16 Background: Preoperative MRI has been used to identify mammographically occult lesions and to determine extent of disease. However, the role of preoperative MRI in breast cancer remains controversial. We previously found that preoperative MRI does not increase total mastectomy (TM) rate. In this study we sought to identify a specific subgroup of patients in which preoperative MRI may be useful. Methods: In this IRB approved study, we conducted a retrospective review of 257 patients with breast cancer who underwent preoperative MRI from 2010 to 2012. We evaluated whether additional imaging and biopsies were recommended after MRI and whether it influenced the final surgical plan and decreased re-excision rate after partial mastectomy (PM). We collected data on several clinical factors and tested these for significant associations with both upgrading to TM and with the need for post-MRI imaging and biopsy using crosstab analysis and Fisher’s Exact test. Age as a continuous variable was also evaluated using binary logistic regression. Results: In our study cohort, 158 patients (62%) had additional imaging and 78 patients (30%) had additional biopsies recommended based on the MRI report. Of those biopsies prompted by MRI, 32 of them (39%) revealed cancer. The clinical significance, however, is subject to further study as only 3% of the 257 patients, eight upgraded to TM. We did not find any statistically significant differences in patients who were upgraded to TM by clinical factors such as age, menopausal status, mammographic breast density, ER/PR, HER2/neu status, or pathologic T stage; though there was a trend towards upgrade to TM in those who required additional imaging (p = 0.16). We found no clinical factors associated with the need for additional biopsies. Conclusions: We did not find a specific subgroup of patients in which preoperative MRI influenced management. Although preoperative MRI slightly increased the rate of TM, it does lead to numerous additional imaging studies and biopsies. Given these results, we are no longer using preoperative MRI routinely at our institution. Additional studies will be needed to determine strict indications for the use of MRI in the preoperative setting.