Comparing the effectiveness of using generic and specific search terms in electronic databases to identify health outcomes for a systematic review: a prospective comparative study of literature search methods
Authors:
- Matt EganMEMatt Egan
- Alice MacLeanAMAlice MacLean
- Helen SweetingHSHelen Sweeting
- Kate HuntKHKate Hunt
Open Access
Abstract
Objective To compare the effectiveness of systematic review literature searches that use either generic or specific terms for health outcomes. Design Prospective comparative study of two electronic literature search strategies. The ‘generic’ search included general terms for health such as ‘adolescent health’, ‘health status’, ‘morbidity’, etc. The ‘specific’ search focused on terms for a range of specific illnesses, such as ‘headache’, ‘epilepsy’, ‘diabetes mellitus’, etc. Data sources The authors searched Medline, Embase, the Cumulative Index to Nursing and Allied Health Literature, PsycINFO and the Education Resources Information Center for studies published in English between 1992 and April 2010. Main outcome measures Number and proportion of studies included in the systematic review that were identified from each search. Results The two searches tended to identify different studies. Of 41 studies included in the final review, only three (7%) were identified by both search strategies, 21 (51%) were identified by the generic search only and 17 (41%) were identified by the specific search only. 5 of the 41 studies were also identified through manual searching methods. Studies identified by the two ELS differed in terms of reported health outcomes, while each ELS uniquely identified some of the review's higher quality studies. Conclusions Electronic literature searches (ELS) are a vital stage in conducting systematic reviews and therefore have an important role in attempts to inform and improve policy and practice with the best available evidence. While the use of both generic and specific health terms is conventional for many reviewers and information scientists, there are also reviews that rely solely on either generic or specific terms. Based on the findings, reliance on only the generic or specific approach could increase the risk of systematic reviews missing important evidence and, consequently, misinforming decision makers. However, future research should test the generalisability of these findings.Keywords
This publication has 26 references indexed in Scilit:
- The health and socioeconomic impacts of major multi-sport events: systematic review (1978-2008)BMJ, 2010
- Systematic review of epidemiological studies on health effects associated with management of solid wasteEnvironmental Health, 2009
- Real world reviews: a beginner's guide to undertaking systematic reviews of public health policy interventionsJournal of Epidemiology and Community Health, 2009
- Health effects of relocation following disaster: a systematic review of the literatureDisasters, 2008
- “A hard day’s night?” The effects of Compressed Working Week interventions on the health and work-life balance of shift workers: a systematic reviewJournal of Epidemiology and Community Health, 2008
- “Profits before people”? A systematic review of the health and safety impacts of privatising public utilities and industries in developed countriesJournal of Epidemiology and Community Health, 2007
- Effects of Soft Drink Consumption on Nutrition and Health: A Systematic Review and Meta-AnalysisAmerican Journal of Public Health, 2007
- A systematic review of empirical research on self-reported racism and healthInternational Journal of Epidemiology, 2006
- Systematic reviews of health effects of social interventions: 1. Finding the evidence: how far should you go?: Table 1Journal of Epidemiology and Community Health, 2005
- Optimal search strategies for retrieving systematic reviews from Medline: analytical surveyBMJ, 2004