Family lawyers on cohabitation and judge-made law
Author:
- 1 October 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by University of Toronto Press Inc. (UTPress) in University of Toronto Law Journal
- Vol. 74 (4) , 408-440
Abstract
This article advances debates on the limits of judge-made law to palliate legislative failure to respond to changing practice. Canadian judges have adjusted the general private law to address the situation of unmarried cohabitants. In Kerr v Baranow, the Supreme Court of Canada continued its adaptation of unjust enrichment to this end. The article reports on the first empirical inquiry into how the judgment is operating, including outside the courtroom. Interviews with family lawyers in Quebec show that bringing claims under the adapted doctrine is complex and costly. Variable and unpredictable outcomes impede fair and efficient private ordering. Cohabitation agreements do not seem a satisfactory solution. The study highlights shortcomings in the leading Canadian judgment, which recognizes some cohabiting couples as partnerships but stops short of presuming an equal sharing of gains during the union. But, since the participating lawyers pointed to factors that would reduce the efficacy of reform by judges or by legislatures, the study does not yield a broad preference for legislative reform over judicial reform.Keywords
This publication has 19 references indexed in Scilit:
- Crafting Prefigurative Law in Turbulent Times: Decertification, DIY Law Reform, and the Dilemmas of Feminist PrototypingFeminist Legal Studies, 2023
- Analyzing the law qualitativelyQualitative Research Journal, 2022
- Differences in a Minor Archive: Feminist Activists and Scholars on CohabitationThe American Journal of Comparative Law, 2022
- Judging in Marriage’s ShadowFeminist Legal Studies, 2018
- The impact of award uncertainty on settlement negotiationsExperimental Economics, 2017
- Thematic analysisThe Journal of Positive Psychology, 2016
- Les couples non-mariés ont-ils des droits ? Comment juristes, intellectuels et journalistes ont construit l’affaire Éric c LolaCanadian Journal of Law and Society / Revue Canadienne Droit et Société, 2015
- When legal rights are not a reality: do individuals know their rights and how can we tell?Journal of Social Welfare and Family Law, 2013
- COHABITANTS IN PRIVATE LAW: TRUST, FRUSTRATION AND UNJUST ENRICHMENT IN ENGLAND, GERMANY AND CANADAInternational and Comparative Law Quarterly, 2013
- Cohabitants, Property and the Law: A Study of InjusticeThe Modern Law Review, 2008