PERFORMANCE ANALYSIS FOR THE ORGANIZATION OF TURKIC STATES MEMBER COUNTRIES IN THE CONTEXT OF POWER ELEMENTS AND SUGGESTIONS IN TERMS OF SMART POWER
Open Access
- 15 June 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Canakkale Onsekiz Mart University in Management and Political Sciences Review
- Vol. 5 (1) , 55-80
Abstract
The main problematics of this article are the accelerated transformation in power, the emergence of new power elements, and the lack of quantitative power performance analyses in the context of the Turkic World. In this direction, it is aimed to evaluate the performance of the Organization of Turkic States member countries Azerbaijan, Kazakhstan, Kyrgyzstan, Uzbekistan, and Turkey, based on the elements of hard and soft power. This study focuses on the transformation in the concept of power. It combines theoretical and quantitative analyses for power resources, and country performance analysis was carried out with ARAS (Additive Ratio Assessment), one of the effective Multi-Criteria Decision Making methods. The main theoretical results reached; that hard power alone is no longer sufficient, and in the new world conditions, structuring in line with smart power is inevitable. The main quantitative results reached by power performance evaluations for countries are; States other than Turkey are quite inadequate in soft power, and these countries are better in hard power performance than soft power, contrary to the post-cold war conditions. However, today, the strategy at the forefront of political power is to focus on soft power. All these are essential shortcomings in terms of smart power potential.Keywords
This publication has 25 references indexed in Scilit:
- Comparing the intensity of scrutiny for ‘domestic’ and implementing bills: does transposition of EU law reduce political contestation in national parliaments?Journal of European Public Policy, 2016
- I Will Follow: Smart Power and the Management of Wartime AlliancesJournal of Strategic Studies, 2015
- Smart Power and Japan’s Self-Defense ForcesJournal of Strategic Studies, 2015
- Political Power and Policy Design: Why Are Policy Alternatives Constrained?Policy Studies Journal, 2014
- Imperial power Europe? The EU’s relations with the ACP countriesJournal of Political Power, 2013
- Smart Power? Health Interventions for Strategic Effect in Iraq and AfghanistanInternational Political Sociology, 2012
- Maximizing Influence in the European Union after the Lisbon Treaty: From Small State Policy to Smart State StrategyJournal of European Integration, 2011
- A NEW ADDITIVE RATIO ASSESSMENT (ARAS) METHOD IN MULTICRITERIA DECISION‐MAKING / NAUJAS ADITYVINIS KRITERIJŲ SANTYKIŲ ĮVERTINIMO METODAS (ARAS) DAUGIAKRITERINIAMS UŽDAVINIAMS SPRĘSTITechnological and Economic Development of Economy, 2010
- Smart power in reunified GermanyJournal of Power, 2008
- Hard Power, Soft Power, Smart PowerThe Annals of the American Academy of Political and Social Science, 2008