RLRobert Leckey

Robert Leckey

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Robert Leckey has a total of 25 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Parental union in Quebec: a model for recognizing cohabitants?

    by Robert Leckey

    This paper introduces an international readership to an innovative policy response to cohabitation. Under a law passed in 2024 by the Canadian province of Quebec, unmarried cohabitants who become parents of the same child will automatically enter a ‘parental union.’ The legislature intended parental union to protect children without marrying adults by force. This new relationship form entails some of marriage’s effects, although it does not change the spouses’ civil status. The paper draws out the design choices underlying this intriguing middle ground between Quebec’s robust marriage regime and its laissez-faire approach to cohabitation. Although the parental union calls for limited sharing and contemplates a remedy for unjust enrichment between the spouses, it has no measures founded in solidarity or redressing need. It does not apply to cohabitants whose common children were born before the end of June 2025. Nor does this reform do anything for the many cohabitants who are not legal parents to the same child. Readers will judge the extent to which this reform merits imitation for the balance it strikes between protection of the vulnerable, compensation for contributions, and autonomy.


  • Family lawyers on cohabitation and judge-made law

    by Robert Leckey

    This article advances debates on the limits of judge-made law to palliate legislative failure to respond to changing practice. Canadian judges have adjusted the general private law to address the situation of unmarried cohabitants. In Kerr v Baranow, the Supreme Court of Canada continued its adaptation of unjust enrichment to this end. The article reports on the first empirical inquiry into how the judgment is operating, including outside the courtroom. Interviews with family lawyers in Quebec show that bringing claims under the adapted doctrine is complex and costly. Variable and unpredictable outcomes impede fair and efficient private ordering. Cohabitation agreements do not seem a satisfactory solution. The study highlights shortcomings in the leading Canadian judgment, which recognizes some cohabiting couples as partnerships but stops short of presuming an equal sharing of gains during the union. But, since the participating lawyers pointed to factors that would reduce the efficacy of reform by judges or by legislatures, the study does not yield a broad preference for legislative reform over judicial reform.

  • Open Access

    Debates on the Amendment of the Charter of Human Rights and Freedoms (La modification de la Charte des droits et libertés de la personne en débats)

    by Oscar Bourgeois, Robert Leckey

    English Via a qualitative analysis of the National Assembly of Québec’s Hansard, this text presents the parliamentary conversation concerning amendment of the Charter of Human Rights and Freedoms, from its enactment in 1975 to 2022. Lawmakers amended this quasi-constitutional instrument many times with the support of all parliamentary parties. Indeed, MNAs long followed a practice of amending the Charter consensually, increasing its legitimacy and moral authority. As they did not feel bound by this practice, however, it did not amount to a constitutional convention. In 2019 and 2022, amendments made in bills that were substantially rejected by the opposition interrupted this consensual practice. The Charter’s status as a collective endeavour of Quebec’s elected representatives is in jeopardy as the exercise of majority power supplants the search for a consensus. French Ce texte présente une analyse qualitative du Journal des débats. Il rend compte de la conversation parlementaire au sujet de la modification de la Charte des droits et libertés de la personne, de sa création en 1975 jusqu’en 2022. Les élus ont apporté de nombreuses modifications à cet instrument quasi constitutionnel avec l’appui de tous les bancs de l’Assemblée nationale. Les députés ont longtemps souscrit à la pratique de modification par consensus, conférant à la Charte une légitimité et une autorité morale accrues. Ils ne se sentaient cependant pas liés par cette pratique, qui ne relève donc pas d’une convention constitutionnelle. En 2019 et 2022, l’adoption de modifications importantes dans le cadre de lois largement rejetées par l’opposition interrompt la pratique consensuelle. Le statut de la Charte comme projet collectif des élus québécois est en jeu dès lors que l’exercice du pouvoir de la majorité supplante la recherche d’un consensus.

  • Differences in a Minor Archive: Feminist Activists and Scholars on Cohabitation

    by Robert Leckey

    In an act of minor comparativism, this Article studies feminist writings on unmarried cohabitation from Canada’s jurisdictions of the common law and civil law. It examines activist texts and legal scholarship for and against regulating cohabitants. Reading the English-language literature from the common law provinces and the French-language literature from Quebec, it reports differences in substance, in emphasis, and in what is common sense. Differing approaches to ideas of freedom, autonomy, and choice run throughout. The Quebec literature shows disagreement between activists and scholars. Over time, that literature has moved towards the view in the common law literature. Lessons for comparatists relate to varieties of difference, the definition of legal sources, the asymmetrical role that legal traditions play in majority and minority contexts, and the limits of law in explaining differences. Given the unreliability of initial observations of difference and sameness, comparatists should read a broad range of sources with care and humility.


  • The notwithstanding clause: Legislatures, courts, and the electorate

    by Robert Leckey, Eric Mendelsohn

    This article interprets the notwithstanding clause in section 33 of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. When a legislature activates the notwithstanding clause, subsection 33(2) temporarily ensures a protected law’s ‘operation’ by preventing it from being ‘inconsistent’ with the Constitution of Canada in the sense of the supremacy clause, thereby precluding judicial remedies such as striking down. Construed in the light of its components (some never considered by the Supreme Court of Canada) and other constitutional features, the notwithstanding clause does not make rights irrelevant or strip them of their legal character. Nor does it confide the assessment of trade-offs about rights to the legislature alone. Instead, subsection 33(3) indicates a framework for such assessments in which the voting public plays a crucial evaluative role. The courts, as interpreters and guardians of the Constitution, can, and in some circumstances should, support the public’s constitutional role by declaring the extent to which a protected law unjustifiably limits Charter rights. The public’s ability to take such declarations into account in evaluating rights trade-offs would advance the democratic purpose of subsection 33(3), a purpose that underpins our constitutional framework more broadly.


  • Top Cited Papers
    Open Access

    Indigenous parents and child welfare: Mistrust, epistemic injustice, and training

    by Robert Leckey, Raphael Schmieder-Gropen, Chukwubuikem Nnebe, Miriam Clouthier

    The settler state's taking of Indigenous children into care disrupts their communities and continues destructive, assimilationist policies. This article presents the perceptions of lawyers, social workers and judges of how Indigenous parents experience child welfare in Quebec. Our participants characterized those experiences negatively. Barriers of language and culture as well as mistrust impede meaningful participation. Parents experience epistemic injustice, wronged in their capacity as knowers. Mistrust also hampers efforts to include Indigenous workers in the system. Emphasizing state workers’ ignorance of Indigenous family practices and the harms of settler colonialism, participants called for greater training. But critical literature on professional education signals the limits of such training to change institutions. Our findings reinforce the jurisdictional calls away from improving the system towards empowering Indigenous peoples to run services of child welfare. The patterns detected and theoretical resources used are relevant to researchers of other institutions that interact with vulnerable populations.