Evaluation of anti-inflammatory properties on the surface of dental implants depending on the type of processing (Part 1)
Open Access
- 22 April 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Zaporizhzhia State Medical and Pharmaceutical University in Pathologia
- Vol. 21 (1) , 14-22
Abstract
The aim. To study of the anti-inflammatory properties of the surface of commercial dental implants with different processing methods using the example of the course of the first stage of implantation. Materials and methods. Dental implants made of titanium with 3D Active and Xpeed surface treatment were used. The surface microstructure and biocompatibility of the samples, surface corrosion, elemental analysis of the surface was studied. The assessment of the severity of peri-implantitis and mucositis based on the depth of the peri-implant pocket and bleeding during probing, determination of the coefficient of stability of implants (KSI) is given. Median test (χ2), Kruskel–Wallis test (H), univariate variance analysis (F) were used for multiple comparison of samples. The difference in parameters was considered statistically significant at the p ≤ 0.05 level. Results. The surfaces of 3D Active implants are monolithic with rounded pores in the form of wells of different diameters and depths; the upper layer of the Xpeed sample consists of closely adjacent to each other fragments of a rectangular or polygonal shape, in the form of tiles, leaving rectangular faces on the outside. On the surface of the 3D Active samples, in addition to oxygen and carbon, there was phosphorus – 5.04 wt%, as well as S, Ca, Na, Zr, Zn which weight percentage did not exceed 1 wt%. A significant difference in the elemental composition of Xpeed implants was the presence of chlorine 0.07 wt% and 0.93 wt%, silicon – 0.10 wt% and 0.14 wt%, aluminum 0.06 wt% and 0.23 wt%, respectively, with the latter has a significant advantage in these elements. Xpeed had an insignificant weight percentage of iron in its composition – 0.12 wt%. The assessment of cell adhesion to the surface of the samples on the first day of incubation demonstrated that the samples with the Xpeed and 3D Active surfaces did not have a statistically significant difference between them. Also, on the 7th day of incubation, the level of reduction of resazurin in Xpeed was lower, no significant difference was observed (p > 0.05). The clinical signs of bone tissue resorption were identified in 36.4 % of 3D Active implants and 60.0 % of Xpeed implants (p = 0.3); inflammation of the mucous membrane – in the areas of installation of 54.5 % of 3D Active implants. No signs of mucositis were detected around the Xpeed implants (p = 0.23). 9.1 % of 3D Active implants were “lost”; no cases of loss of Xpeed implants have been identified. The KSI of 3D Active – 64.0 ± 5.9 units, Xpeed – 65.1 ± 3.7 units. Conclusions. According to KSI indicators, titanium implants with Xpeed coating (65.1 ± 3.7 units) and 3D Active (64.0 ± 5.9 units) showed the same capabilities. Bone tissue resorption without signs of inflammation is more common around Xpeed-coated implants than 3D Active-coated implants. Clinical signs of inflammation are more frequent and more severe around implants with a 3D Active coating, which affected both the severity of the course of the first stage of implantation and its results. Xpeed-coated implants are more reliable than 3D Active: loss among 3D Active implants was 9.1 %, Xpeed – 0.0 %. Мета роботи – дослідження антизапальних властивостей поверхні комерційних дентальних імплантатів із різним методом обробки на прикладі перебігу першого етапу імплантації. Матеріали і методи. Використано дентальні імплантати з титану з обробкою поверхні 3D Active і Xpeed. Досліджено мікроструктуру поверхні та біосумісність зразків, корозію поверхні, здійснили елементний аналіз поверхні. Оцінили тяжкість перебігу періімплантиту та мукозиту за глибиною періімплантної кишені та кровотечі при зондуванні; визначили коефіцієнт стабільності імплантатів (КСІ). Для множинного порівняння вибірок використали медіанний тест (χ2), тест Краскела–Волліса (H), однофакторний дисперсійний аналіз (F). Різницю параметрів вважали статистично значущою на рівні p ≤ 0,05. Результати. Поверхня імплантатів 3D Active монолітна, з порами округлої форми – лунками різного діаметра та глибини; верхній шар зразка Xpeed складається з фрагментів прямокутної чи полігональної форми, що щільно прилягають один до одного, як черепиця, залишаючи назовні прямокутні грані. На поверхні зразків 3D Active, крім кисню та вуглецю, виявили фосфор (5,04 ваг%), а також S, Ca, Na, Zr, Zn (≤1,0 ваг%). Суттєва відмінність елементного складу імплантатів Xpeed – наявність хлору (0,07 ваг% проти 0,93 ваг%), силіцію (0,10 ваг% проти 0,14 ваг%), алюмінію (0,06 ваг% проти 0,23 ваг% відповідно), зі значною перевагою за вмістом цих елементів. Xpeed містив незначний ваговий відсоток заліза – 0,12 ваг%. Оцінювання адгезії клітин до поверхні зразків на першу добу інкубації показало, що зразки з поверхнею Xpeed і 3D...Keywords
This publication has 24 references indexed in Scilit:
- Bacterial Adhesion Strength on Titanium Surfaces Quantified by Atomic Force Microscopy: A Systematic ReviewAntibiotics, 2023
- Impact of bone-implant gap size on the interfacial osseointegration: an in vivo studyBMC Musculoskeletal Disorders, 2023
- Local and Systemic Antibiotics in Peri-Implantitis Management: An Umbrella ReviewAntibiotics, 2023
- Role of chitosan in titanium coatings. trends and new generations of coatingsFrontiers in Bioengineering and Biotechnology, 2022
- Transinusal Pathway Removal of an Impacted Third Molar with an Unusual Approach: A Case Report and a Systematic Review of the LiteratureAntibiotics, 2022
- Antimicrobial and Antibiofilm Coating of Dental Implants—Past and New PerspectivesAntibiotics, 2022
- It is all about peri‐implant tissue healthPeriodontology 2000, 2022
- Biocompatible and Biomaterials Application in Drug Delivery System in Oral CavityEvidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine, 2021
- The Role of Biomaterials and Biocompatible Materials in Implant-Supported Dental ProsthesisEvidence-Based Complementary and Alternative Medicine, 2021
- Peri-implantitis Update: Risk Indicators, Diagnosis, and TreatmentEuropean Journal of Dentistry, 2020