MCManjeet Chadha

Manjeet Chadha

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Manjeet Chadha has a total of 75 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • What puts physicians and patients discussing cancer screening on the same page?

    by Danielle Seiden, Maureen Bezuhly, Gina Aharanoff, Kelly Cassano, Michael P. Osborne, Manjeet Chadha, James Austin Talcott

    1552 Background: Shared decision making requires effective provider-patient communication. We studied concordance in recalled discussions and factors that affected it. Methods: In a cluster-randomized trial of educational supports for providers (MDs), we are enrolling an age-(30-89 years) and sex-stratified sample of 216 patients (PTs) who underwent a physical examination at 2 urban hospitals, 18 for each of 12 primary care MDs. Screening guideline formatting (colorcoding) and academic detailing were randomly assigned in a 2x2 design. Immediate post encounter surveys recorded PT and MD recall of screening discussions. Results: The first 174 participants were diverse (63% white) and highly educated (77% college degree). PTs and MDs differed in recall of screening discussions, and the differences varied by screening test. When MDs reported a colorectal cancer (CRC) screening discussion, 21% of PTs did not; 20% of MDs disagreed when PTs reported the discussion. The discrepancies were greater for prostate specific antigen (PSA) screening, 29% and 29%, respectively, but much less for mammograms (MAM), 8% and 5%, respectively. Recall of the MD recommendation also differed: 15% of PTs disagreed when their MD reported it, and 33% of MDs when their PT reported it. For PSA, disagreement was 26% and 33%, respectively, and for MAM, disagreement was 17% and 10%, respectively. Overall, agreement between all PTs and MDs on whether screening was recommended was fair for CRC, PSA and MAM: kappa = 0.33, 0.34 and 0.29, respectively. For PTs > 70 agreement was nonexistent on recalled CRC and PSA recommendations (kappa = -0.02 and -0.03, respectively) but preserved for MAM (kappa = 0.39). Sex did not affect CRC agreement. Recall concordance improved when SDM was recalled. For CRC, kappa rose from -0.12 to 0.52 if the MD recalled any MDM element. Conclusions: In a highly educated, diverse patient population, patients and physicians often disagreed on recalled cancer screening discussions. Discordance was greatest with PSA and least with MAM. Discordance was greater in older patients. If MDs recalled any shared decision making, agreement increased significantly. Communication varies by cancer screen, PT age and elements of shared decision making. Clinical trial information: NCT02430948.

  • Does shared decision making for PSA screening empower patients?

    by James Austin Talcott, Maureen Bezuhly, Gina Aharanoff, Jessica Herzstein, Michael P. Osborne, Manjeet Chadha

    E549 Background: Participant characteristics affect shared decision making. In a randomized trial of physician (MD) educational interventions to improve cancer screening guideline compliance, we studied patient (PT) and MD recall of discussions and how PT characteristics affected recall. Methods: In a cluster-randomized trial of educational supports for MDs, we are enrolling an age- (30-89 years) and sex-stratified sample of 216 PTs who underwent a physical examination at two urban hospitals, 18 for each of 12 primary care MDs. Screening guideline formatting (color-coding) and academic detailing were randomly assigned in a 2x2 design. Immediate post-encounter surveys recorded PT and MD recall of screening discussions. Results: Of the first 174 participants, 92 were men. PTs were diverse (69% white) and well educated (73% college degree). When MDs reported a prostate specific antigen (PSA) screening discussion, 32% of PTs did not, and 26% of MDs disagreed when PTs reported the discussion occurred. Further, when the MD reported recommending screening, 26% of PTs disagreed, and 33% of MDs disagreed when their patients reported a recommendation. Overall, agreement between all PTs and MDs on whether screening was recommended was fair (kappa = 0.29) but there was no agreement for PTs over 70 years (kappa = -0.03). PTs reported more elements of shared decision making than MDs (data not shown). When both PT and MD or the MD alone reported that all elements of shared medical decision making had occurred, agreement on whether screening was recommended improved (kappa = 0.54 and 0.45, respectively). When PTs disagreed with their MD, they more often reported recommending for screening not against (11 vs. 4). Conclusions: In a highly educated, diverse PT population, PTs and MDs surveyed immediately after their encounter often disagreed on whether PSA screening was discussed and recommended. Disagreement was worse with older PT age but improved when both PT and MD or the MD alone reported all shared decision making elements. Clinical trial information: NCT02430948.

  • The SSO/ASTRO Consensus on Breast Margins: Has it affected clinical practice?

    by Sarah P. Cate, Arielle Brooke Greenberg, Leah Bassin, Alyssa Gillego, Manjeet Chadha, Gina Aharonoff, Susan K. Boolbol

    148 Background: Adequate margin width remains a subject of much controversy in breast conserving surgery. The Society of Surgical Oncology (SSO) and the American Society for Radiation Oncology (ASTRO) presented a consensus statement on margins in December 2014. This guideline stated that re-excision is recommended only in cases where tumor is present on inked margin. In this study, we sought to determine the consensus statement’s impact on re-excision practices at our institution. We examined re-excision rates eleven months before the release and 17 months after the release of the statement. Methods: Patients included in this IRB approved study had a diagnosis of invasive breast carcinoma, underwent breast conserving surgery, and were treated with adjuvant radiotherapy. Patients with pure DCIS were excluded. Results: One hundred and two women treated from January to November 2013 were included in the pre-consensus group. One hundred and three women were treated from December 2013 to May 2015 in the post-consensus group. The women treated prior to the consensus statement (n = 102) and those women treated after the statement (n = 103) were equally matched in terms of patient age, hormone positivity, and tumor size. A close margin at our institution is defined as < 2mm from the tumor edge. There were 16/102 women prior to the consensus who had close margins and 32/103 women in the post-consensus group. Of these, 68.8% (11/16) underwent re-excision for close margins in the pre-consensus group compared to 3.1% (1/32) after the consensus statement was released (p value < 0.01). Conclusions: The rapid adoption of the SSO/ASTRO margin consensus statement at our institution, although not statistically significant, led to a decrease in the number of patients who underwent a re-excision for close margins. Women with a close surgical margin were less likely to undergo additional surgery for re-excision after the guidelines were released. In our institution, using a standard criterion for re-excision, the re-excision rate for close margins decreased from 68.8% to 3.1%. Further studies are needed to examine the impact of the consensus statement on re-excision practices in a larger group of patients.


  • Preoperative MRI: Much ado about nothing?

    by Sarah P. Cate, Pamela Li, John Rescigno, Manjeet Chadha, Alyssa Gillego, Susan K. Boolbol

    16 Background: Preoperative MRI has been used to identify mammographically occult lesions and to determine extent of disease. However, the role of preoperative MRI in breast cancer remains controversial. We previously found that preoperative MRI does not increase total mastectomy (TM) rate. In this study we sought to identify a specific subgroup of patients in which preoperative MRI may be useful. Methods: In this IRB approved study, we conducted a retrospective review of 257 patients with breast cancer who underwent preoperative MRI from 2010 to 2012. We evaluated whether additional imaging and biopsies were recommended after MRI and whether it influenced the final surgical plan and decreased re-excision rate after partial mastectomy (PM). We collected data on several clinical factors and tested these for significant associations with both upgrading to TM and with the need for post-MRI imaging and biopsy using crosstab analysis and Fisher’s Exact test. Age as a continuous variable was also evaluated using binary logistic regression. Results: In our study cohort, 158 patients (62%) had additional imaging and 78 patients (30%) had additional biopsies recommended based on the MRI report. Of those biopsies prompted by MRI, 32 of them (39%) revealed cancer. The clinical significance, however, is subject to further study as only 3% of the 257 patients, eight upgraded to TM. We did not find any statistically significant differences in patients who were upgraded to TM by clinical factors such as age, menopausal status, mammographic breast density, ER/PR, HER2/neu status, or pathologic T stage; though there was a trend towards upgrade to TM in those who required additional imaging (p = 0.16). We found no clinical factors associated with the need for additional biopsies. Conclusions: We did not find a specific subgroup of patients in which preoperative MRI influenced management. Although preoperative MRI slightly increased the rate of TM, it does lead to numerous additional imaging studies and biopsies. Given these results, we are no longer using preoperative MRI routinely at our institution. Additional studies will be needed to determine strict indications for the use of MRI in the preoperative setting.

  • Postsurgical Treatment of Early-stage Breast Cancer With Electronic Brachytherapy

    by Rakesh R. Patel, Peter D. Beitsch, Timothy D. Nichols, John D. Lorenzetti, James C. Wurzer, James C. Tucker, George W. Nunn, Susan J. Laduzinsky, Morris A. Kugler, Dwelvin L. Simmons, et al.

    OBJECTIVES: This multicenter registry followed up patients with early-stage breast cancer treated with breast-conserving surgery and electronic brachytherapy (EBT). This report provides 1- and 2-year updates to the initial publication. METHODS: Patients were of age 50 years or more with invasive carcinoma or ductal carcinoma in situ, tumor size RESULTS: Of the 69 patients enrolled, 62 were evaluated at 1 year and 20 patients at 2 years after treatment. At 1 year, 28 (45.2%) patients reported adverse events that were possibly, probably, or definitely related to treatment. Most (90%) were grade 1: manageable and typical of radiation therapy. Four events were grade 2: induration/firmness (2), field contracture (1), and seroma (1). One event was grade 3: a draining fistula at the lumpectomy site due to residual effects of a breast infection at 1 month. No recurrences have been reported. Cosmetic ratings were excellent or good in 93.4% of patients at 1 year. Most patients (69%) were energetic most or all of the time. Most patients (69% to 98%) were not affected by individual symptoms of breast disease at 1 year. Generally patients who had an adverse event did not report the corresponding symptom on the quality-of-life questionnaire. CONCLUSIONS: This registry followed up patients with early-stage breast cancer at 1 and 2 years after breast-conserving surgery and EBT. No recurrences have been reported, and adverse effects were acceptable


  • How accurately can clinicians predict the Oncotype DX DCIS score?

    by Sarah Patricia Cate, Alyssa Gillego, Manjeet Chadha, John Rescigno, Paul R. Gliedman, Agnes Radzio, Susan K. Boolbol

    90 Background: The Oncoype DX DCIS Score was developed to assess the risk of recurrence for ductal carcinoma in situ, as well as an invasive breast cancer. It is a 12 gene assay performed on an individual patient’s tumor and is used to predict the ten year local recurrence risk of an ipsilateral breast event, which can be either an invasive breast cancer or ductal carcinoma in situ. It is also used to predict the 10 year risk of an invasive cancer. The DCIS Score was clinically validated using patients from ECOG 5194. The purpose of this study was to investigate how often clinicians, (medical oncologists, breast surgical oncologists, and radiation oncologists) can predict the DCIS Score. Methods: In this IRB approved study, we retrospectively reviewed the charts of 27 patients at our institution who underwent unilateral or bilateral partial mastectomy for DCIS from April 2012 to February 2013 and who had their pathology specimens submitted for DCIS Scores. Patient age range was 40-79 years old, with a mean of 56.8. All patients underwent consultation with radiation oncology. A chart was compiled to include the patient’s age and tumor histology. This included grade of DCIS, extent of DCIS, presence of necrosis, margin width, and hormone receptors. We then removed all identifying factors from the patients’ data, and surveyed our radiation oncologists, medical oncologists, and breast surgical oncologists on whether patients had a low, intermediate, or high DCIS Score. Results: Breast surgical oncologists accurately predicted the DCIS score 49% of the time. Medical oncologists predicted the DCIS score 35% of the time, while radiation oncologists were accurate 51% of the time. Conclusions: This study demonstrates the difficulty in predicting the DCIS Score. The information obtained from the DCIS Score is specific to the genetic behavior of each individual tumor, whereas traditional methods of predicting risk of recurrence and benefit of radiation are based on standard pathologic and clinical criteria. Further studies on larger patient populations need to be performed prior to wide scale acceptance of this genomic test. [Table: see text]

  • Does the Oncotype DCIS score impact treatment decisions?

    by Sarah Patricia Cate, Alyssa Gillego, Manjeet Chadha, John Rescigno, Paul R. Gliedman, Ilana Kats, Susan K. Boolbol

    91 Background: The Oncotype Dx DCIS Score has been developed and validated for risk recurrence in ductal carcinoma in situ. It is a 12 gene assay performed on an individual patient’s tumor. The results give information about the 10 year risk of any in-breast event and the 10 year risk of an invasive breast cancer. The clinical validation study was based on patients enrolled in ECOG 5194. The purpose of our study was to evaluate the impact of the DCIS Score on recommendations for adjuvant radiation therapy. Methods: In this IRB approved study, 27 patients at our institution underwent evaluation with the DCIS Score from April 2012 to February 2013. All patients had specimens submitted for DCIS Scores. 14 patients had margins of 3 mm or greater. 12 patients had margins of 1 mm to 2.5 mm, and 1 patient had margins that were less than 1 mm from the DCIS. The mean age was 56.8 years, with a range of 40-79 years old. The DCIS Score is reported on a scale of 0-100. All patients underwent consultation with radiation oncology. The radiation oncologists formulated their preliminary recommendation prior to reviewing the patients’ DCIS Scores. The final recommendation for radiation treatment was rendered after reviewing the DCIS Score. We then compared the pre-DCIS Score and post-DCIS score treatment recommendations. Results: 21 patients (78%) were advised to have adjuvant radiation therapy. 6 patients (22%) were advised not to undergo adjuvant radiation based on their clinical and pathologic features. Although the DCIS Score did not change treatment recommendations for any patient in this study group, it did confirm initial treatment recommendations. For the patients who were advised not to have radiation, their DCIS Scores were 0-31. Conclusions: The DCIS Score is a validated tool to assess the local risk of recurrence for ductal carcinoma in situ. In our study population, the results of the DCIS Score did not alter treatment in any patient. It is important to note that in the 6 patients who were advised not to have radiation, the low DCIS Score confirmed the radiation oncologist’s perceived low risk of recurrence. In order to increase confidence in results of the DCIS Score, further studies need to be performed.

  • Early-Stage Breast Cancer Treated With 3-Week Accelerated Whole-Breast Radiation Therapy and Concomitant Boost

    by Manjeet Chadha, Rudolph Woode, Jussi Sillanpaa, David Lucido, Susan K. Boolbol, Laurie Kirstein, Michael P. Osborne, Sheldon Feldman, Louis B. Harrison