Accuracy Evaluation of Five Blood Glucose Monitoring Systems: The North American Comparator Trial
Open Access
- 1 September 2013
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SAGE Publications in Journal of Diabetes Science and Technology
- Vol. 7 (5) , 1294-1304
Abstract
This study evaluated differences in accuracy between the CONTOUR® NEXT EZ (EZ) blood glucose monitoring system (BGMS) and four other BGMSs [ACCU-CHEK® Aviva (ACAP), FreeStyle Freedom Lite® (FFL), ONE TOUCH® Ultra®2 (OTU2), and TRUEtrack® (TT)]. Up to three capillary blood samples (N = 393) were collected from 146 subjects with and without diabetes. One sample per subject was tested with fresh (natural) blood; the other samples were glycolyzed to lower blood glucose to <70 mg/dl. Meter results were compared with results from plasma from the same sample tested on a Yellow Springs Instruments (YSI) 2300 STAT Plus™ glucose analyzer. Blood glucose monitoring system accuracy was compared using mean absolute relative difference (MARD; from laboratory reference method results) and other analyses. Separate analyses on fresh (natural) samples only were conducted to determine potential effects of glycolysis on MARD values of systems utilizing glucose-oxidase-based test strip chemistry. Across the tested glucose range, the EZ had the lowest MARD of 4.7%; the ACAP, FFL, OTU2, and TT had MARD values of 6.3%, 18.3%, 23.4%, and 26.2%, respectively. For samples with glucose concentrations <70 mg/dl, the EZ had the lowest MARD (0.65%), compared with the ACAP (2.5%), FFL (18.3%), OTU2 (22.4%), and TT (33.2%) systems. The EZ had the lowest MARD across the tested glucose ranges when compared with four other BGMSs when all samples were analyzed as well as when natural samples only were analyzed.Keywords
This publication has 39 references indexed in Scilit:
- AbstractsJournal of Diabetes Science and Technology, 2013
- System Accuracy Evaluation of 43 Blood Glucose Monitoring Systems for Self-Monitoring of Blood Glucose according to DIN EN ISO 15197Journal of Diabetes Science and Technology, 2012
- Performance of a New Blood Glucose Monitoring System in the Hands of Intended UsersDiabetes Technology & Therapeutics, 2012
- Accuracy Evaluation of Five Blood Glucose Monitoring Systems Obtained from the Pharmacy: A European Multicenter Study with 453 SubjectsDiabetes Technology & Therapeutics, 2012
- Clinical assessment of the accuracy of blood glucose measurement devicesCurrent Medical Research and Opinion, 2012
- System Accuracy Evaluation of 27 Blood Glucose Monitoring Systems According to DIN EN ISO 15197Diabetes Technology & Therapeutics, 2010
- IntroductionDiabetes Care, 2010
- Accuracy and Precision of Four Value-Added Blood Glucose Meters: the Abbott Optium, the DDI Prodigy, the HDI True Track, and the HypoGuard Assure ProDiabetes Technology & Therapeutics, 2009
- Performance Evaluation of a New Blood Glucose Monitor That Requires No Coding: The OneTouch® Vita™ SystemJournal of Diabetes Science and Technology, 2008
- Self-Monitoring of Blood GlucoseDiabetes Care, 1994