Eldar Knar
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Eldar Knar has a total of 26 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
A. M. Saletskii
4 shared publicationsL. V. Levshin
M. V. Lomonosov Moscow State University
4 shared publicationsA.M. Saletsky
2 shared publications- Akmaral Ivanovna Doszhanova
Faculty of Philosophy and Political Science, Al-Farabi Kazakh National University, Almaty 050040, Kazakhstan
2 shared publications Altynsarin National Academy Of Education
2 shared publications- Anar Saduakasovna Tanabayeva
Department of Media Communication and History of Kazakhstan, International Information Technology University, Almaty 050040, Kazakhstan
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 17 August 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Humanities and Social Sciences Communications
Recursive introversion, iterative extroversion and transitive ambiversion
- 17 August 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in Humanities and Social Sciences Communications
Open AccessRecursive introversion, iterative extroversion and transitive ambiversion
- Open Access
- 13 August 2026
- Published by Manuscript Technomedia LLP in Journal of Scientometric Research
- Vol. 15 (2) , 452-464
Logic of Scientific Readiness: Constraints, Conflicts, and Pathways of Transformation
Existing models of scientific maturity and readiness help position research systems on a developmental scale, but they often remain descriptive and provide limited insight into the structural causes of stagnation and uneven advancement. This study proposes the TOC-SRL integrative model, combining the logical trees of the Theory of Constraints (TOC) with the level-based framework of Scientific Readiness Levels (SRL). The study is based on the conceptual adaptation of five TOC trees-the Current Reality Tree, Conflict Cloud, Future Reality Tree, Prerequisite Tree, and Transition Tree-to the logic of SRL. The analysis relies on conceptual reconstruction, documentary analysis, and case-based interpretation, using material from Kazakhstan’s national science system and the digital transformation of science and higher education. The TOC-SRL model makes it possible to move from descriptive accounts of science policy to a more systemic analysis of constraints, institutional conflicts, maturity conditions, and transition pathways within research ecosystems. The findings suggest that scientific readiness can be interpreted not only as a position on a scale, but also as a causally structured condition shaped by deeper institutional and developmental limitations. The proposed approach extends SRL from a static maturity scale into a dynamic framework for causal diagnosis and transformation-oriented analysis. It offers a structured way to connect readiness assessment with the identification of constraints, conflict resolution, and developmental sequencing in scientific systems.
- 13 August 2026
- Published by Manuscript Technomedia LLP in Journal of Scientometric Research
- Vol. 15 (2) , 452-464
Open AccessLogic of Scientific Readiness: Constraints, Conflicts, and Pathways of Transformation
Existing models of scientific maturity and readiness help position research systems on a developmental scale, but they often remain descriptive and provide limited insight into the structural causes of stagnation and uneven advancement. This study proposes the TOC-SRL integrative model, combining the logical trees of the Theory of Constraints (TOC) with the level-based framework of Scientific Readiness Levels (SRL). The study is based on the conceptual adaptation of five TOC trees-the Current Reality Tree, Conflict Cloud, Future Reality Tree, Prerequisite Tree, and Transition Tree-to the logic of SRL. The analysis relies on conceptual reconstruction, documentary analysis, and case-based interpretation, using material from Kazakhstan’s national science system and the digital transformation of science and higher education. The TOC-SRL model makes it possible to move from descriptive accounts of science policy to a more systemic analysis of constraints, institutional conflicts, maturity conditions, and transition pathways within research ecosystems. The findings suggest that scientific readiness can be interpreted not only as a position on a scale, but also as a causally structured condition shaped by deeper institutional and developmental limitations. The proposed approach extends SRL from a static maturity scale into a dynamic framework for causal diagnosis and transformation-oriented analysis. It offers a structured way to connect readiness assessment with the identification of constraints, conflict resolution, and developmental sequencing in scientific systems.
- Open Access
- 14 July 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in Publications
- Vol. 14 (3) , 44
A Level-Based Master Plan for Strengthening Research Projects
This paper proposes a level-based scientific maturation master plan (SMMP) for strengthening research projects prior to manuscript submission. A weak manuscript is often not simply a weak text but an immature project that has been translated too early into publication form. Contemporary research management is better at registering deadlines, deliverables, resources, and visible publication signals than at diagnosing the internal maturity of a scientific object. The result is false readiness: a project may have a topic, structure, literature, methodological vocabulary, and a polished manuscript but still lack a mature problem, a coherent conceptual architecture, a testable design, sufficient evidence, and a disciplined contribution. To address this gap, this paper proposes a nine-level SMMP, moving from thematic impulses to peer review and publication readiness. The model integrates noncompensatory gates, evidence packages, red flags, maturation debt, bottlenecks, the publication maturation gap, and peer-review readiness. Methodologically, the paper is a conceptual design study supplemented by a proof-of-concept documentary application to publicly available CORDIS project biographies. The framework shows how to distinguish publication polish from scientific maturation and how to translate expert criticism into concrete presubmission actions.
- 14 July 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in Publications
- Vol. 14 (3) , 44
Open AccessA Level-Based Master Plan for Strengthening Research Projects
This paper proposes a level-based scientific maturation master plan (SMMP) for strengthening research projects prior to manuscript submission. A weak manuscript is often not simply a weak text but an immature project that has been translated too early into publication form. Contemporary research management is better at registering deadlines, deliverables, resources, and visible publication signals than at diagnosing the internal maturity of a scientific object. The result is false readiness: a project may have a topic, structure, literature, methodological vocabulary, and a polished manuscript but still lack a mature problem, a coherent conceptual architecture, a testable design, sufficient evidence, and a disciplined contribution. To address this gap, this paper proposes a nine-level SMMP, moving from thematic impulses to peer review and publication readiness. The model integrates noncompensatory gates, evidence packages, red flags, maturation debt, bottlenecks, the publication maturation gap, and peer-review readiness. Methodologically, the paper is a conceptual design study supplemented by a proof-of-concept documentary application to publicly available CORDIS project biographies. The framework shows how to distinguish publication polish from scientific maturation and how to translate expert criticism into concrete presubmission actions.
- Open Access
- 16 June 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in Philosophies
- Vol. 11 (3) , 97
The Pseudo-Confidence Paradox: The Epistemic Gap in Everyday AI Use
This study examines the phenomenon of pseudoconfident knowledge in the context of the everyday use of generative artificial intelligence. By pseudoconfident knowledge, we mean a response that is substantively plausible, rhetorically coherent, and outwardly persuasive but is treated and understood as knowledge before its actual reliability has been established. Of course, we do not use the term “pseudoconfident knowledge” to denote knowledge in the strict epistemological sense. Rather, it denotes a special form of AI-generated content that acquires the status of knowledge in the user’s perception before its reliability, source-based justification, or factual correctness have been established. The problem here is not that such an answer is already knowledge but that it is prematurely accepted as knowledge because of its coherence, completeness, and rhetorical confidence. The aim of the study is to identify the epistemic gap between the everyday operational integration of artificial intelligence and the user’s critical ability to distinguish between persuasiveness and justification. The theoretical framework combines approaches to AI literacy, epistemic vigilance, and contemporary forms of digital mediation in the circulation of knowledge. The empirical basis of the study is an online survey of AI users. The analysis was conducted using descriptive statistics, contingency tables, and methods for testing associations between categorical variables. The results show that the key differentiating factor is not the frequency of AI use, but the strategy used in handling its responses. More epistemically robust positions are associated with practices of comparison, editing, and verification, whereas uncritical acceptance of the answer is associated with greater vulnerability to pseudoconfident knowledge. We conclude that the spread of generative artificial intelligence is producing a new socioepistemic problem that calls for a shift in emphasis from simple instrumental literacy toward a culture of verification, doubt, and epistemic responsibility.
- 16 June 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in Philosophies
- Vol. 11 (3) , 97
Open AccessThe Pseudo-Confidence Paradox: The Epistemic Gap in Everyday AI Use
This study examines the phenomenon of pseudoconfident knowledge in the context of the everyday use of generative artificial intelligence. By pseudoconfident knowledge, we mean a response that is substantively plausible, rhetorically coherent, and outwardly persuasive but is treated and understood as knowledge before its actual reliability has been established. Of course, we do not use the term “pseudoconfident knowledge” to denote knowledge in the strict epistemological sense. Rather, it denotes a special form of AI-generated content that acquires the status of knowledge in the user’s perception before its reliability, source-based justification, or factual correctness have been established. The problem here is not that such an answer is already knowledge but that it is prematurely accepted as knowledge because of its coherence, completeness, and rhetorical confidence. The aim of the study is to identify the epistemic gap between the everyday operational integration of artificial intelligence and the user’s critical ability to distinguish between persuasiveness and justification. The theoretical framework combines approaches to AI literacy, epistemic vigilance, and contemporary forms of digital mediation in the circulation of knowledge. The empirical basis of the study is an online survey of AI users. The analysis was conducted using descriptive statistics, contingency tables, and methods for testing associations between categorical variables. The results show that the key differentiating factor is not the frequency of AI use, but the strategy used in handling its responses. More epistemically robust positions are associated with practices of comparison, editing, and verification, whereas uncritical acceptance of the answer is associated with greater vulnerability to pseudoconfident knowledge. We conclude that the spread of generative artificial intelligence is producing a new socioepistemic problem that calls for a shift in emphasis from simple instrumental literacy toward a culture of verification, doubt, and epistemic responsibility.
- Open Access
- 19 May 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
The Pseudo-Confidence Paradox: The Epistemic Gap in Everyday AI Use
This study examines the phenomenon of pseudoconfident knowledge in the context of the everyday use of generative artificial intelligence. By pseudoconfident knowledge, we mean a response that is substantively plausible, rhetorically coherent, and outwardly persuasive but is treated and understood as knowledge before its actual reliability has been established. Of course, we do not use the term “pseudoconfident knowledge” to denote knowledge in the strict epistemological sense. Rather, it denotes a special form of AI-generated content that acquires the status of knowledge in the user’s perception before its reliability, source-based justification, or factual correctness have been established. The problem here is not that such an answer is already knowledge but that it is prematurely accepted as knowledge because of its coherence, completeness, and rhetorical confidence. The aim of the study is to identify the epistemic gap between the everyday operational integration of artificial intelligence and the user’s critical ability to distinguish between persuasiveness and justification. The theoretical framework combines approaches to AI literacy, epistemic vigilance, and contemporary forms of digital mediation in the circulation of knowledge. The empirical basis of the study is an online survey of AI users. The analysis was conducted using descriptive statistics, contingency tables, and methods for testing associations between categorical variables. The results show that the key differentiating factor is not the frequency of AI use but the strategy used in handling its responses. More epistemically robust positions are associated with practices of comparison, editing, and verification, whereas uncritical acceptance of the answer is associated with greater vulnerability to pseudoconfident knowledge. We conclude that the spread of generative artificial intelligence is producing a new socioepistemic problem that calls for a shift in emphasis from simple instrumental literacy toward a culture of verification, doubt, and epistemic responsibility.
- 19 May 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
Open AccessThe Pseudo-Confidence Paradox: The Epistemic Gap in Everyday AI Use
This study examines the phenomenon of pseudoconfident knowledge in the context of the everyday use of generative artificial intelligence. By pseudoconfident knowledge, we mean a response that is substantively plausible, rhetorically coherent, and outwardly persuasive but is treated and understood as knowledge before its actual reliability has been established. Of course, we do not use the term “pseudoconfident knowledge” to denote knowledge in the strict epistemological sense. Rather, it denotes a special form of AI-generated content that acquires the status of knowledge in the user’s perception before its reliability, source-based justification, or factual correctness have been established. The problem here is not that such an answer is already knowledge but that it is prematurely accepted as knowledge because of its coherence, completeness, and rhetorical confidence. The aim of the study is to identify the epistemic gap between the everyday operational integration of artificial intelligence and the user’s critical ability to distinguish between persuasiveness and justification. The theoretical framework combines approaches to AI literacy, epistemic vigilance, and contemporary forms of digital mediation in the circulation of knowledge. The empirical basis of the study is an online survey of AI users. The analysis was conducted using descriptive statistics, contingency tables, and methods for testing associations between categorical variables. The results show that the key differentiating factor is not the frequency of AI use but the strategy used in handling its responses. More epistemically robust positions are associated with practices of comparison, editing, and verification, whereas uncritical acceptance of the answer is associated with greater vulnerability to pseudoconfident knowledge. We conclude that the spread of generative artificial intelligence is producing a new socioepistemic problem that calls for a shift in emphasis from simple instrumental literacy toward a culture of verification, doubt, and epistemic responsibility.
- 11 March 2026
- Published by Wiley in Systems Research and Behavioral Science
- Vol. 43 (4) , 1331-1343
The Great Question of the State: Why a Country Is Resilient Even With the Most Incompetent Governance
This study analyses the paradox of state resilience under incompetent governance. The work substantiates the hypothesis that the resilience of political systems is ensured not by the efficiency of leadership but by institutional inertia, social adaptivity and societal stratification. A nonlinear mathematical model of the dynamics of state resilience is constructed, taking into account the factors of managerial incompetence, societal adaptivity, institutional memory and external stochastic disturbances. Numerical simulations are performed via the Monte Carlo method, and the phase transitions of resilience are analysed. Special attention is given to the role of the middle class as an attractor of stability, and the structure of ‘meaningless resilience’ is described, in which the state maintains order despite managerial degradation. Philosophical and systemic aspects of the phenomenon of institutional immortality are discussed. The key results demonstrate that state resilience can be interpreted as a function of the structural connectedness of society and the inertia of institutions rather than the quality of governance. This work reveals the fundamental mechanisms of the long‐term stability of political systems under conditions of managerial competence degradation.
- 11 March 2026
- Published by Wiley in Systems Research and Behavioral Science
- Vol. 43 (4) , 1331-1343
The Great Question of the State: Why a Country Is Resilient Even With the Most Incompetent Governance
This study analyses the paradox of state resilience under incompetent governance. The work substantiates the hypothesis that the resilience of political systems is ensured not by the efficiency of leadership but by institutional inertia, social adaptivity and societal stratification. A nonlinear mathematical model of the dynamics of state resilience is constructed, taking into account the factors of managerial incompetence, societal adaptivity, institutional memory and external stochastic disturbances. Numerical simulations are performed via the Monte Carlo method, and the phase transitions of resilience are analysed. Special attention is given to the role of the middle class as an attractor of stability, and the structure of ‘meaningless resilience’ is described, in which the state maintains order despite managerial degradation. Philosophical and systemic aspects of the phenomenon of institutional immortality are discussed. The key results demonstrate that state resilience can be interpreted as a function of the structural connectedness of society and the inertia of institutions rather than the quality of governance. This work reveals the fundamental mechanisms of the long‐term stability of political systems under conditions of managerial competence degradation.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 27 January 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in Philosophies
- Vol. 11 (1) , 12
Scientific Artificial Intelligence: From a Procedural Toolkit to Cognitive Coauthorship
This article proposes a redefinition of scientific authorship under conditions of algorithmic mediation. We shift the discussion from the ontological dichotomy of “tool versus author” to an operationalizable epistemology of contribution. Building on the philosophical triad of instrumentality—intervention, representation, and hermeneutics—we argue that contemporary AI systems (notably large language models, LLMs) exceed the role of a merely “mute” accelerator of procedures. They now participate in the generation of explanatory structures, the reframing of research problems, and the semantic reconfiguration of the knowledge corpus. In response, we formulate the AI-AUTHorship framework, which remains compatible with an anthropocentric legal order while recognizing and measuring AI’s cognitive participation. We introduce TraceAuth, a protocol for tracing cognitive chains of reasoning, and AIEIS (AI epistemic impact score), a metric that stratifies contributions along the axes of procedural (P), semantic (S), and generative (G) participation. The threshold between “support” and “creation” is refined through a battery of operational tests (alteration of the problem space; causal/counterfactual load; independent reproducibility without AI; interpretability and traceability). We describe authorship as distributed epistemic authorship (DEA): a network of people, artifacts, algorithms, and institutions in which AI functions as a nonsubjective node whose contribution is nonetheless auditable. The framework closes the gap between the de facto involvement of AI and de jure norms by institutionalizing a regime of “recognized participation,” wherein transparency, interpretability, and reproducibility of cognitive trajectories become conditions for acknowledging contribution, whereas human responsibility remains nonnegotiable.
- 27 January 2026
- Published by MDPI AG in Philosophies
- Vol. 11 (1) , 12
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessScientific Artificial Intelligence: From a Procedural Toolkit to Cognitive Coauthorship
This article proposes a redefinition of scientific authorship under conditions of algorithmic mediation. We shift the discussion from the ontological dichotomy of “tool versus author” to an operationalizable epistemology of contribution. Building on the philosophical triad of instrumentality—intervention, representation, and hermeneutics—we argue that contemporary AI systems (notably large language models, LLMs) exceed the role of a merely “mute” accelerator of procedures. They now participate in the generation of explanatory structures, the reframing of research problems, and the semantic reconfiguration of the knowledge corpus. In response, we formulate the AI-AUTHorship framework, which remains compatible with an anthropocentric legal order while recognizing and measuring AI’s cognitive participation. We introduce TraceAuth, a protocol for tracing cognitive chains of reasoning, and AIEIS (AI epistemic impact score), a metric that stratifies contributions along the axes of procedural (P), semantic (S), and generative (G) participation. The threshold between “support” and “creation” is refined through a battery of operational tests (alteration of the problem space; causal/counterfactual load; independent reproducibility without AI; interpretability and traceability). We describe authorship as distributed epistemic authorship (DEA): a network of people, artifacts, algorithms, and institutions in which AI functions as a nonsubjective node whose contribution is nonetheless auditable. The framework closes the gap between the de facto involvement of AI and de jure norms by institutionalizing a regime of “recognized participation,” wherein transparency, interpretability, and reproducibility of cognitive trajectories become conditions for acknowledging contribution, whereas human responsibility remains nonnegotiable.
- Open Access
- 20 November 2025
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Preprints
Strategic Readiness Levels for Digital Health (Preprint)
UNSTRUCTURED This article introduces the strategic readiness level for digital health (SRL-DH), conceptualized as a multidimensional strategic scale for assessing the readiness of digital health systems. The framework integrates seven critical dimensions: the cognitive maturity of regulators, interorganizational coordination, data readiness, stakeholder synergy, strategic risk, technological fragmentation, and epidemiological volatility.
- 20 November 2025
- Published by JMIR Publications Inc. in JMIR Preprints
Open AccessStrategic Readiness Levels for Digital Health (Preprint)
UNSTRUCTURED This article introduces the strategic readiness level for digital health (SRL-DH), conceptualized as a multidimensional strategic scale for assessing the readiness of digital health systems. The framework integrates seven critical dimensions: the cognitive maturity of regulators, interorganizational coordination, data readiness, stakeholder synergy, strategic risk, technological fragmentation, and epidemiological volatility.
- Open Access
- 10 November 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Publications
- Vol. 13 (4) , 57
Integrating Scientific Readiness and Added Scientific Value: A Multiplicative Conceptual Model for Research Assessment
Modern approaches to research assessment often treat two independent dimensions: the degree of readiness (the progress of scientific maturity) and the Added Scientific Value (novelty, rigor, reproducibility, and societal significance). The present study aims to develop an integrative model that links the stepwise logic of Scientific Readiness Levels (SRLs) with the continuous evaluation of Added Scientific Value (ASV). To achieve this, we construct a two-dimensional quantitative framework, SRL × ASV, in which discrete readiness levels are combined with the multiplicative aggregation of normalized qualitative indicators—including novelty, rigor, reproducibility, openness, impact, and collaboration. Advancement to a higher readiness level becomes possible only when the evidential criteria are simultaneously satisfied and the ASV threshold value is reached. The model is formally defined and illustrated via the example of Kazakhstan’s national science funding system. The results demonstrate that the integration of SRL and ASV creates a reproducible and transparent decision-making structure in which weak components cannot be compensated by strong ones, and excessive dependence on purely metric-based evaluations is eliminated. By uniting maturity and quality within a single coherent system, the SRL + ASV model bridges the gap between developmental staging and scientific value, transforming research assessment into a transparent, evidence-based, and continuously improvable process applicable to the governance of responsible and reproducible science.
- 10 November 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Publications
- Vol. 13 (4) , 57
Open AccessIntegrating Scientific Readiness and Added Scientific Value: A Multiplicative Conceptual Model for Research Assessment
Modern approaches to research assessment often treat two independent dimensions: the degree of readiness (the progress of scientific maturity) and the Added Scientific Value (novelty, rigor, reproducibility, and societal significance). The present study aims to develop an integrative model that links the stepwise logic of Scientific Readiness Levels (SRLs) with the continuous evaluation of Added Scientific Value (ASV). To achieve this, we construct a two-dimensional quantitative framework, SRL × ASV, in which discrete readiness levels are combined with the multiplicative aggregation of normalized qualitative indicators—including novelty, rigor, reproducibility, openness, impact, and collaboration. Advancement to a higher readiness level becomes possible only when the evidential criteria are simultaneously satisfied and the ASV threshold value is reached. The model is formally defined and illustrated via the example of Kazakhstan’s national science funding system. The results demonstrate that the integration of SRL and ASV creates a reproducible and transparent decision-making structure in which weak components cannot be compensated by strong ones, and excessive dependence on purely metric-based evaluations is eliminated. By uniting maturity and quality within a single coherent system, the SRL + ASV model bridges the gap between developmental staging and scientific value, transforming research assessment into a transparent, evidence-based, and continuously improvable process applicable to the governance of responsible and reproducible science.
- Open Access
- 9 April 2025
- Published by Center for Open Science in SocArXiv
Dynamics of Insect Paraintelligence: How a Mindless Colony of Ants Meaningfully Moves a Beetle
In this work, a new concept called Vector Dissipation of Randomness (VDR) is developed and formalized. It describes the mechanism by which complex multicomponent systems transition from chaos to order through the filtering of random directions, accumulation of information in the environment, and self-organization of agents. VDR explains how individual random strategies can evolve into collective goal-directed behavior, leading to the emergence of an ordered structure without centralized control.To test the proposed model, a numerical simulation of the "ant–beetle" system was conducted, in which agents (ants) randomly choose movement directions, but through feedback mechanisms and filtering of weak strategies, they form a single coordinated vector of the beetle's movement.VDR is a universal mechanism applicable to a wide range of self-organizing systems, including biological populations, decentralized technological networks, sociological processes, and artificial intelligence algorithms.For the first time, an equation of the normalized emergence function in the processing of vector dissipation of randomness in the Ant–Beetle system has been formulated.The concept of paraintelligence was introduced for the first time. Insect paraintelligence is interpreted as a rational functionality that is close to or equivalent to intelligent activity in the absence of reflexive consciousness and self-awareness.
- 9 April 2025
- Published by Center for Open Science in SocArXiv
Open AccessDynamics of Insect Paraintelligence: How a Mindless Colony of Ants Meaningfully Moves a Beetle
In this work, a new concept called Vector Dissipation of Randomness (VDR) is developed and formalized. It describes the mechanism by which complex multicomponent systems transition from chaos to order through the filtering of random directions, accumulation of information in the environment, and self-organization of agents. VDR explains how individual random strategies can evolve into collective goal-directed behavior, leading to the emergence of an ordered structure without centralized control.To test the proposed model, a numerical simulation of the "ant–beetle" system was conducted, in which agents (ants) randomly choose movement directions, but through feedback mechanisms and filtering of weak strategies, they form a single coordinated vector of the beetle's movement.VDR is a universal mechanism applicable to a wide range of self-organizing systems, including biological populations, decentralized technological networks, sociological processes, and artificial intelligence algorithms.For the first time, an equation of the normalized emergence function in the processing of vector dissipation of randomness in the Ant–Beetle system has been formulated.The concept of paraintelligence was introduced for the first time. Insect paraintelligence is interpreted as a rational functionality that is close to or equivalent to intelligent activity in the absence of reflexive consciousness and self-awareness.