examine how prospective and practicing secondary school mathematics teachers respond to different types of counterexamples. The counterexamples were presented as products of students’ arguments, and the participants were asked to evaluate their correctness and comment on them. The counterexamples varied according to mathematical topic: algebra or geometry, and their explicitness. However, as we analyzed the data, we discovered that these distinctions were insufficient to explain why teachers accepted some counterexamples, but rejected others, with seemingly similar features. As we analyze the participants’ perceived transparency of different counterexamples, we employ various theoretical approaches that can advance our understanding of teachers’ conceptions of conviction with respect to counterexamples.
- Open Access
- 24 May 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in ZDM – Mathematics Education
- Vol. 55 (4) , 719-736
Making university mathematics matter for secondary teacher preparation
Internationally, questions about the perceived utility of university mathematics for teaching school mathematics pose an ongoing challenge for secondary mathematics teacher education. This special issue is dedicated to exploring this topic and related issues in the preparation of secondary mathematics teachers—by which we mean teachers of students with ages, approximately, of 12–18 years. This article introduces this theme and provides a semi-systematic survey of recent related literature, which we use to elaborate and situate important theoretical distinctions around the problems, challenges, and solutions of university mathematics in relation to teacher education. As part of the special issue, we have gathered articles from different countries that elaborate theoretical and empirical approaches, which, collectively, describe different ways to strengthen university mathematics with respect to the aims of secondary teacher education. This survey paper serves to lay out the theoretical groundwork for the collection of articles in the issue.
- 24 May 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in ZDM – Mathematics Education
- Vol. 55 (4) , 719-736
Open AccessMaking university mathematics matter for secondary teacher preparation
Internationally, questions about the perceived utility of university mathematics for teaching school mathematics pose an ongoing challenge for secondary mathematics teacher education. This special issue is dedicated to exploring this topic and related issues in the preparation of secondary mathematics teachers—by which we mean teachers of students with ages, approximately, of 12–18 years. This article introduces this theme and provides a semi-systematic survey of recent related literature, which we use to elaborate and situate important theoretical distinctions around the problems, challenges, and solutions of university mathematics in relation to teacher education. As part of the special issue, we have gathered articles from different countries that elaborate theoretical and empirical approaches, which, collectively, describe different ways to strengthen university mathematics with respect to the aims of secondary teacher education. This survey paper serves to lay out the theoretical groundwork for the collection of articles in the issue.
- Open Access
- 17 May 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in ZDM – Mathematics Education
- Vol. 55 (4) , 779-792
Preparing prospective secondary teachers to teach mathematical reasoning and proof: the case of the role of examples in proving
Mathematics teacher education programs in the United States are charged with preparing prospective secondary teachers (PSTs) to teach reasoning and proving across grade levels and mathematical topics. Although most programs require a course on proof, PSTs often perceive it as disconnected from their future classroom practice. Our design research project developed a capstone course Mathematical Reasoning and Proving for Secondary Teachers and systematically studied its effect on PSTs’ content and pedagogical knowledge specific to proof. This paper focuses on one course module—Quantification and the Role of Examples in Proving, a topic which poses persistent difficulties to students and teachers alike. The analysis suggests that after the course, PSTs’ content and pedagogical knowledge of the role of examples in proving increased. We provide evidence from multiple data sources: pre-and post-questionnaires, PSTs’ responses to the in-class activities, their lesson plans, reflections on lesson enactment, and self-report. We discuss design principles that supported PSTs’ learning and their applicability beyond the study context.
- 17 May 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in ZDM – Mathematics Education
- Vol. 55 (4) , 779-792
Open AccessPreparing prospective secondary teachers to teach mathematical reasoning and proof: the case of the role of examples in proving
Mathematics teacher education programs in the United States are charged with preparing prospective secondary teachers (PSTs) to teach reasoning and proving across grade levels and mathematical topics. Although most programs require a course on proof, PSTs often perceive it as disconnected from their future classroom practice. Our design research project developed a capstone course Mathematical Reasoning and Proving for Secondary Teachers and systematically studied its effect on PSTs’ content and pedagogical knowledge specific to proof. This paper focuses on one course module—Quantification and the Role of Examples in Proving, a topic which poses persistent difficulties to students and teachers alike. The analysis suggests that after the course, PSTs’ content and pedagogical knowledge of the role of examples in proving increased. We provide evidence from multiple data sources: pre-and post-questionnaires, PSTs’ responses to the in-class activities, their lesson plans, reflections on lesson enactment, and self-report. We discuss design principles that supported PSTs’ learning and their applicability beyond the study context.
- 22 October 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in International Journal of Research in Undergraduate Mathematics Education
- Vol. 10 (1) , 255-283
Mathematical Knowledge for Teaching Proof: Comparing Secondary Teachers, Pre-Service Secondary Teachers, and Undergraduate Majors
- 22 October 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in International Journal of Research in Undergraduate Mathematics Education
- Vol. 10 (1) , 255-283
Mathematical Knowledge for Teaching Proof: Comparing Secondary Teachers, Pre-Service Secondary Teachers, and Undergraduate Majors