Comparing morphological and molecular methods for stream macroinvertebrate biodiversity assessment across seven watersheds in the southern United States
Authors:
- Daniel C. AllenDADaniel C. Allen
- Zacchaeus G. CompsonZacchaeus G. Compson
- Chelsea SmithCSChelsea Smith
- Michael T. BoganMBMichael T. Bogan
- Lindsey E. Vande StreekLSLindsey E. Vande Streek
- Kaley CaveKCKaley Cave
- Arial ShogrenASArial Shogren
- Carla L. AtkinsonCACarla L. Atkinson
- Brian A. GillBGBrian A. Gill
- Luiza Gonçalves LazzaroLLLuiza Gonçalves Lazzaro
- Fagbohun IbrahimFIFagbohun Ibrahim
- Meryl C. MimsMMMeryl C. Mims
Preprint
Abstract
Freshwater biodiversity is declining at alarming rates globally, yet our capacity to monitor it depends heavily on the methods used for biodiversity assessment. Stream benthic macroinvertebrates are widely used as bioindicators, but traditional morphological identification is labor-intensive and limited by taxonomic expertise, while DNA metabarcoding offers a promising but incompletely evaluated alternative. Here, we compared biodiversity patterns detected by four macroinvertebrate sampling and identification methods (morphological identification of benthic samples, morphological identification of combined benthic and stream-edge samples, eDNA metabarcoding of bulk benthic samples, and eDNA metabarcoding of streamwater) across 62 sites in seven watersheds spanning the southern continental United States. We compared methods across three facets of biodiversity (gamma diversity, alpha diversity, and taxonomic composition) and three taxonomic levels (family, genus, and species). We found that which method detected more taxa shifted with taxonomic resolution: morphological methods detected more families and genera, while metabarcoding methods detected more species. Bulk benthic metabarcoding detected more families and genera than water eDNA metabarcoding, consistent with the “watered-down biodiversity” effect of DNA dilution in water samples, but the two metabarcoding methods did not differ significantly in species richness. All four methods detected largely distinct suites of taxa, with metabarcoding methods yielding more unique taxa than morphological methods. Notably, taxa uniquely detected by water eDNA were dominated by soft-bodied organisms (oligochaetes, leeches, earthworms) and water-column-associated taxa, while benthic eDNA uniquely detected hard-bodied EPT insects. We attribute this pattern to fundamental differences in eDNA shedding, transport, and deposition dynamics across organism types. These results demonstrate that no single method captures a complete picture of stream macroinvertebrate biodiversity, and that method choice should be guided by the taxonomic resolution and community components most relevant to the goals of the bioassessment program.Keywords
Funding Information
- US National Science Foundation (1802714)
- US National Science Foundation (1802766)
- US National Science Foundation (1802811)
- US National Science Foundation (2150626)
- US National Science Foundation (2207680)
- US National Science Foundation (2406856)
- United States Department of Agriculture (Project #PEN04817 and Accession #7003724)
This publication has 49 references indexed in Scilit:
- Rainfall has contrasting effects on aquatic and terrestrial environmental DNA recovered from streamsEcological Applications, 2026
- Cross-comparing different protocols for DNA metabarcoding of freshwater macroinvertebratesHydrobiologia, 2025
- Squishy and Crunchy Invasive Invertebrates: Environmental DNA Is Not Shed EquallyEnvironmental DNA, 2025
- DNA metabarcoding captures different macroinvertebrate biodiversity than morphological identification approaches across a continental scaleEnvironmental DNA, 2023
- DNAqua‐Net conference unites participants from around the world with the quest to standardize and implement DNA‐based aquatic biomonitoringEnvironmental DNA, 2021
- Stirring up the relationship between quantified environmental DNA concentrations and exoskeleton‐shedding invertebrate densitiesEnvironmental DNA, 2020
- Environmental DNA shedding and decay rates from diverse animal forms and thermal regimesEnvironmental DNA, 2020
- Why We Need Sustainable Networks Bridging Countries, Disciplines, Cultures and Generations for Aquatic Biomonitoring 2.0: A Perspective Derived From the DNAqua-Net COST Action2018
- An environmental DNA assay for detecting Arctic grayling in the upper Missouri River basin, North AmericaConservation Genetics Resources, 2016
- DNA (meta)barcoding of biological invasions: a powerful tool to elucidate invasion processes and help managing aliensBiological Invasions, 2015