The Pseudo-Confidence Paradox: The Epistemic Gap in Everyday AI Use
Authors:
- Lyazzat Tulbayevna KurmanbayevaLKLyazzat Tulbayevna Kurmanbayeva
- Anar Saduakasovna TanabayevaATAnar Saduakasovna Tanabayeva
- Akmaral Ivanovna DoszhanovaADAkmaral Ivanovna Doszhanova
- Aidyn Aidaruly OlzhashovAOAidyn Aidaruly Olzhashov
- Denis BakarassovDBDenis Bakarassov
- Adilbek Knarovich BisenbaevABAdilbek Knarovich Bisenbaev
Open Access
- 16 June 2026
- journal article
- research article
- Published by MDPI AG in Philosophies
- Vol. 11 (3) , 97
Abstract
This study examines the phenomenon of pseudoconfident knowledge in the context of the everyday use of generative artificial intelligence. By pseudoconfident knowledge, we mean a response that is substantively plausible, rhetorically coherent, and outwardly persuasive but is treated and understood as knowledge before its actual reliability has been established. Of course, we do not use the term “pseudoconfident knowledge” to denote knowledge in the strict epistemological sense. Rather, it denotes a special form of AI-generated content that acquires the status of knowledge in the user’s perception before its reliability, source-based justification, or factual correctness have been established. The problem here is not that such an answer is already knowledge but that it is prematurely accepted as knowledge because of its coherence, completeness, and rhetorical confidence. The aim of the study is to identify the epistemic gap between the everyday operational integration of artificial intelligence and the user’s critical ability to distinguish between persuasiveness and justification. The theoretical framework combines approaches to AI literacy, epistemic vigilance, and contemporary forms of digital mediation in the circulation of knowledge. The empirical basis of the study is an online survey of AI users. The analysis was conducted using descriptive statistics, contingency tables, and methods for testing associations between categorical variables. The results show that the key differentiating factor is not the frequency of AI use, but the strategy used in handling its responses. More epistemically robust positions are associated with practices of comparison, editing, and verification, whereas uncritical acceptance of the answer is associated with greater vulnerability to pseudoconfident knowledge. We conclude that the spread of generative artificial intelligence is producing a new socioepistemic problem that calls for a shift in emphasis from simple instrumental literacy toward a culture of verification, doubt, and epistemic responsibility.Keywords
All Related Versions
This publication has 34 references indexed in Scilit:
- Beyond tool use: Tracking the evolution of generative AI literacy among university students through a process-oriented investigationComputers and Education: Artificial Intelligence, 2025
- A taxonomy of epistemic injustice in the context of AI and the case for generative hermeneutical erasureAI and Ethics, 2025
- Transmitting Understanding: Imitation, Transformation and Delayed Epistemic VigilanceErkenntnis, 2025
- Critical GenAI Literacy: Postdigital ConfigurationsPostdigital Science and Education, 2025
- Large language models (LLMs) and the institutionalization of misinformationTrends in Cognitive Sciences, 2024
- AI models collapse when trained on recursively generated dataNature, 2024
- Detecting hallucinations in large language models using semantic entropyNature, 2024
- AI literacy for users – A comprehensive review and future research directions of learning methods, components, and effectsComputers in Human Behavior: Artificial Humans, 2024
- Conceptualizing AI literacy: An exploratory reviewComputers and Education: Artificial Intelligence, 2021
- A classification of illocutionary actsLanguage in Society, 1976